Dine in, carry out, request delivery and catering with Brooklyn Pizzeria! Home to Fayetteville, NC's most superior quality Italian ingredients and preparation, Brooklyn Pizzeria offers pizza-lovers in North Fayetteville, Methodist University, and the Pine Forest community true Brooklyn-style pizza pie.
With over 80 years of experience in the business, we have mastered the authentic art of pizza creation. Our customers can experience a wide variety of authentic pizza pie, garlic knots, and more. Pick up a slice during your lunch break, study break, or have it be the crowd-pleasing favorite at your next party or event.
With over 80 years of experience in the business, we have mastered the authentic art of pizza creation. Our customers can experience a wide variety of authentic pizza pie, garlic knots, and more. Pick up a slice during your lunch break, study break, or have it be the crowd-pleasing favorite at your next party or event.
Reviews (26)
AngJoe Truth
Jan 21, 2022
Report
Cameron -Bowman
Jan 13, 2022
Report
Tracey Moore
Jan 04, 2022
Report
Stage service was good. I’m from Brooklyn, NY and I have eaten a lot of NY pizza. We ordered pizza and garlic knots. In my opinion, the garlic knots needed more garlic. There was very little visible on the knots. The pizza needed a little more sauce. They do not use San Marzano Italian tomatoes in their sauce. At least, I didn’t taste it. NY pizza is known for the distinct taste of the pizza sauce because tomatoes from Italy (San Marzano) are used. I would visit again.
Rebecca Savarese
Jan 02, 2022
Report
Hate to play Gordon Ramsey, but here goes. It's really gone downhill. Dirty inside, disgusting bathrooms that always smell bad. I noticed the toilet hadn't been cleaned with the ring of bacteria inside the bowl. Could use air freshener at least! The tables are not cleaned between customers. A lot of staff stand around, yet the wait times are terrible. Pizza is not great for the prices. One guy seems to be doing all the work! It's like the rest just show up to get paid. With the price increase you have to keep all the plates spinning.
Ali Q.
Jan 01, 2022
Report
Candice T.
Dec 29, 2021
Report
Eileen Taylor
Dec 05, 2021
Report
Hit or miss. Sometimes it’s the best sometimes you want your money back. Not consistent. I’m from NYC and moved here. The first time I tasted this pizza I was sold. The next time, below average. Went 3 days ago and it was hot crispy (I requested) and cheesy. Tonight I got cold unheated slice that was soft and the cheese won’t even move. Smh get consistent
Nathanael Rose
Nov 18, 2021
Report
Lauren Henn
Nov 13, 2021
Report
We ordered takeout, got there within the timeframe, drove 10 min home but the pizza tasted as if it had been sitting out for quite a long time. The crust was extremely thin and soggy and the pizza just didn’t have a great taste. We got the Brooklyn special. We also got the wings which were fine but nothing special. For almost $40 we expected much better. Would recommend going to Elizabeth’s on Skibo instead. We had heard good things about this place but sadly we likely won’t be back.
Mims W.
Oct 24, 2021
Report
Went to Brooklyn's prepared to love it. Was so disppointed. Ordered a few different things so we could really give it a fair shot. Pizza was a level below cicis which is the lowest you can get imo. The crust was so chewy and hard. Garlic knots were hard on the outside, undercooked on the inside. Lasagna seemed like microwaved slop. Watered down. Slathered in marinara sliced swiss cheese barely melted on top. Middle was still cold. Jalapeño poppers were ok. Employees were loudly cursing the whole time we were there (with a kid present).
The Bearded Review
Oct 13, 2021
Report
Mignone S.
Oct 11, 2021
Report
Andrew D.
Aug 22, 2021
Report
Bridgette M.
Aug 21, 2021
Report
Christian H.
Aug 11, 2021
Report
Great pizza spot and option if you are craving some delightful and greasy Brooklyn Style pizza!!! The slices are nice and big and you need to eat them the traditional Brooklyn pizza way by folding it into a size that can fit into one's mouth hole.
This Folding ensures the toppings are mixed properly and the one-way eating makes all the nutrients combine at once. This pizzeria does an amazing job of presenting that feature.
If you don't know what Brooklyn style is - it means hand-stretched pizza. The difference is typically in the crispiness and the amount of mozzarella used.
It
This Folding ensures the toppings are mixed properly and the one-way eating makes all the nutrients combine at once. This pizzeria does an amazing job of presenting that feature.
If you don't know what Brooklyn style is - it means hand-stretched pizza. The difference is typically in the crispiness and the amount of mozzarella used.
It
Weldon H.
May 29, 2021
Report
Becky R.
May 11, 2021
Report
Cynthia K.
May 09, 2021
Report
Tired of big name pizza, I sought a nearby local pizza place with great ratings and this was what turned up. An 18-in meat lover and 10 garlic Parmesan wings was right at $29. The pizza itself was really good but was disappointed in how it seemed bunch in the box. Crust hand tossed and fairly thin but good flavor. Light sauce and good amount of toppings. The wings I would not recommend but could be personal preference. Still haven't found that oven crispy garlic Parmesan I've been looking for. The wings were fairly small which explains how cheap they were but they were moist almost like
M. Pressive
Feb 16, 2021
Report
Had high hopes for this place, since they do not deliver to my area. The outside looks great, but quickly changed upon entering. Don't know how old this place is, but it isn't eye pleasing. Looked like it was still being renovated. Rug was dirty! Their wings are very undersized and appetizing. They had a weird sauce that looked like mac sauce. Their heroes and stromboli are worth trying as a plus. Staff is jovial, but a little to playful when customers are inside. They were more interested in tv series and movies than anything else. They all went in back to talk and left one worker to prepare everything
Hello Kitty Gang
Jan 22, 2021
Report
Sean P.
Jan 03, 2021
Report
Timothy M.
Dec 13, 2020
Report
Tawana A.
Nov 28, 2020
Report
Pizza was pretty good but anytime you don't see a review of a certain menu item stay clear. I ordered a half Brooklyn half cheese pizza, a chef salad, and 10 garlic Parmesan wings. Boy I was so set on wings and salad bc I don't eat pizza. Only to end up with burnt fried chicken wings ON TOP of garlic Parmesan sauce. The wings were not tossed in sauce at all. This was definitely NOT what I was expecting for $8.00. Stay clear of the wings or you'll be highly disappointed. Unfortunately I doubt I'll return
Trisha B.
Jul 21, 2020
Report
My husband loves the pizza here so this is more for him. It is fairly authentic and so good when hot and fresh it is not, however, food leftover pizza or good cold. It is also slightly more expensive than the chains but it's worth it. Also, they don't have any "deals" which I though was standard at a pizza places. But overall the place is a good solid pizza joint.
Tksoul L.
Jul 19, 2020
Report
Josh H.
Feb 12, 2020
Report
