We started Fairy Cakes as a catering business in 2007. While we started baking out of a commercial kitchen, doing farmer's markets private events, it was always our dream to open a storefront. In 2011, we opened our Parkside Ave Cupcakery and bakeshop. We are proudly a from scratch cupcakery and bakeshop, and use only the best ingredients.
We have been featured on Cooking Channel's Cupcake Showdown and Cheap Eats. We are a family friendly, full service bakeshop, and would love to help you realize all of your dessert dreams! Our shop is located in the beautiful Parkside neighborhood of Buffalo, NY. We are a short walk from the Buffalo Zoo, Delaware Park, and Frank Lloyd Wright's Darwin Martin House.
We have been featured on Cooking Channel's Cupcake Showdown and Cheap Eats. We are a family friendly, full service bakeshop, and would love to help you realize all of your dessert dreams! Our shop is located in the beautiful Parkside neighborhood of Buffalo, NY. We are a short walk from the Buffalo Zoo, Delaware Park, and Frank Lloyd Wright's Darwin Martin House.
Services
Macaron are available in almost any color and flavor. All of our frosting and fillings and almost all of our specialty cupcakes can be adapted into a macaron flavor. If you are ordering for an event, flavors do not have to match colors- they can instead match your event colors. You can order specific color and flavor macaron by the dozen.
Please include any favorite desserts, any styles you are interested in, or any colors to be included. For cake/cupcake tastings, please choose up to five cake and five frosting flavors from the menu under our cupcakes tab. If you would like to try a specialty cupcake, count it as a cake and a frosting.
Whether you simply need more space to hold a party, you want us to do the work for you, or you want a fun day out with friends, you can find what you need at Fairy Cakes! Don't see exactly what you're looking for? Give us a call and we can discuss other options. Have your child's next birthday party at Fairy Cakes!
Fairy Cakes was founded by Kelly, and soon joined by Mo, primarily with a focus on cupcakes that had a from scratch, home baked taste, with a mix of classic and creative flavors. After a couple years of baking out of a commercial kitchen, doing the Downtown Country Market, and delivering special orders, we opened our shop on Parkside Ave in 2011.
Fairy Cakes is open for Weekly Shop Preorders Fridays and Saturdays from 10am-2pm, and for walk in traffic Saturdays only from 10am-2pm. You may come in to pick up your order, or call 716.688.0361 when you arrive for curbside pickup. For special orders Wednesdays through Saturdays, please email fairycakesbuffalo@gmail.com.
Reviews (10)
Betsy Juhasz
Dec 31, 2021
Report
Lisa Gibbons
Nov 30, 2021
Report
Christine G.
Nov 23, 2021
Report
My daughter ordered several items for Thanksgiving and while the cookies and white chocolate wreath were very good, the $36 apple pie was not good at ALL and was thrown out with only one piece cut out. It was over-powered with lemon flavoring which was awful and you didn’t get the apple pie taste. Several of us tried the piece and all agreed. We will not purchase this type of pie from there again.
Mary McLean
Nov 16, 2021
Report
From start to finish Fairy Cakes impressed us every step of the way!
Kelly was our contact and she was amazing! So attentive, so helpful and always a joy to work with.
We met with her and she offered us many ideas, suggestions and guidance on creating the perfect dessert table; one with variety, cohesiveness and the appropriate amount for our number of guests.
When we arrived at the reception, I was speechless! The table was perfection! The wedding decor was black and white and every dessert, every stand and every detail complimented the modern, yet classic theme.
The Fairy Cakes creations
Kelly was our contact and she was amazing! So attentive, so helpful and always a joy to work with.
We met with her and she offered us many ideas, suggestions and guidance on creating the perfect dessert table; one with variety, cohesiveness and the appropriate amount for our number of guests.
When we arrived at the reception, I was speechless! The table was perfection! The wedding decor was black and white and every dessert, every stand and every detail complimented the modern, yet classic theme.
The Fairy Cakes creations
Rachel Vaccaro
May 12, 2021
Report
I Love Love Love Fairy Cakes!
If you live in the Buffalo area and have never been, do yourself a favor and visit Fairy Cakes the next time you are craving something sweet. Their cupcakes are creative, gorgeous and delicious!! They also make some of the BEST macarons in the area! ❤️❤️ I recently pre-ordered some treats for Mother's Day and they were a hit!! As a fellow baker, I can be a bit pickey when it comes to baked goods However, Fairy Cakes never disappoints. They are masterful in their craft and you can tell they know how to make quality pastries. Their baked goods are absolutely
If you live in the Buffalo area and have never been, do yourself a favor and visit Fairy Cakes the next time you are craving something sweet. Their cupcakes are creative, gorgeous and delicious!! They also make some of the BEST macarons in the area! ❤️❤️ I recently pre-ordered some treats for Mother's Day and they were a hit!! As a fellow baker, I can be a bit pickey when it comes to baked goods However, Fairy Cakes never disappoints. They are masterful in their craft and you can tell they know how to make quality pastries. Their baked goods are absolutely
Alex M. Odachowski
Jan 07, 2021
Report
Sara O'Grady
Sep 17, 2020
Report
My dad and I went to this place as a treat, but the cupcakes were just so expensive. We ordered a dozen and paid $47. When we were there there weren't many options, they only had a few flavors. We ordered a few of each thinking we'd try them all, because there were no flavors we really wanted. The cake was really dense, and they didn't seem fresh. Maybe we just caught them on a bad day. The staff were pretty friendly and the red velvet cupcake wasn't too bad (although they only had one and the cake part was kinda dry and stale). The frosting on the red velvet was really nice. Overall, I don't think
Joanne Groves
Jun 04, 2020
Report
Brittany Soemann
Oct 28, 2019
Report
We had Fairy Cakes provide the cupcakes for our wedding last month. We went for a tasting and let me tell you, choosing only a handful of flavors was NOT easy as the possibilities are endless! Kelly & Mo are so friendly and easy to work with. After the wedding our guests raved about the cupcakes. Highly recommend!
Autumn Furmanek
Sep 26, 2017
Report