When it comes to cakes, there are none better than Key West Cakes. Our job is to make your cake the perfect compliment to your Big Day-whatever it may be. From Weddings to Birthdays (and back to Weddings again), since 2001 it has been Key West Cakes' pleasure to make beautiful, delicious cakes and treats for some of the best weddings, parties, and events on the island.
Remember: Key West Cakes are more than just works of art, they taste as delicious as they look. Hand-crafted and baked on-location, we recommend stopping by and seeing for yourself magic being made. We are open Monday through Saturday. And there is always something delightful to taste or take home.
Remember: Key West Cakes are more than just works of art, they taste as delicious as they look. Hand-crafted and baked on-location, we recommend stopping by and seeing for yourself magic being made. We are open Monday through Saturday. And there is always something delightful to taste or take home.
Services
Key West Cakes was founded in 2001 by Paulie & Steven as a specialty cake bakery dedicated to equal parts creativity, presentation, and flavor. Starting small, with a small kitchen and tight-knit group of cake artists, Key West Cakes began in Paul's home kitchen. The rest has been a fairy tale success.
Reviews (20)
Christina E.
Jan 26, 2022
Report
AMAZING CAKES!!!! Steve and his team did an amazing job. Communicated via email we sent them pinterest ideas and they replicated the photos beautifully. We received so many compliments on our two cakes for our wedding, one cake was our traditional wedding cake and the second cake was the grooms cake key lime style. Both were gorgeous and delicious. They worked with out florist to use the flowers on the cake as well and delivered the cakes to the Hemingway Home where our reception was. No issues. Everything was seamless. Definitely recommend. Plus they were able to accommodate our shrinking wedding
Laura Beth Thiele
Jan 25, 2022
Report
Nicole B.
Dec 22, 2021
Report
Laura Sigmon
Dec 22, 2021
Report
We got married in Key West in December. We weren't sure if we wanted a wedding cake and at the last minute, I decided I did. I called Key West Cakes on a Thursday to see if I could get a cake for our wedding the following Tuesday. I was able to get an 8" cake with a cute beach theme delivered to the restaurant for a reasonable price. The cake was Key lime with Key lime mousse filling. It was absolutely delicious!!! There were only 6 of us but I wanted the bigger size so we would have leftovers. We each had a piece for breakfast the next morning. 😋
Norwren K.
Dec 17, 2021
Report
Lisa B.
Nov 28, 2021
Report
I wanted to wait to give these artists a true review until I thawed out the top tier of my wedding cake for my anniversary and was able to judge how well it lasted. It was literally just as delicious as the day we first cut into it. The frosting crystallized on the outer edge just slightly but other than that it was literally identical which was dang impressive. We got a lemon cake with lemon curd and vanilla buttercream and for a hot summer wedding there couldn't have been a better choice!! Thank you guys so much for truly making my wedding magical! You can tell on my husband and I's face just
Kristin Santiago
Nov 26, 2021
Report
Key West Cakes made our wedding cake and it was not only gorgeous, it tasted absolutely amazing! When we went for the tasting a few months ago, there were so many tasty options to pick from. We went with the key lime cake, key lime mousse filling and strawberry filling. Steven was so helpful and quick to respond. He had great ideas and recommendations regarding the layout of our cake and how to cover enough for our guests. Very easy to work with. They added the flowers our florist dropped off onto our cake in such a beautiful way. Our cake was so beautiful and our guests kept saying how good it
Viktoria Molnar
Nov 14, 2021
Report
This bakery is a joke! I ordered a cake topper from them because I made my own cake and I just wanted a cute decoration on the top. (Made my own because they just overload cakes with sugar) They were weird about the order, I guess it’s not common in their store to just order a topper. We specified details and on the day of my event I received a decor that a kindergarten kid could have made better….Not a “professional bakery” Shame!
The bear I asked for ans the one they made:
The bear I asked for ans the one they made:
Angela Kolhagen
Oct 26, 2021
Report
Steven and the team at Key West cakes were amazing to us for our wedding! We originally were going to use another bakery in town, however that business refused to respect the budget we gave and said they couldn’t do a cheaper version of our cake vision. So we found Key West Cakes and I can’t begin to explain how happy we were with our decision. Steven worked with me on what I envisioned for our wedding cake and respected the budget we had. He reassured me everything would be ready and amazing for our special day. We also chose to do small cookie favors for each of our guests, Steven made samples
Darcie Humphries
Oct 24, 2021
Report
The cupcakes were extremely disappointing. This bakery got excellent reviews on facebook, and their cupcakes and cakes are beautiful. However, the cake is not moist, and it is hard and dense, and the frosting is heavy and not tasty. If you're going to be a renowned cupcake shop, the basics of the cupcake should be impeccable, and it was subpar. We bought 4 cupcakes and were extremely disappointed in ALL of them. We gave them a chance.
There was one gentleman that was extremely nice, patient, and kind. I will say that the service was friendly. But the cupcakes were not good. If you want a beautiful
There was one gentleman that was extremely nice, patient, and kind. I will say that the service was friendly. But the cupcakes were not good. If you want a beautiful
Michael B.
Jun 18, 2021
Report
I'm glad I came across this place again. A few years back Steven made a personalized cake for my partners' birthday. She's always loved to travel & has done a good amount of it. I just planted the thought in Stevens head & left the creativity to him. It was a GREAT cake - not only in its presentation but in taste too!!!
Barb M.
Mar 24, 2021
Report
Sura R.
Dec 31, 2020
Report
Jo H.
Nov 16, 2020
Report
We ordered an 8 inch cake via email for our daughter's small wedding. Steve was responsive in answering questions and when we arrived we gave Steve the cake topper we brought and paid the $100, which included delivery to Sunset Key. The cake was delivered on time with the topper. The cake was delicious!
The only nit was that we ordered German chocolate filling with the funfetti cake with buttercream frosting. The cake that we got did not have any chocolate in it. When I followed up with Steve later he replied they don't usually put chocolate filling in a cake unless the cake itself
The only nit was that we ordered German chocolate filling with the funfetti cake with buttercream frosting. The cake that we got did not have any chocolate in it. When I followed up with Steve later he replied they don't usually put chocolate filling in a cake unless the cake itself
Ihona Gonzalez
Oct 16, 2020
Report
My experience with Key West Cakes was EXCELLENT! Their customer services is superb, they were a joy to do business with. They created a beautiful cake for my daughter’s first birthday, and the taste was amazing. We choose coconut cake with cannoli filling and it did not disappoint. I will certainly be back in the future!
Mark L.
Oct 04, 2020
Report
Christy M.
Mar 07, 2020
Report
Owner and staff were so helpful and appreciative of my order. I wanted to give my wife a wonderful birthday cake and she enjoys yellow cake and chocolate icing. They made a basic birthday cake into a delicious, moist cake and she was so excited with the decoration and the taste of the cake. She said this was the best birthday cake she has ever had! I would definitely recommend Key West cakes to anyone in the area looking for a delicious cake. Thank you and we will definitely be back next time we are in town!
Ken
Ken
Myles W.
Feb 23, 2020
Report
It wasn't what I expected from a highly rated bakery. The I tried 4 different cupcakes a brownie and slice of chocolate cake. Unfortunately the flavor of everything reminded me of something I could buy for half the price from a local grocery store. The presentation of the cupcakes and everything was pretty but it didn't make them taste better I must say. It either was lacking flavor or was too overpowering in flavor and I'm not talking too sweet either. It's a bit pricey but the cupcakes are twice the size you would find anywhere else.
Jen V.
Jan 09, 2020
Report
Kris H.
Sep 07, 2019
Report
Key West Cakes is amazing!
I live in TX & wanted to order a cake for a friend's 50th birthday that we were going to celebrate while on vacation in Key West.
I saw the great reviews on Yelp and contacted Key West Cakes. After speaking & emailing Steven he was able to bake a cake that was delicious and exactly what I envisioned!!
I highly recommend Key West Cakes!
I live in TX & wanted to order a cake for a friend's 50th birthday that we were going to celebrate while on vacation in Key West.
I saw the great reviews on Yelp and contacted Key West Cakes. After speaking & emailing Steven he was able to bake a cake that was delicious and exactly what I envisioned!!
I highly recommend Key West Cakes!