Home of the traditional handmade bagels baked fresh daily. Tucked away in the Southwest corner of our great state, we are one of Peterborough's best kept secrets since 1996. Our cozy atmosphere provides the perfect place for a casual Breakfast, Lunch, or quick cup of coffee. Welcome to the Bagel Mill!
Start your day off right with your favorite bagel, fresh out of the oven, topped with one of our multiple delicious spreads! Not only are our signature sandwiches second to none, but we also cook up freshest hearty soup for those extra cold New England days.
Start your day off right with your favorite bagel, fresh out of the oven, topped with one of our multiple delicious spreads! Not only are our signature sandwiches second to none, but we also cook up freshest hearty soup for those extra cold New England days.
Reviews (9)
Joseph Leone
Jan 02, 2022
Report
My wife grew up going to bagel Mill and I’m sure at one point it was great but I have to say it’s awful for anyone who truly loves bagels. The bagels are about the size of Lenders bagel minis. They barely warm them thru the toaster. You have to ask for them toasted dark to have them toasted at all. The croissants are tiny as well and didn’t seem worth the money. Shame shame shame.
Shirl Katherine
Jan 02, 2022
Report
My husband really likes getting an everything bagel with cream cheese and salmon. I used to like their apple crunch bagels, but they have changed the recipe and it’s no where near as good. The other thing I really don’t like, is that they microwave the eggs (straight from the shell) for breakfast sandwiches. It makes it such a weird texture and just doesn’t taste good. It really wouldn’t take much longer to make the eggs in a skillet. Or even make them and put them in a warmer for the busy times, if it’s not always possible to make them to order.
Bethany Paquin
Dec 05, 2021
Report
Susan Ruch
Oct 04, 2021
Report
Bagels and cream cheese are always freshly made and soooo satisfying! My recent fave is cinnamon raisin with plain cream cheese! My honey's is toasted poppy with bacon horseradish cream cheese! Great coffee, teas, should and sandwiches! Great staff, always friendly! THANK YOU to the guy who gets there at 3:00 AM To start making the bagels!!
Chris Ramsey
May 22, 2021
Report
Wayne Jacques
Apr 02, 2021
Report
Lisa Marie
Apr 01, 2021
Report
Audrey L.
Jul 29, 2020
Report
Greg Yerkes
Nov 10, 2019
Report
Been going here for years, cozy atmosphere and the bagels are good, but the coffee is pretty meh. New England coffee, so there is only so much you can do with it I suppose. But everything bagels are great here. Thicker, smaller sizes bagels, plenty of cream cheese. Scallion is good, haven't had the lox yet, but will try next time. Good egg sandwich too. Juices are bottled Nantucket nectar juices
