Willoughby Insurance
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Willoughby Insurance
Willoughby Insurance is your dedicated insurance agency, serving the community of Buffalo and all of Western New York for over 70 Years! As Certified Insurance Counselors, the Willoughbys have the knowledge and expertise to provide an insurance solution to each and every client that offers value, security, and peace of mind.

At Willoughby Insurance, we build trusting partnerships with our customers because we understand that when the unexpected happens, this is the time that you need your insurance company the most. At Willoughby Insurance, our ultimate goal is to create lasting relationships with each of our clients so that we may continue providing excellent service for another 70 years to come.
Services
The Willoughby Insurance team is committed to providing clients with the highest quality insurance services combined with the lowest rates available in your area. The outstanding insurance agents here will work with you one on one to ensure that you get a solution that is tailored specifically to meet your needs.
When it comes to Auto Insurance, there are a wide variety of coverage options and policies available. Whether you are in search of a new policy, shopping around for a better rate, or just have questions about the many types of coverage available, we are here to help you.

For over 60 years, Willoughby Insurance has worked with only the best insurance providers to ensure that each and every client is provided with a quality auto insurance policy at a competitive price.Every motorist in New York is required to have auto insurance, whether you are in Buffalo, Niagara Falls, Tonawanda, Blasdell, or Williamsville.
Your home is a very important investment, and our job is to help you protect it. With home insurance you can protect your home and your possessions inside of it. You've worked hard for what you have and it's very crucial to have the proper protection to safeguard it. There are several options of what home insurance can cover on your property.
Life insurance is an important investment and valuable part of your financial planning, no matter your age or financial situation. Most families do not have savings substantial enough to replace the income of a lost loved one. Life insurance is meant to provide much needed financial security to your family in the event you were to pass away.
Whether you ride a motorcycle to work each and every day, or just enjoy going for a ride on the weekends, New York law requires you to carry motorcycle insurance. Our team of agents at Willoughby Insurance will help you find a motorcycle insurance policy that will protect you and your motorcycle at a great rate.
Reviews (10)
Jennifer Bulczak
Jennifer Bulczak
Jan 06, 2022
Report
After years with another broker promising me lower rates I made the switch to Willoughby. Not only did They save me hundreds, they were also amazing nice, helpful, and patient. I would 100% Strongly suggest that if you're looking for insurance this is the place to go!
Brenden Zaky
Brenden Zaky
Jan 04, 2022
Report
Absolutely amazing experience, every time I call it’s a pleasure and they beat my old rates! Definitely recommend to anyone! Ask for Wendy! She’s the best!
Chuks Remmy
Chuks Remmy
Dec 19, 2021
Report
I am proud to recommend Mrs Cathy Frederick for a selfless and reliable investment service, I was constantly looking for a reliable platform to invest and my friend introduced me to her platform and I realized this is the best platform to invest on because she maintains discipline in her investment, relationship and strategies to ensure the complete transparency and credibility of her investors. if you want to be financially successful invest in her platform now, Contact her Via Email: cathyfrederick867@gmail.com Whatsapp: +18504466717
Warren T. J.
Warren T. J.
Jul 16, 2021
Report
Great customer service and determination to help its customers thanks Willoubhy
Alena Woolcot-Felvus
Alena Woolcot-Felvus
Oct 02, 2020
Report
I will never go through anyone else as long as Willoughby is around. Always able to find you insurance and at the cheapest rate 👏💯
Cheryl W.
Cheryl W.
Jun 08, 2019
Report
Went there with a friend. Staff appeared to be miserable. Parking is tough on Pine Avenue. Never know if they are open unless you hike up the stairs and find a note.
Shakelah Mitchell
Shakelah Mitchell
Jan 15, 2019
Report
They definitely will through I’m feed you don’t know about .. this is why my policy got canceled!!WORST I WOULD NEVER RECOMMEND THEM
Carl Daniels
Carl Daniels
Jun 14, 2018
Report
Always there to help you ,always willing to assist you and your insurance needs
Petros Dross
Petros Dross
Feb 01, 2018
Report
I’ve worked with Willoughby Insurance in the past looking for cheaper motorcycle insurance. I went from a $1000+ year policy, down to $400 a year by shopping with him. Can’t recommend enough.
Joe Irelan
Joe Irelan
Aug 30, 2017
Report
Excellent pricing, excellent service! I have been with him for over 5 years and I have been very pleased with my insurance.