data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/15e89/15e8982c9336680a3ed6853bc835f0c826706bff" alt="Cerrone's Brick Oven Pizzeria"
Awarded BEST IN THE SOUTHEAST 2019 10th in the World in our Division & 3rd Place in the South East 2016 & 2017 & 2018 in the International Pizza Challenge! We are locally owned and operated serving the only true to region, authentic New York brick oven pizza in Columbus. All our items are prepared by hand daily from the freshest imported Italian and domestic ingredients available.
Wood fired in our Brick oven brought down from New York. Our goal is to make Authentic New York brick oven pizza using quality ingredients and traditional methods.
Wood fired in our Brick oven brought down from New York. Our goal is to make Authentic New York brick oven pizza using quality ingredients and traditional methods.
Reviews (10)
Floyd Moon
Dec 18, 2021
Report
Zach Steinsberger
Nov 29, 2021
Report
Chris Collier
Aug 28, 2021
Report
Angie White
Jul 17, 2021
Report
I ordered online through their website. I got there a little early but they were extremely busy. My food was ready at the exact moment that my confirmation email said it would be ready. I ordered the meatballs and a Supreme pizza. Let me tell you, it was no less than amazing. The meatballs were HUGE and so tasty. And the pizza was delicious. My husband doesn't like bell peppers but he said it was so good, even with bell peppers. Definitely 5 stars.
Noel Lucas
Dec 31, 2020
Report
Stopped by for lunch with my son today while letting him play hooky from school and let him have a fun day. We have been wanting to try it out for a while, but always forgot about it. When we walked in, you could tell it was going to be something special, just from the "vibe" and looks of the place. If you are a pizza connoisseur, the menu will be a pleasant surprise alone, based on the wide variety. I've always been a huge fan of Mellow Mushroom's Buffalo Chicken pizza with bacon. So, with that high standard, I ordered a small version of it here, and my son went with the old reliable small pepperoni
Resting Sad Face
Jul 30, 2020
Report
My family and I have been coming here for about three years now, and for good reason. we absolutely love it. I can say without a doubt that this is our favorite pizza place, easily that best pizza I’ve had in my life. my mother and I come here weekly to eat and relax, and the environment does provide the atmosphere. we love the staff and always feel welcome. incredibly friendly and open. 10/10 would recommend :)
ps. Shaun’s the real og 👌
We will miss you guys. There is no other Pizza like yours🔥🦑🔥
ps. Shaun’s the real og 👌
We will miss you guys. There is no other Pizza like yours🔥🦑🔥
Michele Kendall
Jun 04, 2020
Report
Becky M.
Sep 27, 2019
Report
Paige Annen
Sep 07, 2019
Report
An hour and fifteen minutes total wait from the time I ordered online. Thirty minutes past the time it was read when I placed the order. No one came to apologize for the delay, or to check on us. My husband went to the back area twice to see the two cashiers and the manager not helping, but distracting the people cooking. And two of our pizzas were incorrect according to the menu. The first picture is "supposed" to be a supreme and the second is the margherita. This is our third or fourth time getting pizza from here and I'm pretty disappointed in the service tonight. I understand it's the night
Makayla Frias
Jun 12, 2016
Report
Very nice staff, welcoming entrance, they played Frank Sinatra (personally love Frank, so this was a plus), it was a great atmosphere for pizza. The food itself was okay. I would not recommend buying the meatball appetizer. $8.95 for 5 meatballs, kinda overpriced and they weren't exactly the tastiest. They were okay. I also ordered the Personal Hawaiian pizza ($11.95) it was okay, too. The crust was perfect, the cheese was not too excessive, but the most important piece to the pie (the marinara sauce) felt like it was missing something. It was overall an okay pizza, just felt like the sauce was