Supreme Awards
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Supreme Awards
Located in historic downtown Baraboo, WI we invite you to visit our shop and browse the hundreds of gift and award items on display. If visiting is not an option, then this website is for you. Supreme Awards features some of the finest quality awards and gifts on the market today. We have built our reputation on quality and service; quality of the product and service to our customers.

We know the importance of your awards presentation whether it is a youth sports party or a corporate banquet. We make sure that your event is a success! We recognize the importance of each individual award and realize that each award has a special meaning to the recipient. At Supreme Awards, assembly and engraving is done in-house, which allows for quick turnaround times if needed.
Services
Supreme Awards has been promoting excellence in Baraboo and the surrounding area since 1983. We are committed to providing the highest level of quality and service for the best price available. To achieve that goal we strongly believe in the importance of continuing education.

Supreme Awards has been a member of the Awards and Personalization Association since 1989 and regularly attends the national trade show and convention where seminars are presented on such topics as graphic design, engraving techniques, marketing and customer service.Jean Sandmire earned her Certified Recognition Specialist (CRS) certification in 2003.
Communication is very critical to ensure your order is done correctly. Therefore, we have not designed our website with a shopping cart. We want to personally communicate with you on your order. Normal production time for most orders is 5-7 working days. Large orders or custom designed pieces can take longer and will be quoted prior to production.
Reviews (9)
Lydia Cahill
Lydia Cahill
Dec 23, 2021
Report
They turned around a very special item for us in less than 8 hours. Customer service was amazing.
Scott L.
Scott L.
Jan 22, 2020
Report
Never been there before. The window display attracted me to come in the store. Jean was wonderful. She helped me with a custom plate for a trophy I was making. He idea on plate color was great. turned out wonderful. This was a fun NFL trophy.
Joey Vw
Joey Vw
Jan 12, 2020
Report
Jean was very nice to work with. She does a great job making sure you're taken care of. 5 stars all the way!
Miller Miller
Miller Miller
Dec 30, 2019
Report
My company has worked with Supreme Awards for many years. Jean and her staff keep excellent records, which helps keep me organized. They go out of their way to provide superb service. Just last Thursday was tasked with getting a personalized retirement award by Friday. Supreme Awards came to the rescue!
Katie Cook
Katie Cook
Dec 07, 2019
Report
I have been working with Supreme Awards for years for trophies, plaques, medals, and special awards and they do fantastic work. Excellent customer service, they keep awesome records, and are just really wonderful to work with. Their experience can't be beat especially when you need some ideas or recommendations.
Chris
Chris
Dec 02, 2019
Report
I bought an award from them and the two name plates were crooked and not centered. when i took it in they said " its not that off" we cant really fix it . You should win the award for the worst customer service. I am going to use a dot com from now on. UPDATE they fixed the bottom but didnt touch the top . Nothing supreme about that.
Dan Kremer
Dan Kremer
Sep 25, 2019
Report
Some of the fastest and most sincere service you will find! Great people and great products!
David Hutchens
David Hutchens
Jan 23, 2018
Report
Used to have monogram engraved on gifts. Done in a reasonable and timely fashion. Work done was perfect.
Candice Wandice
Candice Wandice
Jul 14, 2014
Report
I requested a very... unusual phrase to be engraved on a pen last Christmas. The owner was extremely accommodating and had a great sense of humor about it. She was awesome. The pen turned out beautifully. The price was very reasonable. I would definitely go back and I would recommend her services to friends.