Simple Sweets Bakery
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Simple Sweets Bakery is an old-fashioned, artisan bakery. We have two bakers and all our treats are made in house, in small batches. We make all kinds of baked goods, ranging from the simple, fresh baked cookie to the elaborate elegance of wedding cakes. Our in-store selection of goodies is changed regularly to keep it from "going stale", so to speak.

So stop by often to see what new and exciting treats we have to offer! Don't forget to like us on Facebook! All of our products are produced on shared equipment. We cannot with 100% certainty guarantee that items are free of any allergen contaminant. When placing an order, or visiting our bakery, please be sure to advise us of any and all allergies so we can properly handle your order.
Services
Bakery disclosure: Not everything listed on our site is available in-store at all times. We are a small bakery and simply do not have the square footage required to have all the treats we can make on display at all times. For a list of treats we have on hand, call us or check our Facebook page. We are committed to keeping a fresh variety on display for your choosing.
We are an artisan bakery with only two bakers, who make everything fresh. Due to this, only a certain quantity of orders can be taken for any given date. Some dates fill up quickly, especially during peak wedding season (June-September), so if you are planning a party or any type of gathering, the sooner orders are placed the more likely we will be able to accommodate you.
Or maybe you are going to the country club, winery, lake, or your best friend or family's back yard. Wherever your ceremony is taking place, a fabulous reception is sure to follow, where the second (or third) beautiful sight of the day will be showcased (the first being your reflection Ms. Soon-to-be-bride).
Reviews (9)
Ethan & Jade Thomas
Ethan & Jade Thomas
Jan 06, 2022
Report
We used Simple Sweets Bakery for our wedding, and it was the best cake I've ever had. They are so nice, and our filling was not on their official list but they made it anyways with no up charge. Our wedding guests raved about it!
Gary Wurstner
Gary Wurstner
Jan 03, 2022
Report
Stopped in for the first time for a late lunch and were not disappointed. The food was delicious, fresh and made from scratch. The chicken soup was filled with chunks white meat and finely chopped vegetables in a savory broth.
Lisa B.
Lisa B.
Dec 28, 2021
Report
Every cookie on our holiday platter was superb! Delicious, and beautifully decorated! Thank you!
Kate Sonja
Kate Sonja
Oct 14, 2021
Report
Came here for coffee and breakfast, our sandwiches were delicious! We would highly recommend the Chipotle mayo, the hashbrown that came on the side of our sandwiches were sooooooo good! Our coffees were perfect as well. What a great start to our day!
Robert & Kimberly Yarnall
Robert & Kimberly Yarnall
Oct 01, 2021
Report
Great family run bakery. Friendly service and the brownies were great!
Regina Hamblet
Regina Hamblet
Aug 16, 2021
Report
Marina did a fantastic job with our wedding cake! She was super helpful and she did exactly what we had in mind and we couldn't have been happier.
It was a Lemon cake, cherry filling, vanilla bean buttercream. We're planning on ordering cupcakes in the same flavor soon!
The cake was a hit with our guests, several said "the best wedding cake they've ever had "
I'm definitely inclined to agree.
Deb B.
Deb B.
Apr 13, 2021
Report
We loved this place when we lived in Geneva and now that we live in Rochester, we still make a special trip now and then just to visit this bakery. It's THAT good! Friendly staff, great selection, amazing baked goods!
Yasmin Disla
Yasmin Disla
Aug 12, 2020
Report
This establishment is very cute and looks very clean. I called the store the day prior to ensure they had vegan options available before I made the trip. Arrived there at 1:30 PM and was able to get 3 cookies which is all they had (all same flavor). No options as they said yesterday. Really disappointed as I'm allergic to eggs and wanted like a vegan cupcake or perhaps a brownie, something. Was told chef made different desserts daily that were vegan. I'm so upset.
Rebekah Hylton
Rebekah Hylton
Aug 09, 2018
Report
Marina did a stellar job! My husband and I are not cake people but man, hers is the best! It was super close to our venue which was nice as well. We went with a four tiered naked cake. Our bottom layer was chocolate and the other three were banana (odd, but so so good!) and chocolate frosting on all of it. Again, I just showed Marina some inspiration photos for our cake and we purchased the flowers/cake topper ahead of time. All she had us do was leave the decorations on the cake table before she arrived and she worked her magic! The cake looked exactly as I hoped, if not better, and tasted SO