Fusaro's

I like the bay scallop dinner, that's why it got 2 stars, but the portion sizes for appetizers and especially the chicken parm is why I stopped eating here. If I spend 60+ with tip and no drinks on dinner for myself at an ITALIAN restaurant and am still hungry after that's just someplace I can't in good conscious recommend to my friends and family when they visit me.

Service was excellent and dinner was amazing truly loved it compliments to the chef, if you like Italian this is the place to dine!!!

My impression is that something must have gone very wrong in the kitchen tonight. We were told that the management was prioritizing take-out orders over in-restaurant dining, which is why our orders were taking a very long time. The friendly waitstaff was apologetic, but that's not a great message. My wife was reassured that her sole would be fresh, but it clearly was not. Making matters worse, it had a hair in it! My chicken parmigiana had the texture of a frozen cutlet that had been thawed in a microwave. The breading was soggy and flavorless. We did not complain about the two failed entrees

My family and I stay at our house in Madaket one week out of the year. We like to splurge a few times and eat out. We picked Fusaro’s because the food sounds delicious on the menu. I’m sad we never got to taste any of it.
Upon entering the the restaurant, the owner did not greet us , or even look in our direction. She was too engrossed with writing a takeout order for a couple ahead of us and wouldn’t even glance our way. After waiting for 7 minutes (doesn’t sound long but when you are awkwardly hanging out by the front door with staff that won’t talk to you, it seems like forever) the

My party had the Oxtail Gnocchi and the gluten & gluten free Bolognaise (pardon my spelling) dishes. Every bite was perfectly delicious from every dish. Saw God. Will visit again.

We had a fantastic experience at Fusaro's! The atmosphere was beautiful and clean. Our waiter was very pleasant and professional. The food? Oh the food... Delicious!! It was priced fair and portions were spot on!.

My wife and I finally visited Fusaros........ What was the wait!?!? This place is excellent! The staff, the cozy feeling, the food? Oh, yes the food, absolutely amazing. My wife got the special Duck Ragut over Gnocchi. Epic! I got the Fettuccine Alfredo with grilled chicken. Awesome 👍. We have a new great Italian place to choose from! Thanks to the staff front and back for a great experience.

Poor delivery experience. Took over 2 hours from order. Multiple phone calls, no one could help. They tried to blame their delivery provider, but my driver told me he was there 3 times and the food was never ready. I completely believe him after the experience I had on the phone w the restaurant. With that said, the food was warm and good. Hence the 3.

Great for pizza, and eat-in dining. I was very disappointed when I ordered this dish to-go for $22 +tax. No bread, no side salad, not even a fork and knife. This was ordered back in February 2020

Great service and awesome food. Had the Nantucket Scallops, Fettuccini Alfredo with chicken, Linguini and Clams, Scallop Chowder, and Eggplant Parmesan