James Insurance Agency
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Our Agency strives to provide great insurance products at a price you can afford, all while giving you the best level of service around! We would love the opportunity to live up to our motto-Customer service is our specialty. However, if you would prefer to be actively involved in managing your policies, our companies offer the ability for you to create a customer account which will allow you to communicate and manage your account online.

Give us a chance to earn your business. Call or email today and let us shop all of our insurance markets for the coverage and a payment plan that fits your needs. Let us show you what we can do! To get a quote, just give us a quick call at (812) 849-5479 or email us your phone number with a day and time that you would like for us to call you.
Services
George, who was a Prudential agent at the time, had owned the building and operated it as a Prudential Insurance office since 1986. He retired from Prudential in 2001 and joined Michael as a partner at James Insurance until retiring from the insurance business in 2008.

We remain as eager today as we were when we first opened our doors to welcome you as a customer and show you the many advantages of trusting your insurance needs to a family owned, independent insurance agency.Thank you for allowing us to serve you!
Stop in and meet our Team. We remain as eager today as we were when we first opened our doors to welcome you as a customer and show you the many advantages of trusting your insurance needs to a family owned, independent insurance agency. Thank you for allowing us to serve you! Michael is a 1987 graduate of Mitchell High School and a 6 year US Navy veteran.
Reviews (9)
Joey W.
Joey W.
Jul 01, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Overpaid by 20 bucks an I didnt realize as I was leaven they come out an gave me my 20 back. that's awesome. Great home town people.
April Sims-Clark
April Sims-Clark
Feb 06, 2021
Report
I have been doing business with James Agency in Mitchell for some time now. I am extremely satisfied with the service and the responsiveness I receive there. Pam is always there to answer questions or requests and everything is done in a timely manner. I can’t say enough about the great job they do and the customer service they provide!
Russell Howe
Russell Howe
Dec 30, 2020
Report
I have had my insurance here since I was 17. Never had any issues! great price, kind people. 10/10
Krista Bridwell
Krista Bridwell
Nov 26, 2020
Report
Mike and Pam and the staff are great and their service is always so helpful and friendly! They always follow-up with me or even send me reminders to keep me updated! Thanks for doing such a great job for me!
Nicole
Nicole
Oct 17, 2020
Report
Friendly service, such good prices also. I can't say enough good about them! Highly reccomend for ur insurance needs!!👍🙂
Desiree Lake
Desiree Lake
Oct 06, 2020
Report
We have been with James Insurance for 9/10 years. We highly recommend them. Great service, friendly and great rates! I love having a local agent that can answer all of questions and takes care of us. Great places still exist!
Dottie Troutman
Dottie Troutman
Sep 29, 2020
Report
They treat you like a good friend. Helping you with your insurance needs.
Tygr Northup
Tygr Northup
Oct 19, 2019
Report
We have used James for years, couldn't ask for better or more affordable!
Sheetz Sheetz
Sheetz Sheetz
Oct 09, 2019
Report
Love the small town hospitality. Michael finds low rates that I can afford and a payment day that works for me.