Name: Crooked Lake Mercantile
Address: [3682 - 3698] State Route 54A, Branchport, NY, 14418, US
Telephone: (315) 595-2233
Rating: 4.11

We are located at the four corners of Branchport, on the northwest branch of Keuka Lake, in the beautiful Finger Lakes region of Upstate New York. Since 1993 we have been serving the public in our 1890's country store. A full line of groceries and home staples, to accommodate your every need, can be found on the wooden shelves of yesteryear.

If we don't have it, we can get it. Our deli and bakery features homemade goodies for you to enjoy either here, amidst our warm and welcoming atmosphere, or packed for your picnic elsewhere. Shop All Things Keuka! - gifts, souvenirs, men's, women's, and children's apparel, toys and so much more are interspersed throughout our store.

Website Update

Services

Deli / Bakery Report

We are located at the four corners of Branchport, on the northwest branch of Keuka Lake, in the beautiful Finger Lakes region of Upstate New York. Since 1993 we have been serving the public in our 1890's country store. All things Keuka, gifts, souvenirs, men's, women's and children's apparel, toys and so much more are interspersed throughout our store.

Reviews (9)

Write a Review

K. Millsey

Sep 05, 2021

Report

Lots of merchandise Keuka related and beyond....worth a stop!! Friendly staff and the place smells great!!

Jan Kline

Sep 01, 2021

Report

If you want Keuka lake memorabilia, this is the place for you. There are 2 floors and even a cafe. They have coffee mugs, shot glasses, all kinds of clothes and it's even a convenience store. It's has good quality merchandise so you will pay a little more

Spy K.

Aug 23, 2021

Report

So many great things in this store. Everything from Breakfast Sandwiches to boat tubes. Make sure you swing by!

Major Air

Jul 27, 2021

Report

HUGE selection of clothing and other souvenirs! Go upstairs for clearance. 30% off, or buy 3 or more to get 50% off.

Lori Cookjohnson

Jul 26, 2021

Report

Great place! They actually have a lot of stuff there for a small town! They have nice quality merchandise. A little pricey but I guess everything is everywhere now a days! They have stuff for the lake plus some food stuff.

Caleb Bulriss

Jul 25, 2021

Report

Awesome store tons of extremely cool things more geared towards tourist however they make great Subs and I bought some lures there that I actually used to catch a big bass they were made locally

Win R.

Dec 09, 2019

Report

The women who ran the store were super mean. I walked in with my aunt and my two special cousins and they followed use around and kept badmouthing us to other customers. It did not feel like a friendly environment. The women were following us around like they were expecting us to break something and they started making fun and laughing about my two special cousins while they were out of the store and I was still looking around. Will never EVER shop there again.

Dj Wright

Dec 05, 2019

Report

Omg the absolute best sandwiches you'll ever eat. I don't care much for bread but that fresh baked bread is so delicious. My car automatically stops there if we are in the area lol

Barlow Rhodes

Aug 22, 2018

Report

We had excellent sandwiches there. The store has many souvenirs related to Keuka Lake. A very interesting store in an old recycled building in an old but well cared for town.