Pagliai's Pizza
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Pagliai's Pizza
Enjoy incredible pizza made using only the freshest ingredients at Pagliai's Pizza. Whether you're dining in or picking up an order for takeout, you can count on our locally owned and operated restaurant to provide you with a dining experience like never before. Enjoy exquisite cuisine made fresh daily using local produce and meats; all sausages and cheeses are made fresh on premises.

Enjoy your favorite dishes whenever you like; we're open seven days a week for your convenience. Stop by our restaurant and dine with us. Established in 1964, Pagliai's Pizza is a locally owned and operated restaurant offering mouthwatering pizzas and much more. We've been serving delectable pizzas for over 50 years.
Services
The origin of Pagliai's Pizza dates back to 1955 when the original Pagliai's was opened in Ames, IA by Sam and Delores Pagliai. There were a total of 26 storefronts sprinkled around many small college towns throughout the Midwest. Many of those stores are still operating and very much in business. Established in 1964, Pagliai's Pizza is a locally owned and operated restaurant offering mouthwatering pizzas and much more.
There's no sincere love than the love of food! When your belly demands a break from your daily diet, stop by Pagliai's Pizza for a plateful of heavenly pizza. We offer an assorted menu of mouthwatering pizzas and more, made by our amazing chefs using fresh ingredients and a pinch of love. Whether you want to throw a feast for your family and friends or simply want to enjoy the delicacy all by yourself, Pagliai's Pizza is your go-to restaurant.
Take a moment to read through some of our testimonials and see what our happy customers have to say about Pagliai's Pizza. Count on over 50 years of experience, our commitment to quality, and fresh ingredients to give you a dining experience like no other. Check out our Wednesday specials. Visit us today!
Reviews (10)
Abbey Cimarolli
Abbey Cimarolli
Jan 27, 2022
Report
Staff was so incredibly friendly and inviting. It was my first time here and service and food was amazing. So highly recommend
Amy Warman
Amy Warman
Jan 17, 2022
Report
Pagliai's has always been my favorite! In addition to being the best pizza out there, they are fast & offer great service!
Danielle Connour
Danielle Connour
Jan 13, 2022
Report
I always loved coming here with my family as a kid and now as an adult I still love to come here with my own family. Great food, decor, and service. This place has been a town favorite for years. I wish them many more years to come.
Laurie Browning
Laurie Browning
Nov 15, 2021
Report
Very good food. Very cheap. More food than I could eat. The waitress seemed kinda stressed. Just asked for some utensils. Kept telling us they'd been busy and running off. Apologized multiple times. Hope everything's good. Make sure you check on your staff btw.
Renate Ping
Renate Ping
Nov 10, 2021
Report
Always great food and fun staff. The pizza is flavorful and cooked to perfection. Be sure you indulge in the cheese sticks (breadsticks with cheese) along with the marinara and garlic butter. You won't be disappointed. A great Saturday evening dinner.
Tony Reeley
Tony Reeley
Sep 23, 2021
Report
Pagliai's pizza is the best! The thick crust House Special or thin crust Pagliai's Special. You can't go wrong!
Jamie Barthelme
Jamie Barthelme
Aug 22, 2021
Report
Frustrating, every time we've called they have their phone off the hook until 7pm. The manager complains about not having enough staff, but then you never see him there either. No wonder why they can't find delivery drivers. They have them doing dishes for minimum wage instead of making deliveries and earning tips. The place has great food, but is very poorly run under the new management.
Brian Werner
Brian Werner
Jul 25, 2021
Report
By far my favorite place to eat pizza.I travel alot, and always make it a point to stop in for their one of a kind pizza. Absolutely love it.
Candy Meltzer
Candy Meltzer
Jul 20, 2021
Report
Won't be back again. Thick crust pizza was still raw, very little sauce on it, asked 3 times for plates. They made no attempt to rectify the situation on an inedible product. Manager and staff did not care about their service or product provided. It's one thing to be understaffed, it's another to provide food that is raw. They offered a discount but price paid was still full price. They even charged for a glass of water.
Joy Kaurin
Joy Kaurin
Jun 15, 2021
Report
Wonderful pizza! The house special is our favorite. It can be super busy and you may have to order in person instead of by phone.