Name: New System Bakery
Address: 125 Western Ave, Chillicothe, OH, 45601, US
Telephone: (740) 773-2885
Rating: 3.3

Fresh blueberry muffins are next up (pictured), along with our glorious morning muffin, which is similar to a carrot cake muffin. Then we begin fresh, rich fudge brownies with our chocolate fudge frosting. Whoopee pies are decadent with our homemade chocolate cake sandwich filled with our Bismark cream and topped with fudge icing.

We do birthday cakes in many different sizes and flavors! These are VERY SIMPLY decorated cakes. Includes our traditional white icing, writing of your choice, roses and top and bottom borders. Call for pricing. CAFE NOW OPEN! Enter from 296 West Water Street or through our parking lot (rear) at 125 Western Avenue.

Website Update

Reviews (10)

Write a Review

Trisha Bowles

Jul 20, 2021

Report

You crushed my cookies by cramming 2 dozen in a small box. Use some common sense and a bigger box because the blue icing was everywhere.

Raven Hook

Apr 21, 2021

Report

I actually ordered from Door Dash a dozen of there doughnuts and all I can say is WOW. They are absoluting amazing! I am now obsessed and they have the best Starwberry Filled Pastery of greatness. I'm not sure the names but goodness I could eat them all day long! They remind me of toaster strudels but in stick form and are 10 times better! If you ever see them on Door Dash or are in the area they are definitely worth a try!

Debbie Jenkins

Aug 04, 2020

Report

Love their cakes!! So good and moist. Everything I have bought has been fantastic

Terri Fitch

Jul 07, 2020

Report

Has great doughnuts and cookies. I think sometimes they even havecakes and pies, not very big, but they are delicious. It's a totally different taste than Crispe Creme in town, which what makes it good... It gives you VARIETY!!!

Kayla B.

Dec 04, 2018

Report

I grew up eating this bakery, and I remember it as far back as I can remember. Coming home from school to a Devils Food Pie was such a treat. Since the change of location and staff, the quality has declined in a disappointing way. My parents, especially my dad, loved this bakery. They couldn't go to Chillicothe without going to New Systems. The cupcakes are now dense and taste stale. I'm not sure but they taste like they're frozen then dethawed. I know the recipes are supposedly the same, but the quality in our opinion has declined and the prices have exceeded the lack of quality. Very dissapointed

Lisa Call

Jun 22, 2018

Report

We picked up a cake on Christmas Eve. We brought it home and wrapped the box tightly in plastic wrap and put in the deep freeze for a couple of days. When we got it out to serve, it was so dry. It was like eating a dry sponge. Nobody would eat it so consequently we ended up throwing away a half sheet cake. When I talked to the owner she said she was sorry but offered no compensation of any kind. This was our first time buying a cake from this bakery and it will be our last.

Andrew Willke

Jan 28, 2018

Report

I love the bismarks and cream sticks! They also have seasonal cookies there too such as the Halloween cookies and the valentines cookies. Donut holes are a good time, too. Always worth the drive from Cincy!

Brenda Snodgrass

Dec 07, 2017

Report

Paid over $7 for a dozen sugar cookies, they were horrible ! I was shocked, I have never had anything bad from here. cookie had no flavor and the icing tasted old.

Tabatha Turner

Oct 28, 2017

Report

I was born and raised in Ohio. I remember my mom and dad taking me to get donuts. Now my husband and I live in Texas and you can not find donuts like New Systems! Our favorites are the Bismarks and the Cream/Iced-sticks. Happy they now ship out of state. One of a kind bakery!

Nithya Rajan

Dec 08, 2015

Report

Old fashioned bakery. Their signature product is the Bismark. A delicious pastry with cream filling. Want chocolate bismarks? You can only get them on Friday. Just before Christmas they make a fruit cake that is legendary.