McCool Insurance Agency
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
McCool Insurance Agency
Met with Melinda to discuss changing insurance. She compared my current policy to another company and not only presented better coverage but lowered the cost of my policy. Transition to the new company was flawless, she did everything. Melinda has contacted me after the meeting to insure I was satisfied with her service.

Melinda with McCool insurance agency is the best! I called in a couple weeks ago with some questions and concerns about flood and homeowners insurance. She was patient and explained everything to me step by step. And guess what! I made the switch. Thanks again for all your help and I look forward to doing business with you for years to come.
Services
As independent agents, we have established long-term, solid relationships with some of the top national and regional carriers in the industry. Our experienced staff will be able to provide comprehensive, expert insurance solutions and service. For you, our client, this provides competitive pricing, coverage options, and peace of mind that the company providing your insurance coverage meets our standards.
If you've had a positive experience with our agency, one of the best things you can do as a client of our agency is to leave us a genuine online review. We would be grateful if you took a few seconds to do this! It couldn't be easier, and it helps us tremendously in terms of other people finding our agency online.
Voices of Hope, Inc. is a 501(c)3 non-profit organization made of people in recovery, family members and allies who support recovery throughout Maryland, but primarily in Cecil and Harford Counties. Our mission is to advocate for behavioral health disorder prevention, intervention, treatment and recovery resources, eliminate the stigma of addiction through outreach events and education, and support all pathways of recovery.
The benefit of working with an independent agency like us, is that we can compare your policies with multiple companies, saving you time, aggravation, and money. To get the quote process started, please complete the fields below. We will reach out to you to gather more information to complete your quotes and provide you with a comparison.
Reviews (11)
Meghan Steimer
Meghan Steimer
Feb 19, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Amazing experience. Ask for Leta she goes above and beyond!
Caitlin Molisani
Caitlin Molisani
Oct 23, 2020
Report
Ask for Melinda! I had questions about policy info and asked so many questions, I’m pretty sure her ear about fell off. Highly recommend. Very professional and everyone was super nice!
Rick Haddox
Rick Haddox
Jul 27, 2020
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Met with Melinda to discuss changing insurance. She compared my current policy to another company and not only presented better coverage but lowered the cost of my policy. Transition to the new company was flawless, she did everything. Melinda has contacted me after the meeting to insure I was satisfied with her service.
Lorenzo Hendricks
Lorenzo Hendricks
Jul 02, 2020
Report
Melinda with McCool insurance agency is the best!! I called in a couple weeks ago with some questions and concerns about flood and homeowners insurance. She was patient and explained everything to me step by step. And guess what!!! I made the switch. Thanks again for all your help and I look forward to doing business with you for years to come.
Linda Lipscomb
Linda Lipscomb
Jul 01, 2020
Report
Without a doubt, McCool Agency and Melinda Nunley are the best in the business! Whether just answering a question or helping you navigate through all the things to do after your car has been totaled, I know I can count on them. They are always responsive, friendly, knowledgeable, and personable. Been a client for a long time and never disappointed.
Caity Steven
Caity Steven
Jun 16, 2020
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness
Melinda is one of the best! I can’t thank her enough with the help she provided after a mixup over my husband’s vehicle. She handled it in a calm and professional manner, definitely helped me feel better! My parents have been lifelong members and now my husband and I are too. I can’t recommend McCool enough.
Charles Crafton
Charles Crafton
Jun 06, 2020
Report
Positive: Value
Great overall customer service! Melinda was a pleasure to speak with and helped out so much. I would definitely recommend McCool Insurance to everyone looking for good rates on their insurance!
Bill Wentz
Bill Wentz
May 22, 2020
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
I just recently started a business and the process was all new to me. Dorothy was such a pleasure to work with. She was very thorough and patient with me and made this process seamless. It really makes a difference when you deal with a company that cares for their customers. I highly recommend!!!
Bill Fisher
Bill Fisher
May 10, 2020
Report
Just to be clear, I tend to ask a lot of questions and associated "what ifs". Melinda was very helpful in clearly explaining the details of my auto and homeowners' policies. I wanted to better understand my coverage as my personal situation changed. She was very detailed (I like that) and helpful in adjusting my coverage to fit my present situation. Thank you! Bill
Darell Hagerman
Darell Hagerman
Aug 17, 2019
Report
Christy Lewis and Lisa Evans were both incredibly helpful and very professional while helping me navigate the challenging claims process. Christy kept me informed and fought for our best interest. Her tireless effort is greatly appreciated.
Mark A.
Mark A.
Jul 15, 2017
Report
Terrible service. Did not allow for good choices to even compare with Geico prices even though they are an independent broker. Did not cancel insurance as requested which caused a double charge for my daughter's new six-month term.