Otterstedt Insurance Agency
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Otterstedt Insurance Agency
We don't just sell you a policy. Insurance, like people, come in different shapes and sizes and we are here to help you personalize your insurance needs. Choose an insurance partner that makes your protection and profitability their main priority. As you prepare to change your wardrobe from summer swimsuits and sandals to turtleneck sweaters and boots for the fall season, don't forget your car and home.

Fall brings beautiful foliage along with its shorter daylight, light rain, and cooler weather. For this reason, it's always advisable to be prepared well in advance. Excellent insurance company, Joseph Nasello has been my agent for over 30 years, would not have anyone else. He is there for me when I have any concerns.
Services
100 years of history-and 1000s of satisfied clients to show for it. Since1919, when Fred H. Otterstedt founded the company, we've had a special tie to the families, individuals and businesses we serve. The Parisi Family has continued that tradition for over 60 years now.

Joseph Parisi Sr., Lucille Parisi, and their son, Joseph Parisi, Jr. have led Otterstedt to become one of the tri-state area's leading insurance agencies, while maintaining the personal focus we began with.We're good folks with high I.Q.s (that's Insurance Quotients.) The experience and passion of every Otterstedt professional has given our clients incredible insights into their current and future insurance needs over the years.
As part of our goal to provide you with prompt and accurate service, whether you need help paying your bill, filing a claim, or requesting a certificate of insurance or auto ID card, we have provided this specific area for your use. If you are a Traveler's Personal Insurance client please dial this number for immediate assistance and someone will be able to help: 844-489-9138.
Otterstedt Insurance Agency has been serving the insurance needs of the people who call New Jersey home since 1919. During that time we've worked hard to earn your trust as an ethical insurance company that works with you when the time comes to choose your insurance coverage as well as when the time comes to file a claim.
Our people are smart and they're available to help. If you ever have to file a claim, and we hope you never do, you'll find yourself in the hands of experts who are working hard to quickly resolve your situation in your best interests. It's one of the many reasons why we were recently recognized as one of the Top 50 Insurance Agencies in the country.
A tailored approach to one of the most personalized forms of insurance. No two homes are exactly alike. And the possessions that make it a home are always unique. Making sure you're adequately protected if your property is damaged or if someone is injured on it requires the thoughtfulness and expertise of an Otterstedt representative.
Reviews (6)
Andria J. Youmans
Andria J. Youmans
Apr 09, 2021
Report
My agent, Darin Maund, is the BEST. I can always count on him finding me excellent coverage at the best rates. Otterstedt goes above and beyond for their clients!
Anthony Rinaldi
Anthony Rinaldi
Apr 08, 2021
Report
Excellent service for contractors. Ask for Bryan H. He helped us save money and get better coverage. Getting COI's fast from their team too is a major plus.
Mark D. Antonucci
Mark D. Antonucci
May 03, 2018
Report
It has always been a pleasure dealing with everyone at Otterstedt. They have always been very helpful, informative and professional.
Laura Kozak
Laura Kozak
Apr 09, 2018
Report
I had no problems getting my car repaired, and the agents are very nice to deal with. I highly recommend this company to all of my friends!
Imelda Bruce Sobiloff
Imelda Bruce Sobiloff
Mar 29, 2018
Report
Otterstedt is a great agency. Our agent Tracy is professional, friendly and always helpful.
Christine A.
Christine A.
Nov 05, 2015
Report
If you want amazing service and unbeatable prices then Otterstedt Insurance is the company for you! Florence and Marissa handle our business insurance and they are lovely to deal with and make everything so easy for us . They are truly and asset :)
We are very lucky to find an honest and reliable company ! All the best, Christine