Catanzaro Insurance
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Catanzaro Insurance
Proudly located in Historic German Village in Columbus, Catanzaro Insurance is an independent insurance agency helping people with auto/car insurance, flood insurance, homeowners insurance, business/commercial insurance and life insurance. At Catanzaro Insurance, we believe that if you genuinely care about people first, the rest will fall into place.

Serving the entire State of Ohio we understand you have a choice when it comes to insurance. Catanzaro Insurance will assess your situation thoroughly and provide you with the best options to choose from. In the end we think our effort and expertise will make Catanzaro Insurance your obvious choice.
Services
Anthony began his insurance career in 2011 with a Fortune 100 insurance company and left as a respected top producer for the company. After his time as a producer, he went on to be a District Manager in the Washington, DC area for another Fortune 500 insurance company. Anthony founded Catanzaro Insurance to provide his clients with multiple options for insurance and offer the best products to fit the client's needs.
Catanzaro Insurance is an independent insurance agency, meaning we are free to choose the best carrier for your insurance needs. We do not work for an insurance company; we work for you. We work on your side when you have a loss and follow through to see that you get fair, prompt payment and service.
At Catanzaro Insurance, our personal insurance products provide our customers with protection for their homes, automobiles and personal possessions, along with personal liability coverages. How we serve you is as important as what we provide. First, we listen to you, then we discuss your needs and answer your questions.
The second part of auto insurance covers the car itself: comprehensive coverage reimburses losses from fire, theft or other perils; collision coverage pays to repair losses caused by an accident. Often this coverage is mandated by leasing companies or banks. There are also ancillary medical, car rental and other coverages which vary by state.
If you have tangible assets, you need the protection of a homeowners insurance policy. These policies cover you in a home or condominium/apartment, whether you are an owner or a renter. A well-written homeowners policy will pay to replace any of your personal property that is destroyed in a fire or other disaster.
Reviews (9)
Michael Harry Klein
Michael Harry Klein
Nov 07, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
If you are an American citizen needing insurance as a Nomad or Expat, look no further. Patient, responsive attention and a real willingness to find solutions for people in our situation.
Jeffrey Madison
Jeffrey Madison
Nov 01, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Mr. Catanzaro is the most responsive agent I’ve ever encountered. Plus he is able to find good policies at lower prices than anyone else. Highly recommend!
Chris Plunkett
Chris Plunkett
Apr 29, 2021
Report
I was contacted by Anthony after my insurance company of 8 years left me high and dry without even a days notice, I was uninsured and frantic. He came through for me in my greatest time of need. I called hundreds of companies, some who never even returned my call. Anthony not only was able to get me insured in less than 24 hours but the rate he was able to get me was a fraction of what I was being told elsewhere it would be. Not to mention the insurance company he was able to get me set up with was a much more reputable company than I had previously been with. Thanks again Anthony!
Olakunle Afolabi
Olakunle Afolabi
Feb 28, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Very responsive and great prices. You helped me when I needed the help most especially with the very busy schedule of my team. Thank you!
Antonia McFadden
Antonia McFadden
Dec 01, 2020
Report
Anthony is always very professional I have sent multiple clients to him for a quote and he’s always come through with better insurance and lower price!
Julia Ayers
Julia Ayers
Oct 19, 2020
Report
Agree with the lack of customer service. When it came to initially getting me to sign up for insurances, e-mails and call were immediately retuned or answered. Now when it comes to needing help with a claim I don't get responses in weeks. Then I might get one after multiple e-mails on my end and then nothing again. Still have not received the help I needed since January.
Dale Barbe
Dale Barbe
Jul 09, 2019
Report
I called about our renewal because it went up and they were suppose to have Anthony call me back. He has not called back yet. It has been almost three weeks. If this is the customer service experience I am going to receive than some a other insurance company/ agent can have my business.
Andrea Ferguson
Andrea Ferguson
Dec 27, 2015
Report
I recently contacted Catanzaro Insurance for a price comparison with my current homeowners and automobile policies. After speaking with Anthony and letting him know what my needs were, he was able to find me a policy with everything I needed, and also with substantial savings. Anthony was very knowledgeable and personable. He made me feel extremely comfortable in coming to him with any questions that I had. He made what can sometimes be a stressful transition extremely effortless, on my part at least. I would highly recommend Catanzaro Insurance!! Thank you Anthony for providing me with such a
Brandon Olszewski
Brandon Olszewski
Aug 05, 2015
Report
I felt like the team at Catanzaro truly valued my business. They were very responsive and made it easy for me to contact them at any time. Anthony gave me his cell phone number and told me to text or call at any time. I was very pleased with the high level of customer service.