Connecting the community to the land through food, art & events 441 Rte 5, Elbridge NY 13060. Our cafe is open 7 days a week for casual dining serving breakfast, lunch and dinner! Our menus are heavily influenced by local, seasonal products. Stop by for coffee, baked goods, food, and ice cream OR check out our beer and wine selections.
Enjoy the realm of CNY at Bailiwick Market & Cafe, just 6 miles north of Skaneateles, NY. We are located at 441 Route 5 West of Elbridge, in the heart of the finger lakes, and only a 20 minute drive west of Syracuse, NY. Nothing is better than homemade hard ice cream served year round - Try Field of Creams at Bailiwick Market & Cafe!
Enjoy the realm of CNY at Bailiwick Market & Cafe, just 6 miles north of Skaneateles, NY. We are located at 441 Route 5 West of Elbridge, in the heart of the finger lakes, and only a 20 minute drive west of Syracuse, NY. Nothing is better than homemade hard ice cream served year round - Try Field of Creams at Bailiwick Market & Cafe!
Reviews (24)
Jon Wright
Jan 13, 2022
Report
Asked for my eggs to be over easy in my sandwich. Yeah not so much. My wife's English muffin looks like it might have been waved over the toaster once or twice. That said flavors were good. Place was chilly and I wondered why the ceiling fans weren't on forcing some warmth down from the 24' vaulted ceiling. Otherwise a nice ambience and polite friendly servers. Coffee was hot and mmmmm.
Pj C.
Dec 26, 2021
Report
Jon B.
Dec 24, 2021
Report
This is one of my favorite places. The homestead setting with an airy interior is just so relaxing. The menu has a lot of healthy and hearty options. I have been there for lunches and breakfasts in past and have never been disappointed. If I lived closer, I would frequent there more often. Even if you are looking for that special gift, the shopping for local goods is a bonus.
Brittney Mikula
Oct 15, 2021
Report
Stephen Healey
Sep 28, 2021
Report
I cannot come up with a single negative about this place. Only visited once. Salmon salad special was excellent- salmon cooked just right. Bathrooms are top notch. Wide selection of items, gluten-free options, homemade hard ice cream, pleasant indoor and outdoor seating, lots of parking, they serve beer, they sell a bunch of nice items besides food: gift-appropriate things like BBQ sauce, hot sauce, kitchen tools, wine, greeting cards, trinkets, not junky stuff. Staff was efficient and friendly.
Samantha H.
Sep 08, 2021
Report
Katelyn Gelormino
Aug 28, 2021
Report
Erin C.
Aug 19, 2021
Report
Kimberly Lane
Aug 17, 2021
Report
Raymond S.
Jul 27, 2021
Report
Stoped in this past Saturday morning to pick up 4 quarts of ice cream for a gathering later in the afternoon. I did my homework before going by reviewing flavors on the webpage. I flagged 4 different flavors on my list. Much to my disappointment none of the 4 were available. Black Raspberry, Lake Effect, Peppermint Fudge and Peanut Butter Blossom. I understand being out of a flavor or 2, but 4. I would think production would be increased during the summer to cover demand. When I questioned if this was all available I was told yes and what flavors was I looking for. After naming the flavors I was
Rodrick Jones
Jun 23, 2021
Report
Cassie C.
Apr 18, 2021
Report
Such a good first experience here. We went on a less busy day, so there was no line and very few people. The staff was friendly and accommodating. The flavors of the ice cream were spot on & if you have a dog I recommend getting them "Puppy Love". It's vanilla ice cream with a small dog treat on top. My dogs give it 4/4 paws!
Jennifer Sampson
Mar 25, 2021
Report
Bailiwick Market. Taking the long way home from Waterloo we saw this place. I had remembered hearing about their home made ice cream so we stopped in.
This place was so much more than I expected. The live music was not only awesome but just made the whole experience that much better. The shop was adorable with so many great things to check out.
Now I mentioned we stopped for ice cream. But my teenage son saw someone's sandwich and decided he needed to have one and he was starving. Lol. So this turned into dinner, a show, and ice cream to go.
He got the Reuben sandwich. It came with sweet pickle
This place was so much more than I expected. The live music was not only awesome but just made the whole experience that much better. The shop was adorable with so many great things to check out.
Now I mentioned we stopped for ice cream. But my teenage son saw someone's sandwich and decided he needed to have one and he was starving. Lol. So this turned into dinner, a show, and ice cream to go.
He got the Reuben sandwich. It came with sweet pickle
Katie R.
Oct 15, 2020
Report
Today I received my order of a quart of chocolate milk, hash brown patty, small iced mocha with extra mocha, raw bagel with extra cream cheese - I prefer bagels cold over toasted, and a bailiwick parfait. And boy did they deliver it well. I've been going for the past few days and the drink taste super homey.
Mike C.
Sep 05, 2020
Report
My wife and I loved this place until today.
The chicken pot pie was the best I've ever had. However, today, we both left disappointed with only 3 tiny pieces of chicken in each pie. Before our pies were filled with cubed pieces of breast. If you like a bowl of gravy order the chicken pot pie, because you will be hunting for the chicken. Extremely disappointed!
The chicken pot pie was the best I've ever had. However, today, we both left disappointed with only 3 tiny pieces of chicken in each pie. Before our pies were filled with cubed pieces of breast. If you like a bowl of gravy order the chicken pot pie, because you will be hunting for the chicken. Extremely disappointed!
Joanne R.
Jun 25, 2020
Report
Erin O.
Oct 05, 2019
Report
Saw an ad for a fall festival here on Facebook and decided to give it a try. This place is so cute. Everyone was so nice and inclusive. From the second I walked in people were coming up to my son and I and letting us know about all the events taking place and activities. The food was good but I only had a small amount so can't speak for most of the food. The activities were catered to kids of all ages and my son loved all of it.
Priyanka K.
Sep 28, 2019
Report
This review is for the molasses crinkle cookie ice cream only. Five stars. It has displaced Gannon's raspberry truffle as my favorite ice cream in the greater Cuse area.
The service was lovely. The lady at the ice cream counter allowed me and friend to sample basically everything. The pumpkin ice cream is also phenomenal. I settled on the molasses crinkle cookie ice cream in a homemade waffle cone...be still my heart.
The other counter serves Kubal coffee, beer and wine and their extended menu. I didn't stay for a meal but it appears they serve breakfast, lunch and dinner.
The
The service was lovely. The lady at the ice cream counter allowed me and friend to sample basically everything. The pumpkin ice cream is also phenomenal. I settled on the molasses crinkle cookie ice cream in a homemade waffle cone...be still my heart.
The other counter serves Kubal coffee, beer and wine and their extended menu. I didn't stay for a meal but it appears they serve breakfast, lunch and dinner.
The
Brian S.
Sep 01, 2019
Report
Found this gem randomly traveling from Auburn to Saratoga. I have two toddler boys and we're often attempting to plan road trips around naps, which can be difficult so adding a meal to that complicates things especially when looking for something other than the usual rest stop fast food. We were ten minutes before the chefs changed over from breakfast to lunch - which is actually the reason for four stars instead of five since by the time we got our food, it was past 11.
We got French toast sticks for the kids - which were crispy and delicious. My wife got a breakfast pizza with egg, sausage
We got French toast sticks for the kids - which were crispy and delicious. My wife got a breakfast pizza with egg, sausage
Deb B.
Jul 14, 2019
Report
Unusual place in he middle of farm fields on the edge of Onondaga and Cayuga counties. Plenty of local and not so local wares to see. The night we stopped for ice cream, there was a square dance class going on in the garden, outside a rather large gazebo-type structure. The cafe serves everything from scones and desserts to meals and the place is huge.
Don't miss the ice cream, locally made and delish! They also were selling local berries, and have a lovely indoor and outdoor eating area. This place is worth a stop when in Elbridge.
Don't miss the ice cream, locally made and delish! They also were selling local berries, and have a lovely indoor and outdoor eating area. This place is worth a stop when in Elbridge.
Jim K.
Jan 15, 2019
Report
This is a review not on the food at Bailiwick as I have not had it, but rather on servI have frequented this place for the coffee in the morning on my ride to work. I believing in supporting local business. However, I can no longer go to this place through their drive thru...I have been the only in the line twice since the first of September and have waited over 8 minutes for a cup of coffee. The last straw was on Friday morning, a car was actually in front of me at the drive thru and I waited 10 minutes and the car was still in front of me. I had to leave. I have heard good things about the food
Steve L.
Jan 05, 2019
Report
I've been back and have rethought my opinion like they are trying to rethink the restaurant business... the restaurant business evolved over the years to a fairly direct model... you arrive, sit, tell the staff what you want and then they bring it, top off your beverages and check back once you've had the food for about a minute, then leave us alone until we want to pay or even leave the check so we don't have to ask for it... it had pretty much worked that way for a few decades that way.
Now come the new generation of thinkers that have redesigned the whole experience except they
Now come the new generation of thinkers that have redesigned the whole experience except they
Judy B.
Dec 10, 2018
Report
Thomas C.
May 13, 2018
Report
Nancy Hourigan envisioned an ice cream stand across from the Tessy Plastics plant on Route 5 in Elbridge. But, that vision grew into the Bailiwick Market and Cafe, an eclectic 4,000 square-foot restaurant/store that sells local merchandise--free range eggs from Elbridge chickens, Wake Robin Farm cheeses from Jordan or 4 Tin Fish Farm cheese from Conquest. The shop has locally produced pottery, fiber art, soap, candles and scents.
Bailiwick means realm of interest; geographical area, and their goal is to create a gathering space for people to connect with others through our shared realm of interest
Bailiwick means realm of interest; geographical area, and their goal is to create a gathering space for people to connect with others through our shared realm of interest
