Mills Catering

Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Value
Mills Catering was willing to assist us at our fine home on short notice- great food and a nice bar service. Excellent service all the way around. Thank you!

Matt was fantastic to work with, we communicated mostly by email and he was able to execute the menu we had chosen so well. The chicken and waffle skewers were a huge hit as were the mini beef tenderloin sliders and beef wellington. Also something to repeat were the stuffed mushrooms. It earned rave reviews at the party and people kept coming back to munch...thank you!

Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Mills Catering did an outstanding job for our daughter's wedding (115 guests). The food was excellent and the serving staff did a superb job before, during, and after the reception. Highly recommend! Thanks Jessie and Nancy for all your hard work!

This is one of the most consistently amazing caterers in Indy! The food and service are unmatched. Recently I attended an event where they created the most delicious gluten-free and vegetarian meal and it was by far the best catered meal I've ever had at any event in any city. Incredibly well-done cauliflower steak with creamy risotto and lavender roasted carrots ... usually vegetarians can be left with kind of mediocre meals at events and add a gluten allergy to it and the meal is almost always underwhelming. The care and thought that went into creating this meal was like nothing I've

My husband Andy and I chose Mills Catering for our wedding in September of 2021. We had growing concerns while vendor shopping because all of the rescheduled events from 2020 meant that many vendors' calendars were already filling up for 2021. We therefore realized that it would be best to act quickly and choose our vendors without prevaricating. Luckily, that was supremely easy in the case of Mills Catering. They were the only vendor we interviewed, and the only one that we needed to.
Everything about our experience with Mills was simply amazing. The food at our wedding was just as delicious

Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Mills Catering made our company picnic the best!!! The food was fresh and flavorful! Everyone was happy with their food, especially my bosses! Thank you!!!!

Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Absolutely loved the food! My wedding guests were amazed by the amount of food and quality! I highly recommend using Mills Catering for any occasion!

I had to cancel a wedding in MA and opted to have it out here in Indy at Lauren Hall a week later. So with only a week's time, Jesse and the staff at Mills Catering did an outstanding job for the wedding. We went with the 6oz Filet Mignon and Maple-Mustard Glazed Chicken as our meat options and a Vegetable Lasagna for the vegetarian. I got nothing but rave reviews on the food from everyone. They put everything together from the linens and china to the bar and cocktail tables. Also the staff was very professional and served appetizers throughout the night and cleaned up everything nicely. I would

Catered our Enployee Appreation lunch. The food itself looked really good and well presented, I had an Asian wrap. It had no taste at all, the pasta salad was ok.
It was free for me although I only ate 1 Bite

With the current circumstances, we had all sorts of changes occur with our catering. From numbers dropping rapidly, switching from buffet to plated, and seating charts changing constantly, our catering needs were much different in the end than we originally discussed. Jessie and his team were flexible, understanding, and professional at all times. Everything was delicious and the staff was more than courteous.

Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
I've had Mills Catering on several occasions. The first thing that got me were the appetizers. Really well-selected and presented. MC introduced me to Medjool dates (filled with cheese) - they were so good. Every meal has been so satisfying - a highlight of the event. Highly recommend Matt and his expert crew.

I worked primarily with Jessie throughout our wedding planning, and the whole time he was consistently available and attentive. He offered up fun and interesting ideas and seemed genuinely invested in making our wedding a success. I appreciate everything he and the other staff at Mills did to remain flexible and accommodating. On the day of the wedding, everything went off without a hitch; the food was great. I would recommend Mills to anyone looking for a solid caterer with interesting selections at a very reasonable price.

Mills Catering did a superb job at our park anniversary celebration. The food was great and plentiful. The two ladies that catered that day were early, extremely nice, efficient and customer service oriented...Any Event's Dream Team! Most of our club members went back for seconds and raved about the food. I highly recommend hiring this catering company for your event! The only thing that I would change about that day is the fact that we did not have a cash tip for the staff. We added it later but they deserved to be tipped on the spot!

Matt and his staff just wrapped up our daughter's wedding on Father's Day. The bride and groom were a little behind schedule due to a shower (they were in an open classic convertible and had to duck for cover until the shower passed). That didn't phase Matt and his crew. The meal was hot and delicious. The food was as great as our tasting (and everyone knows that small batch can vary quite a bit). Finally, the staff were extremely helpful and courteous. I loved that they found and assisted our senior guests through the buffet line. In all business transactions, Matt was easygoing

Matt and his staff did a top notch job for our wedding at Laurel Hall! They really took charge of all the food, drink, and table setup, making the catering part of our wedding planning much easier. We planned this wedding from Arizona, so communication and flexibility were vital! Given how busy these guys are, we really felt well taken care of and never felt like we were forgotten in the mix. The food that they make is phenomenal and our guests couldn't stop talking about how great everything was! They really make sure that everybody leaves full, and they were so accommodating to our requests

We were seeking a caterer for our wedding rehearsal dinner, and Mills Catering was suggested to us by our photographer. Their group caters some artsy/First Friday type events, and she said that they were great.

We weren't sure if we were the type of business they usually did, but after a call, they were perfectly happy to work with us. We saw some sample menus, but none of them really went with the backyard BBQ theme we were hoping for. When we mentioned this, Jessie (the main gentleman we worked with) put together a fabulous menu that fit with what we're looking for. Then (and we were

First, I should say that I joined Yelp primarily to give an excellent review for Mills Catering. I use Yelp on a regular basis, but this is the first time that I have felt called to give props to a truly amazing company.

We recently hired Mills Catering for our wedding reception. From my first email response from Matt Mills until we settled our final bill, we were thoroughly impressed with the quality of Mills' cuisine and customer service. I heard about Mills through one of my closest friends, who had only good things to say about bout Mills' catering at her wedding reception. My