Preferred Insurance
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Preferred Insurance
Our customer driven approach to insurance centers on educating our clients on the best coverage and price options, while putting the utmost importance on providing the personal service you deserve! Preferred Insurance Opportunities, Inc. is an independent insurance agency located in New Ulm, MN serving the south-west Minnesota area, including Courtland, Nicollet, Mankato, Sleepy Eye, Springfield, Winthrop and Madelia.

I looked at 3 local insurance agencies to get a policy which would fit the needs of a family member. Not only was Nick the first one to get back to me with a few different options, he came in as the best value and fit our needs. Great integrity and customer service!
Services
With a combined 50 years of industry experience, and equipped with multiple top-rated insurance carriers, we take a thorough approach to assessing your personal and business insurance needs, to provide solutions that are tailored to fit you! Our mission is simple, to prove a true client experience that is unique in the insurance industry.
A personal umbrella, or umbrella policy is an additional liability policy meant to protect you from large liability claims. The umbrella coverage "kicks in" after liability limits on your auto or homeowners policy have been exhausted or reached to provide additional liability coverage to a specified amount.
Car and truck insurance in New Ulm, Courtland, Nicollet, Mankato, Sleepy Eye, Winthrop, and Madelia, MN. Your vehicle often is one of the biggest assets you own aside from your home. Therefore protecting our cars/trucks, the people we transport, and the rest of our assets becomes of the utmost importance.
Your home isn't just a place you rest your head, it's where we raise our families, spend time with family and friends, and build memories. But for most of us, our house presents our biggest personal investment and asset. That's why its important to insure it correctly!

This is where we come in, at Preferred Insurance we will work with you to evaluate all the coverage and risks you face in order to craft a policy that protects you, and your biggest asset in life!Dwelling Coverage, sometimes rereferred to as Coverage A is value your home is insured for in the event that it is damaged or destroyed due to a covered peril like fire, lighting, wind, or hail.
At Preferred Insurance, we love our "toys" just as much as you! Time spent on the open road, or blasting through trails in the great outdoors represents a feeling of freedom, and a break from the everyday hustle and bustle. Our customers take great pride in their recreational vehicles, that's why property insuring them is vital so that time spent riding them is as enjoyable as possible!
Reviews (10)
Trisha Homan
Trisha Homan
Nov 29, 2021
Report
We worked with Nick who did a great job helping is with our auto and homeowner insurance. He was personable, professional and made everything very easy.
Mitch Bockenstedt
Mitch Bockenstedt
Jul 18, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Value
They did a great job tailoring coverage to my families needs and were able to get us better coverage with a lower price
Marie Jay
Marie Jay
Jun 30, 2021
Report
Nick was very efficient and courteous! He helped us with not only our personal auto insurance but also our commercial insurance and saved us a lot of money from our previous policy! I would highly recommend him!
Lacey Lueth
Lacey Lueth
Jun 03, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
In the past two years I have switched all of my home and auto insurance over to Preffered Insuranace of New Ulm. Service is quick, someone always replies, and I get all of my questions answered within a few hours. Prices are competitive, but it's the service that can't be beat!
Lee Schissel
Lee Schissel
May 15, 2021
Report
Very professional and had every thing done on time with little effort for me. Nick was great to work with.
T. Lyons
T. Lyons
May 02, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
I called Preferred Insurance for assistance with a possible claim and Nick was more than helpful in assisting me navigate that process. Ultimately I did not need to file, but the prompt and courteous assistance was much appreciated. Thank you!
Sol D.
Sol D.
Apr 14, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
I looked at 3 local insurance agencies to get an policy which would fit the needs of a family member. Not only was Nick the first one to get back to me with a few different options, he came in as the best value and fit for our needs. Great integrity and customer service!
Erik Magelee
Erik Magelee
Apr 14, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness, Value
I have nothing but great things to say about preferred insurance. I have worked with them for my business since 2005 and they are always right there when you need them. Very responsive and helpful. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for business insurance!
Lindsay Henn
Lindsay Henn
Oct 27, 2020
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Working with Nick at Preferred Insurance has been such a pleasure! As a first time business owner, this team made choosing the right policy simple and were quick to answer any questions I had. They are very knowledgeable in their field and I would highly recommend this business for any insurance needs!!
Jessica Sandey Jess
Jessica Sandey Jess
Sep 18, 2020
Report
I have been with Preferred Insurance for so long now and I love it. Not only have I been a long time customer, but my mom also has been, and they know both of us by name! They also made my transition from being on my mom's auto insurance very simple to get on my own and bundle with my renters insurance. Every time you reach out via phone/email/in person, the friendly staff are always there to answer and help with anything needed. There is never any pressure with what plans to sign up for, and being new to learning about insurance, they answered all my questions thoughtfully, and clearly (even the