Greenlee Winchester
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Established in 1955, we serve clients throughout Jamestown, Mayville, Findley Lake, Bemus Point, Cassadaga and the surrounding communities. We are not just an insurance agency selling a product, our goal is to provide you with information about insurance products that are available and to advise you on the coverage best suited to helping you protect yourself, your family, your business and your property.

Based on your input, we will then offer you specific personal and commercial insurance products and design a comprehensive insurance program tailored to your unique requirements.
Services
Sounds like a lot of questions, but your answers will help us at Greenlee-Winchester Agency to provide you with quality auto and motorcycle insurance in Jamestown, Findley Lake, Mayville, Bemus Point, Cassadaga and other communities in Chautauqua County. We are also one of the largest auto insurers in western New York and that means we can find the right coverage with the most competitive rates for your specific needs.
At Greenlee-Winchester Agency we understand the unique challenges companies in Chautauqua County face and we're ready to provide business insurance in Bemus Point, Cassadaga, Findley Lake, Jamestown, Mayville and surrounding communities. In addition, we understand the dynamics involved and the risks faced by farmers and others involved in the agricultural industry.
Reviews (6)
Conar Rough
Conar Rough
Oct 17, 2021
Report
Super professional and a great guy to chat with. Definitely recommend buying from him 100%.
Benjamin Nichols
Benjamin Nichols
Mar 02, 2021
Report
Positive: Quality
Been with them for years, always been treated well and will continue to stay with them.
Getting Along Alone
Getting Along Alone
Dec 27, 2019
Report
I have been with Greenlee Ins. since 1988. I have been ripped off for years because I didn't know they own the insurance they sell you, therefor, they make percentage of the expensive Insurance they sell you. They have ZERO interest to save you a penny because it affects their bottom line. I went to Brown & Brown Ins in Jamestown instead, and they were able to gut my rates in half and saved me $700 a year on the coverage Greenlee was over charging me on. Stay away from Greenlee Ins. They are a rip off and never try to find you a better rate. You will never hear from them if they could save you
Nicole DeVlieger
Nicole DeVlieger
Sep 20, 2016
Report
Greenly is amazing have used them for about 10yrs would highly recommend them to just about anyone lowest rates i could find.
Steve Koestler
Steve Koestler
Jun 13, 2015
Report
Experience counts a lot when it comes to finding a insurance policy and in this regard Greenlee-Winchester Insurance Agency is hard to beat. They are one of the reliable and reputed family owned and operated insurance agency offering auto, homeowners, and commercial insurance.
Bryant Aplass
Bryant Aplass
Oct 14, 2012
Report
I just ordered from this company, and it was quite awesome. I highly recommend them!
Thanks! Bryant