Tamer Insurance Agency
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Tamer Insurance Agency
If you are looking for the right broker who can assist you with all your insurance needs, turn to the experienced professionals at Tamer Insurance Agency LLC. We're an independent insurance agency that aids in protecting the things you care about. Our team will work with you to understand your needs and provide great insurance deals that you deserve.

Call us today for a FREE quote! Rely on the Tamer Insurance Agency LLC team to get the best insurance package for your automobile. You can count on us to get you comprehensive policies at the best possible rates. Give your home the protection and coverage it deserves, as it is one of the most important investments you've made.
Services
Get a great auto insurance policy through your friendly local brokers! With our industry connections and powerful partners, we'll get you the most comprehensive policies at the best possible rates. Come, visit us or give us a call and you'll see! Together, we can find a policy that perfectly suits your needs while fitting within your budget.
When you choose us, you'll get the personal attention and customer service of our small, family owned firm, while being backed by powerful policies from some of the insurance industry's most trusted names. Reach out to us today for policies from big companies like West Bend, Acuity, Badger Mutual, ASI, and more - all at competitive prices.
Protect your health and the people you love by investing in health and life insurance through Tamer Insurance Agency. We'll connect you to great rates on health insurance, dental insurance and medicare supplements, protecting your ability to care for those you love. You'll also be able to get great deals on life insurance, meaning that you'll never have to worry about what could happen to your loved ones if you're unable to be with them.
You've worked too hard and put your years of sacrifice and effort into your business to allow it to be put in jeopardy. Many things can go wrong that can lead to your business being put on the line - unless you have the right policy. You can call us today to speak with our agents at Tamer Insurance Agency and allow us to work with you on this crucial area of your business plan.
Reviews (8)
Steven Lentz
Steven Lentz
Nov 04, 2021
Report
Sarah has been a pleasure to work with over the years. Every year she has called with great news about our auto insurance rates! Would highly recommend!
Kelsey Porada
Kelsey Porada
Jan 04, 2021
Report
My husband and I have benefited so much from working with Tamer Insurance Agency. As a young couple, navigating insurance policies is still new and confusing, but Tamer always helps us understand and find the best coverage for our needs. I want to give a special shout-out to Sandy at Tamer who uncovered a way to discount our policy payment in half while maintaining the same level of coverage - her skills, advocacy, and commitment to her clients make her a real life superhero. Thank you, Sandy!
Sbenkert
Sbenkert
Oct 12, 2020
Report
We recently switched insurance providers and Sarah at Tamer gave us first rate service. She worked diligently to research our needs and provided detailed & insightful comparisons. This was not easy as we have multiple vehicles, a camper, motorcycles and our home that we bundled together. Very happy with the service provided and we would highly recommend them to anyone looking for a quality insurance provider.
Andrew J.
Andrew J.
Oct 07, 2020
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
I've been with Tamers for roughly 12 of the last 15 years. They have always been there for me and any questions. Always looking ways to save me $$. but also what is the best.
Mary Wysocki
Mary Wysocki
Jun 25, 2020
Report
Have ben doing business with them for more than 20 years. Fantastic customer service. Great people. They are very nice to my mom .Frank , Sandra and family are fabulous.
Didier Babits
Didier Babits
May 07, 2020
Report
Was a good agency the first years, now I have no idea if my agent is alive or dead. Have not heard from them in at least two years, although , I believe I received one of their cheesy calendars for the holidays. Approximately three weeks ago I again emailed them to contact me, giving them my cell and work number, since email doesn't seem to work for them. Although I think over 1200 a month for health insurance is a bit excessive they seem to be happy with their cut of the action.
Don Tendick
Don Tendick
May 07, 2019
Report
Excellent, high quality, honest insurance agency. Highly recommended. Have know the principles for over 30 years.
Whitney S.
Whitney S.
Oct 05, 2010
Report
I have been going to Tamer for two years now and the agents there are awesome. Sarah is my agent for my car and her mother is my agent too! They remember you by name and are very quick to return calls. I used to get insurance directly through progressive but Tamer was cheaper and the care was much better. I have called for issues that I could have handled myself by calling progressive but Sarah has taken care of the issues for me. They are always willing to help and have always been able to answer my questions. Frank is very knowledgeable and is able to answer just about anything.
I'm very glad