What's Cooking Cafe
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
What's Cooking Cafe
What's Cooking Cafe is the culmination of a decade of care and development by Anna Martinelli and her mom, Kathy. Anna has been cooking and baking since she was 6 years old. Her public debut came when she created some beautiful cupcakes for her brother Robby's graduation party. The guests were so impressed with the taste and appearance of her cupcakes, that Anna started receiving requests to bake for other parties.

She was 16 years old at the time. Now Anna is a graduate of Art Institute of Pittsburgh's Culinary School specializing in baking and pastries. In 2015, Anna and Kathy opened What's Cooking Cafe in the old Goshen Dairy building in New Philadelphia.
Services
We love celebrations. There are only so many opportunities in live to have a party, and we hate to let one pass by without making it into something special. Whether it's a ninth birthday, a retirement party, a housewarming get-together or a going away party, we can help create the perfect cake to make it feel just as special as it really is.
Is there any better celebration than a wedding? At What's Cooking Cafe we love to contribute a centerpiece to this amazing party. We can do something as simple or as complex as you like, but no matter what, it will be a taste to remember. Our wedding cake process starts with a sit-down meeting with Anna.
Cupcakes make an easy dessert option for any occasion. At graduation parties, they make an easy-to-serve alternative to a traditional sheet cake. At a wedding, they make a great addition to a wedding cake, allowing guests with gluten allergies or other taste preferences to have just the kind of cake they want.
Reviews (17)
Jan 17, 2022
Report
The peanut butter pie is outstanding! I'm eating it while typing this review. You won't regret it.
Olivia Weaver
Olivia Weaver
Dec 26, 2021
Report
We decided to try it out for lunch, and i will never be going back. If you want food under five minutes, this is your place to go. You can get better food for less money at McDonalds. I got a bowl of gross Macaroni and Cheese and a pepsi for almost $7!! Insane.
Molly Boland
Molly Boland
Dec 25, 2021
Report
Great atmosphere, friendly people, good sweets (lemon cookies) but the sandwich, salad, and coffee left a lot to be desired.
Jason Sanchez
Jason Sanchez
Oct 24, 2021
Report
Good service, good food, nice staff. The Mac n cheese was like soup tho.
Gordon Shumway
Gordon Shumway
Sep 22, 2021
Report
Everything I’ve ever had here has been outstanding. When we have friends come in from out of town we always direct them here for lunch. Super friendly staff and very talented bakers.
Roksanna Stephens
Roksanna Stephens
Aug 27, 2021
Report
Stopped in and had an early dinner with a friend. This place had great tasting food. The art was fun!
Angelika Fish
Angelika Fish
Aug 12, 2021
Report
Very delicious food. Friendly staff great customer service. Clean and beautiful. Cozy place
Kelly Bruzzese
Kelly Bruzzese
Apr 13, 2021
Report
What’s Cooking Cafe did an array of Italian cookies for my wedding reception and they were so delicious. My only regret is that we didn’t order more!
Ordering and delivery to the venue was easy and seamless. Highly recommend.
Fubeezy
Fubeezy
Mar 28, 2021
Report
Was super awesome! Service perfect! Super good lunch specials to cater to all.... plus a bonus being a bakery too... highly recommended! Trust me on this one! It's worth a lunch break.
Lynn Gilland
Lynn Gilland
Feb 21, 2021
Report
Love this place! Anna made a delicious cake and cupcakes for my husband’s birthday. There lunch menu is great! My favorite lunchtime spot! Their Turkey Rueben is so yummy!
Travis N. Brandi Frye
Travis N. Brandi Frye
Dec 29, 2020
Report
The cinnamon roll cheesecake I bought for Christmas dinner was awesome!
Melly West
Melly West
Aug 27, 2020
Report
I order doordash from home all the time and what's cooking helps me make sure I'm eating a balanced meal that is fresh. The food always has that homemade taste and it's so good!
Bethanie Staley Moser
Bethanie Staley Moser
May 14, 2020
Report
Anna and her staff are always warm, welcoming, and serving up delicious food! Tonight we had the Hungarian stuffed peppers and they were fantastic! I highly recommend!!!
Emily Hope
Emily Hope
May 11, 2020
Report
My Mother’s Day Brunch was Amazing! Thank you so much Anna! The Italian quiche and strawberries and cream cheesecake were to die for!! It was gluten free also!! So many compliments, and people going for seconds!! Thank you for a stress free brunch!!
June Contini
June Contini
May 01, 2020
Report
OMG!!! I just ate the best chicken pot pie ever! Spectacular!! So fresh, light, creamy ...the taste is perfect! This brought pure pleasure & comfort on this gloomy May 1st day!
Walter Esese
Walter Esese
Oct 06, 2019
Report
The food was fantastic! The staff we're also super friendly. The me u prices also felt like they were at a good spot for the quality of food and atmosphere you got. Would definitely recommend.
G. P.
G. P.
Sep 13, 2019
Report
Loved everything ! The best tiramisu, scone, and the espresso. The staff was so kind and the service was impeccable. I also loved the coffee selection. A perfect treat for any morning.