McGee Jewelers
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
McGee Jewelers
Providing unsurpassed customer service and high-quality fine jewelry has been the mission of McGee & Co. since we opened our doors in 1988. As a family-owned and operated business, we value the relationships built with our clients as we participate in some of the most memorable events of their lives.

From bridal jewelry sales and insurance appraisals to custom design and repairs, we are a full-service jewelry store. Our showroom features an extensive collection of fine jewelry and watches. If you don't see what you're looking for, we can get it or have it made by our award-winning custom designer.
Services
We can make anything your heart desires! Our CAD/CAM system gives us the power to precisely create or customize the perfect pieces for you. We can build from scratch or take a current style and add special touches for a unique item you are sure to cherish. With over 30 years of experience, our on-site jeweler can complete the vast majority of repairs right here, saving you time and money.
You've popped the question to your special someone, and now they're your soon-to-be partner for life! Now's the time to pick out wedding rings. If you and your partner are among the 42% of women and about 20% of men that consider a 12-18 month engagement an ideal. The tradition of offering the fiancee an engagement ring began with Maximilian of Austria back in 1477.
Reviews (25)
Jason McClendon
Jason McClendon
Dec 27, 2021
Report
Wonderful selection with experienced staff, choosing the perfect piece for you or loved ones is guaranteed! They are also happy to customize a piece with stones you already have!
Rick Deez
Rick Deez
Nov 05, 2021
Report
I recently started shopping for an anniversary ring for my wife. McGee’s prices and service couldn’t compare to any other store I shopped. I have them a few clues and they found me many options under the budget I gave them. Zero pressure sale. Found exactly what I needed under budget. So glad I found them.
Alexa Polk
Alexa Polk
Oct 06, 2021
Report
I absolutely LOVE the team here! I've come in with several projects, and they always take their time helping me create exactly what I want while being understanding of my budget. I live further away now, but I will 100% be making the trip to them for all of my future needs. Couldn't recommend more!
J. Ellen Franklin
J. Ellen Franklin
Oct 05, 2021
Report
Good service, cleaned old ring I had resized, it looked new! Pleasant staff.
Alex D.
Alex D.
Jul 16, 2021
Report
Very friendly and helpful staff had my watch battery fixed in mins and only charged $10
Daniel Ryan
Daniel Ryan
Jun 18, 2021
Report
Great staff, welcoming environment. They found me a nice piece for a solid value. Would definitely recommend to a friend! Shout out to Chris and Tara for their expertise, friendliness and professionalism!
Jun 13, 2021
Report
Their behavior is amazing and friendly. They are very honest about their promises. I got what I wanted. Strongly recommended for everyone.
Michael Foster
Michael Foster
Apr 29, 2021
Report
We were happily greeted moment we walked in. Shelly was very helpful and took time to ensure we got exactly what we were looking for. They were able to set our stone in the mount we selected, put it on a white gold chain, and even gift wrapped it. We will definitely be visiting again in the future.
Andrew Sullivan
Andrew Sullivan
Jan 23, 2021
Report
McGee and company are expert jewelers with a wealth of knowledge. They guided me through a very unique and and special engagement ring. There aren’t gimmicks at this family owned jewelry store, just good people trying to help their costumers. Huge thank you!
Suzin G.
Suzin G.
Nov 23, 2020
Report
The entire staff at McGee's always goes above and beyond for me. I recently got engaged and my fiancé knew this was my Jeweler of choice. They helped him pick the perfect ring and I couldn't be more pleased with the service he received as well.
Renee G.
Renee G.
Nov 07, 2020
Report
I haven't been able to wear my aquamarine ring since I got pregnant. I went to J L Johnson's to have it resized and they said because the 14k gold is so thin and the band is hallow it'd cost $300-400 to have it sized up and it would be really thin and take up to 4 weeks.
McGee had my ring back to me in 3 days for $65!!
Fits perfectly-could not be happier!
The Jeweler even took time to come out and speak to me about my concerns prior to dropping off!
Super friendly staff
Kayla O'Day
Kayla O'Day
Aug 31, 2020
Report
My fiance and I designed my ring here. Not only did the manager remember me (and my fiance) on separate visits, but he was able to take my specific tastes and immediately show me a book of ideas; the second ring setting he showed me was perfect! Everyone here has always been friendly. I just went in a month after the engagement to get the prongs checked and a cleaning and they seemed genuinely happy to see it cleaned and invited me to come back anytime. He even remembered my ring and my fiancé's name! I recommend this highly after looking at several places.
Cory S.
Cory S.
Jun 04, 2020
Report
I'm close to giving this place 5 stars, but I'm going to stick with 4 stars for 1 minor reason. Their selection isn't as large as other places, but does offer a nice variety.
I came through here during COVID after they opened back up as I wanted to support local businesses and needed a 10 year anniversary present for my wife.
I went in without a budget and only a vague idea of what I wanted to get (a right hand ring). I found Caroline behind the counter and immediately loved working with her as she was super friendly, educated on what they had and willing to work with me to find
Emi M.
Emi M.
Mar 11, 2020
Report
Great experience for watch repair.
Very professional, courteous staff and service.
If you have a timepiece you need to fix and are looking for a place you can trust, go here!
Graciela M.
Graciela M.
Jul 11, 2019
Report
They are so awesome here! Fixed my diamond earrings for such a reasonable price and they're as good as new. They also offer cleanings for free! Unbeatable customer service! Thank you all!
Julia A.
Julia A.
Nov 28, 2018
Report
Fantastic service and great prices. Have been taking jewelry in for repairs (watch batteries/bands/etc.) and even an appraisal for over 10 years now. They have always been extremely helpful even when it isn't a product/brand they sell. Their prices and honesty are both appreciated. I would highly recommend McGee & Co.
Dee H.
Dee H.
Oct 24, 2018
Report
WOW! My husband and I had the best experience, Elena and Doug were very helpful. They made it so easy to find the best ring. I highly recommend McGee & Co...they will treat you right!
Mike M.
Mike M.
Oct 04, 2017
Report
We LOVED working with McGees! They went above and beyond for everything that we requested. Adam in particular was exceptional with his work and his words for us. The entire staff there was very nice and always wanted to do what was best for us. Dropped off my wife's wedding bands at noon on Monday and had a special request to have them finished by the close of business that night before we left town for a funeral the next morning and then the honeymoon to follow. Overall, we have had great experiences across the board! I would give it more than 5 stars if I could!
Joanna S.
Joanna S.
Sep 08, 2017
Report
You will not find a more honest, competitively priced jeweler in central Indiana. They have a large selection of jewelry in all styles and price ranges. The staff is extremely knowledgeable, I suggest you ask for Stephaney.
Drew H.
Drew H.
Jul 29, 2017
Report
I went in to have a watch that was given to me re-sized which only costs $5! Now I'm not someone who knows anything about watches, but I met with Adam who gave me a lot of information regarding the watch that I wasn't aware of at all. He spent 15-20 minutes with me walking me through the different gadgets on my watch and making sure I knew how to operate it. I was extremely impressed with the customer service and will be back!
Garvy S.
Garvy S.
Sep 12, 2016
Report
I am long overdue for this review! I recently got engaged and was in need of getting my ring resize, with the recommendation of my co worker she recommended I use McGee. I have called around other places and McGee gave me a quote of $45 which was way less than other places. The employees are so helpful and knowledgeable of rings. I was able to find out my ring size along with finding my great half ring size. I was able to pay and got my ring back in 4 days. That was super fast! I was not at all nervous or afraid to leave my ring with these people because they know exactly what they are doing. I
Bob J.
Bob J.
May 11, 2016
Report
If you are looking for a special piece of jewelry, this is the place. Dennis Allen and staff are not your typical jewelers. Knowledgeable, low key and very helpful--they keep you coming back because of the service. It is the selection that will draw you in the first time. There is a large variety of unique pieces with an eye toward contemporary flair. Great people building a relationship, not just selling a product.
Holly T.
Holly T.
Jul 18, 2015
Report
We went to several large chain jewelers to pick out our wedding rings. This place was the only place that was patient and took the time to make sure we loved what we picked out. All the other places seemed like they were trying to hurry up and get the sale. Also, love that they have a interest free layaway option.
Dan J.
Dan J.
Jan 23, 2015
Report
I walked in with a watch that needed a new battery and another watch to be resized. I was greeted immediately with a friendly smile. The watch service done immediately. Employees were friendly, helpful, courteous, and welcoming without being pushy. During my short wait I noticed they have a nice selection of men's watches (Tissot, Citizen, Seiko) in addition to fine women's watches and jewelry. I'll be back.
Michael G.
Michael G.
Apr 06, 2014
Report
Hands down, the best jewelry store in Greenwood. They have a great selection and the staff is awesome. My wife and I have been shopping there for years and always get treated like we are part of the family. Do yourself a favor and check them out before you make your next jewelry purchase somewhere else.