Wickersham Jewelry
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Wickersham Jewelry
Since 1959, we have always put our customers first. We take pride in our customer service, variety of jewelry inventory, and repair and custom jewelry departments. We invite you to stop into each Wickersham Jewelry store location to browse or purchase jewelry, have jewelry repaired, or have a unique piece of jewelry created.

After all, "If you can dream it, we can make it!" Even with all the available designs in the marketplace today, sometimes nothing quite matches your unique fashion and style. In no time at all, you could be the proud owner of a unique and beautiful Wickersham Jewelry Custom Design! Browse our collection of beautiful fine jewelry.
Services
No two colored gemstones are alike, nor are any two jewelers. When choosing your gems, it is important to work with a jeweler that understands all of the aspects that need to be considered when purchasing a colored gemstone. For example, what is the best colored gemstone? The answer to this question extends well beyond ruby, sapphire and emerald and is different for each person.
Buying a diamond is a very personal experience. Diamonds can be bought to signify love, significant accomplishments, milestones in your life or that of a gift's recipient. Unlike when you buy clothing, electronics, or cars, the features of a diamond may not seem quite so obvious to you. We would like to change that.
Buying a gemstone is often a very different experience than buying a diamond. Gemstones are bought based on favorite colors, wardrobe matches, personality, and fashion trends. While gemstones are judged using the 4Cs, just as diamonds are, each is judged separately. For example, a sapphire is compared to another sapphire, but wouldn't be compared to an emerald or aquamarine.
Ania Haie was born out of a need for on-trend jewelry at accessible prices without compromising on quality. Featuring some of the most intricate pieces from our diamond bridal collection, each design embodies a sense of artistic expression. Since 1983, Malo has offered a vast selection of traditional and contemporary wedding bands, and designed beautiful creations to help.
Ania Haie was born out of a need for on-trend jewelry at accessible prices without compromising on quality. Drawing inspiration from fashion catwalks and street style, we offer fresh, wardrobe must-haves that cater to every woman. All our pieces are crafted in 925 sterling silver, plated with rhodium or 14kt gold and designed to be layered up to express your unique personal style.
Reviews (15)
Leonardo Zernone
Leonardo Zernone
Dec 22, 2021
Report
Very pricey!they wanted $300 for a dinky necklace. Found one on line 4x bigger in width for half the price.
Kerri Schmidt
Kerri Schmidt
Sep 22, 2021
Report
Very knowledgeable and professional staff. Bryce did a great job and has product knowledge especially 💎
Valencia Valentino
Valencia Valentino
Aug 15, 2021
Report
I love this place.. the employees are amazing great attitudes very knowledgeable welcoming atmosphere and quick quality work
Jordan Renn
Jordan Renn
Jul 08, 2021
Report
We worked with Paige to find the perfect engagement ring and both of our wedding bands. She is so kind and helpful - we enjoyed working with her!
Haley Haenel
Haley Haenel
Jun 18, 2021
Report
My husband recently got me an anniversary ring here, and Bryce was amazingly helpful to him! She really takes the time to make sure you get what you want, and make sure you love it! They have beautiful pieces and are very accommodating to working with a budget, and still finding something beautiful you dream of!
Bennett Berray
Bennett Berray
May 06, 2021
Report
Bryce and the staff were very professional and went above and beyond our expectations. Bryce listened to every single detail we asked for and developed an incredible engagement ring that was absolutely gorgeous. We will be customers for life.
Angie Olson
Angie Olson
Apr 27, 2021
Report
Bryce at Wickersham Rhinelander location is the BOMB!!! Bryce "ROCKED" my engagement ring. She took a picture and made it even better than I could've ever imagined! Wickersham put my gorgeous custom made ring together in less than a week. I cannot thank Wickersham Jewelers enough! I love love love my ring ❤️💍
Tom Kingston
Tom Kingston
Apr 21, 2021
Report
Great customer service. There is always someone there to greet you with a smile and help you find the right peice of jewelry! If you are looking for something custom, Paul is th guy. He does amazing work and is very knowledgeable and helpful!
Dana Gregory
Dana Gregory
Dec 14, 2020
Report
I dont have experience at or in this store, however, I received a silver chain and pendant from my boyfriend that he said was purchased here after looking high and low for something special to give me for Christmas 2019. Because of circumstances I received it in March or April 2020. We went lake swimming for the weekend of July 4th. After swimming, we were just sitting on lounge chairs when the necklace fell into my lap, in 3 different pieces. The chain broke in 2 places. ??????
After this happened my boyfriend informed me the necklace "was not cheap".
I said "I know Hunny I know"
???????
Sara Toltzman
Sara Toltzman
Nov 17, 2020
Report
They are super friendly and sized and cleaned my parents precious wedding bands beautifully. The rings looked gorgeous when they were finished. Trust this jeweler, you won’t be sorry! 💝💎
Irving Gelbart
Irving Gelbart
Aug 26, 2020
Report
Stopped in to have a simple repair.
The staff was super professional and delivered exceptional customer service.
I asked if by chance they had a a piece of jewelry for a gift for my girlfriend.
Lo and behold, they had one in stock and they even offered it to me at a great price.
All in all, great customer service, great selection, great prices.
I highly recommend Wickersham Jewelry and will do business with them again.
Lacey Kerlin
Lacey Kerlin
Apr 29, 2020
Report
Paige was so wonderful to work with! She went out of her way to help me with a disaster of an experience that I had at a jewelry store in Appleton. I can't speak highly enough of her and I always love the warm and friendly welcoming every time I went in the store! Speaking of, I'm looking forward to being able to go back in to store very soon :)!! Thank you!
Chastidy Bongiovanni
Chastidy Bongiovanni
Feb 29, 2020
Report
Finally had my grandmother's diamond reset for something more my style, and I couldn't be happier! Beautiful job and wonderful customer service. I would recommend them to everyone!
Holly Rose
Holly Rose
Jun 07, 2019
Report
The team at Wickersham is amazing! They are great about looking up previous add a pearl purchases to ensure that I’m ordering the correct ones. They are so warm and friendly and I always look forward to doing business with them.
Debby McGrath
Debby McGrath
Jun 28, 2018
Report
This was the best experience for me! Paul took the time to listen to what I wanted in my design and he created a beautiful ring for me. I had a lot of questions throughout the process. Paul was very patient with me and answered all of my questions, all while assuring me that I would be very happy with the design, and if I wasn’t he would do everything he could to be sure that I loved my ring when it was all said and done. He was right! I love my ring!! It’s more beautiful than I could have imagined and I now have something that I can enjoy for a long time and then pass on to my daughter some