The Pie
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Customer service, quality taste of food, in a good family atmosphere would be key to a great pizza restaurant. Many nights were spent in the kitchen developing unique recipes and ways of doing things, all in the name of good taste. If Mark didn't like it, no one would like it. In 2003 they celebrated the opening of their first store in Barnesville, GA and telephones haven't stopped ringing yet!

Over the past 7 years American Pie Pizzeria has expanded to 6 locations with more on the horizon. Since childhood brothers, Mark, Joey, Billy and Matt Lane absolutely loved pizza, after all most kids do. Growing up in southern California, Mark and family would eat a couple times a week, as Mark recalls eating at Pizza Challet, Shakey's Pizza and of course Pizza Hut.
Reviews (10)
Ashley Hursey
Ashley Hursey
Jan 24, 2022
Report
We got a small pepperoni pizza and an order of butter balls. Food was great and the wait wasn't bad.
Gage Dobek
Gage Dobek
Jan 21, 2022
Report
Very good food and service... buutttt... very high in price. Maybe good for like a once in a blue moon pizza.
Tj Mizel
Tj Mizel
Jan 19, 2022
Report
Normal buffet pizza not amazing but good.staff asked if we wanted anything specific put out and we asked for bbq and buffalo chicken pizza and they had it out in minutes which is A+ service
Amelia
Amelia
Nov 26, 2021
Report
Best pizza place in town to me honestly ! We always order the large 24” pizza with a cinnamon pizza and let me tell you the cinnamon pizza is the best !! We’ve only had the pepperoni and Hawaiian pizza and they’re both good . Family oriented, friendly staff . Definitely check them out .
Jade Gordy
Jade Gordy
Nov 13, 2021
Report
THE ONLY PIZZA PLACE I EAT AT!!!!!!! the 🍕 is AHHHHHMAZING, and everyone that works there is great, and super friendly. LOVE IT!! I highly recommend you try it if you haven't yet!!!
C. L. Holloway
C. L. Holloway
Sep 02, 2021
Report
Monday is all you can eat night and I've been wanting pizza for weeks. So tonight was the perfect time to get some. The price has gone up since the last time I've been on all you can eat night but who hasn't gone up! There are several types of pizza to choose from. It's pizza! Good but not great but I will return! I recommend going! Have a great day❣️
Collyn Archer
Collyn Archer
Jul 14, 2021
Report
Food is decent. Not a ton of options in the area. My husband and his friends like it. I’d probably like it more if they paid attention in the kitchen... Ordering something vegetarian (veggie wrap or asking specifically for no bacon on my pizza) apparently means sprinkle ALL the bacon on my food. 2/3 visits this has happened to me. I’m reaching my limit. Not to mention during this last visit my wrap came out 13 minutes after my husbands pizza… I had to check to see if they forgot to make it.
Selena Nicholson
Selena Nicholson
May 30, 2021
Report
It was good as far as pizza places go. Our son ordered a calzone, it had very little meat or taste. The same can be said for the rest of the good that we ordered. On a side note, while we waited almost 30-45 minutes for our food to be brought out to us and I understand that it is a pizza place and everything is cooked and made when you order it, I watched one employee go out of the kitchen several times to deliver food to cars&tables,retrieve boxes from the store room,go back into the kitchen and handle food without ever changing his gloves once. He never changed his gloves or washed his hands
Talena S.
Talena S.
Aug 02, 2016
Report
They serve fantastic Pizza! Our family enjoys eating here regularly. On Monday evening they have a dinner buffet...and also for lunch daily I believe. You need to try their butterballs in buttery garlic sauce. The prices are reasonable. Clean restaurant with friendly staff.
James M.
James M.
Oct 23, 2012
Report
Gooooood pizza, calzone, betty salad is the bomb, and butter balls. mmmmmm