Website
Call
Newbrook Insurance Agency
As an independent agency, we are able to shop the insurance marketplace for our customers and find the best combination of companies to meet all of their insurance needs. Sometimes that means all of your coverage is with one company and in other cases it means we are able to bring either enhanced savings or additional coverage by matching you with multiple insurance companies.

Either way, you can be sure we are working hard to provide you the best overall insurance program from the broad selection of companies that we represent. All of our underwriters are licensed professionals and continually update their industry knowledge via continuing education classes and insurance seminars.
Services
At Newbrook Insurance Agency we have protected the residents and businesses of Port Jefferson Station and Suffolk and Nassau Counties on Long Island, New York since 1969. We know the area. We know the residents. We know how to protect you with the rightcar insurance. Avoiding accidents is not promised to you or anyone else.
As a business owner, are there risks you haven't considered? Are there ways your business is exposed to unplanned financial losses? As a small businessowner, you want to cover all of your business needs while maximizing your profits. Did you know that a New York Business Owners Insurance policy can protect such exposures as your office and business interruption?.
What kinds of health insurance are there? There are essentially two kinds of heath insurance: Fee-for-Service and Managed Care. Although these plans differ, they both cover an array of medical, surgical and hospital expenses. Most cover prescription drugs and some also offer dental coverage. These plans generally assume that the medical professional will be paid a fee for each service provided to the patient.
At Newbrook Insurance Agency we have protected the residents in Suffolk and Nassau County on Long Island and locally in Port Jefferson Station since 1969. We are friends with the people here. We know home insurance. We understand home values on Long Island, and we know how to protect your home to give you and your family peace of mind.
Is there a sadder situation than that of a young widow with small children sobbing at the funeral of her husband? Or what about the sad wake of single mother struck down in the prime of life, leaving two children to fend for themselves? Long Island Life insurance would have protected them after their mother and father passed away.
Reviews (10)
Edward Litts
Edward Litts
Dec 02, 2021
Report
I’ve been a loyal customer of Newbrook for approximately 20 plus years. The agents are the most professional I’ve ever had the pleasure to deal with. They are always helpful and very knowledgeable. I would highly recommend this company over any other.
Bill A.
Bill A.
Nov 27, 2021
Report
Any time we have ever had any issues Newbrook Insurance has rectified them with the insurance companies.
Relating to the latest issue, Margaret was GREAT following up with and helping us out. Without me even asking her to call the insurance company she did and got us a refund. That's SERVICE!!
Correne Martinez
Correne Martinez
Nov 19, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness
Been with them for years. Great customer service!
Jan Bernauer
Jan Bernauer
Nov 02, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
David is a great agent. He managed to get me an Umbrella insurance from the same company as my auto and home insurance, something my old agent wasn't able to negotiate. Fast response time and competent answers to all my questions.
Maryanne Hull
Maryanne Hull
Oct 23, 2021
Report
I just became a customer with your agency. I am so happy I did I should have done it sooner. Margaret was a tremendous help professional and courteous at the same time. I’m more than satisfied. I saved a lot of money and was able to get more insurance. Being a single mom and a widow I now feel very secure with the coverage I have. Thank you again if I need any further services I will definitely call you.
Joshua Rossman
Joshua Rossman
Jul 03, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness
I have used this company for over 10 years now. You will never find a company more sharp, organized, professional or fair. I highly recommend them.
Deborah Marino
Deborah Marino
Jun 25, 2021
Report
I have been with Newbrook for a few years for my auto and homeowners insurance. Their prices are very reasonable and they are cheaper then other insurance companies. They respond very quickly to an email or phone call. My husband had an accident about a month ago and they were right on it. The also had the check mailed out within 2 weeks and called to check on how things were going with the repair. I would highly recommend Newbrook. Everyone is personable and attends to you immediately.
Popkin Electric
Popkin Electric
May 30, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
I had a recent issue with my mortgage company not having the property insurance bill. Corinna was so professional in contacting the bank and correcting their issue. I can not say enough how well this was taken care of by the Newbrook Staff. Many thanks.
Kristin Giordano
Kristin Giordano
Apr 19, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
We have been dealing with Phil & Newbrook Insurance Agency for years now. Everyone is always extremely responsive and a pleasure to deal with! We are always confident they are shopping around for the best deals without us having to ask. It's so nice to be able to completely trust a company & it's employees. I highly recommend them!
Barbara Barker
Barbara Barker
Mar 29, 2021
Report
They made getting my very affordable homeowners insurance simple, and it's so easy to renew it through them. It's easy to get in touch with them and it's easy to pay my insurance through them. They honestly just make everything easy for me. Everyone I've dealt with is very nice and helpful, they respond quickly to emails and when they say they will call you right back, they really do!