Stephens Pizzeria

I LOVE this place! They have the BEST CALZONE! The Greek salad is great, too! You definitely get your money's worth here! Staff are friendly, too!

My wife and I came in, grabbed a menu, and sat down. Staff did not speak to us. Went to wash up before we ordered and BOTH restrooms had a sign saying, " Out of order." We felt that this was probably the staff's way of saying we were not welcome there, so we left without ordering. Won't be back.
Hope you have a Merry Christmas.

This has been our favorite place since we moved here 2 years ago. However, the past month we ordered twice. Both times the kids working were talking with friends. Once we ordered and they didn't have our order... then they made the pizza and got it wrong when we were standing there. They overcharged and when we pointed it out, the young man said, "What do you want me to do?" Seriously? The pizza wasn't cooked. Next time they said they didn't have the order, but they did. It was under someone else's name...there was no one in the shop. Got home, pizza not cooked. We loved it here, but one more chance

The pizza and bread sticks were great. The pizzas came out piping hot and we didn't have to wait very long. Staff was very friendly. This will be our go to for pizza for now on.. The restaurant was very clean.

I have recently started eating here over the past month and I feel bad I didn’t start earlier. Everything I’ve had has been great and the staff has been awesome. Pizza is good but the cheesesteak with hot peppers is amazing. I’d buy a jar of the hot peppers by themselves if they sold them.

Stopped in after working late, guys were really nice and accommodating. I had a sausage and mushroom calzone with a 1/2 Greek salad, my co-worker ordered a buffalo chicken calzone, which isn't on the menu, but they gladly gave it a try. We both enjoyed our food, great portions and good service.

Food is good when the staff gets the order right....I used to order carry out once a week from this place....however it’s became once a month due to the inability to get my order right virtually every time! When you call to let them know, they say ....sorry! Again food is good, the attention to detail and customer service is lacking. Picture below is a prime example....no refund just a sorry....

I love Stephen's Pizzeria and their calzones are my favorite! However, when I went in to order a calzone to go, it took over 45 mins for them to get it ready. I understand it can take a while but there was only one other family in there and they had already been served and were leaving. The entire time all I could hear was the workers talking in the back about who was giving their notices and how they could be making more money working somewhere else instead. I get that this may be a minimum wage job, but complaining in front of customers or within the vicinity where customers can hear you is extremely

Great crust, great cheese! No sauce at all. We ordered extra sauce today and at pickup they repeated “extra sauce” but there was no sauce on the pizza. Always been an issue but they were the only decent pizza in Gray imho. This was the last one for us. Would have told the owner but never see him around anymore. Maybe that’s the problem?

Let me start off by saying customer service was amazing. My friends ordered the spaghetti and I ordered the pizza. They said their spaghetti was very delicious. With that being said, I had to only rate 4 stars because my pizza was bland. Honestly it had no flavor to it whatsoever and it killed me because I wanted to really like this place. My buddies enjoyed their food but mine was just okay, despite it being a pizzeria. Customer service was absolutely 5 stars tho!