Old Town Bakery

We came here for a slice of key lime pie since I saw it on many lists for places to try key lime pie in Key West.
I really loved the filling. It was perfectly tangy how I think it should. Many of the others we had were not as tangy.
The crust, on the other hand, was not good. It was the worst crust of the 5 pies we had. That being said, it's worth having for the filling alone.

We stopped here nearly every morning while in Key West. The pastries were delicious! I also had their tomato sandwich a couple times for lunch. It also was yummy.

Carry out only. The pastry and breakfast sandwiches are good. We tried the ham and cheese croissant, an apple pastry, and raspberry muffin. The raspberry tarts are VERY good! The variety of coffee and iced coffee is appealing and very good. Lunch sandwiches are available. Don't dare open your sack inside or the lady will chastise you. The curt attitude of the lady drags the rating from a 5 to a 3. She should work on her PR to make the customer feel welcome. She gave me the impression she really didn't want to be there.

Good selection of pastries. We have not tried lunch but breakfast boritos were very good. Generous with the bacon and sausage. Danish and other pastries were also very tasty. The gentleman working behind the counter was very friendly even though they were extremely busy.

I have visited Old town bakery in different occasions and I always lover every bit of the experience! They have a variety of delicious freshly baked goods to choose from, it’s always so hard to decide. It seems they really know what they are doing, they have been around for a while. Definitely recommend to check it out for a nice breakfast option! Take out only I believe!

The food was fresh and good. We had breakfast croissants and coffee. Easy to get in and out of. Some of the local hotels will give you coupons to use for $5 off.

We ordered breakfast croissants and pastries. When we received delivery the order wasn’t completed. Called back and received an uneasy response nonetheless I personally will give em another try 🙂

Brought a slice of pie because of all the hype... Terribly let down. Really tart and the crust is soggy. There's a bit of liquid pooling at the bottom. The whipped cream tastes stale as well, got that refrigerator taste. Went first thing in the morning, so I feel like the pie were leftovers... I would had ranked this better but the hype make it too much of a let down...
But chocolate croissant was good.

We had delicious breakfast burritos!! Cute hole in the wall. We didn’t indulge in the sweets, but they looked yummy!!

Reading all of the other reviews I think we must have just visited on an off day.
My sandwich was dry and lacked filling (see photo) but the Key Lime Pie was delicious . The bakery itself is adorable and one member of staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming. Maybe she needs to train the other person who was working today!