Michelangelo Pizzeria & Restaurant

Since the ownership has changed, the prices have gone up and the quality has hone gone down. I ordered a pizza and three heros on Sunday at 4:30 PM. They told me it would be ready in 20 - 30 minutes. I got to Michelangelo's at 5:00PM. They only had a kid and two adults making pizzas and serving the customers. They way way behind with the pizza. After waiting till 5:30PM one hour after ordering my pizza and heros it was still not ready. At 5:45PM i finally got my food. I got it home the pizza was cold the heros were cold and very poor taste. From being one of the best pizzeria's in the Eastport

Planned our Christmas Eve dinner a month ago, ordering very much in advance. Checking on it twice including the day before about the time we were going to be picking it up. They tell me yes 5:30 it will be ready. I get there after church at exactly 5:30 and with a kid laughing behind the counter saying they're an hour plus behind schedule. Thinking it was a joke I asked if he was serious and the other 16 people waiting they were all like he's very serious. Most of the people in there were waiting from before 430 for their 430 pickup. Where I was taking this food wasn't around the corner, it was

Great food. Great service. Mike and Anthony, the new owners really care. Highly recommended!

Best quality pizza around!!! Super friendly staff. Can’t go wrong with any dish from here.

Visiting from VA. Wonderful food! Fantastic flavors, perfectly cooked. Generous portions and awesome service! J.M, the server was hustling and did a great job at all the tables!
Would love to have this restaurant at home!! I would definitely be a regular!
Thank you!

It’s just not that good. Pizza I guess is ok but dining side 👎. They’ll always have business it’s local and convenient. And people like the Olive Garden so.

First off the restaurant is clean and well staffed, all staff are polite and courteous, as for the food is was out of this world, food portions arw.morw.thwn worth the price, and the food is very fresh,, I am very picky to where we eat at restaurants due to what I do as a living I am in the pest control field and with all my experience this place is top notch. I WOULD HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS RESTAURANT TO ANYONE THAT ASKS, I will be returning to this restaurant in the near future.

We love this restaurant. Ask for Adam!! Great bartender and server. He has a wonderful personality and is so friendly. Always makes you feel at home and makes the best dirty martini in Suffolk County! Lots of love for this restaurant especially now that it is under new management. Carissa is wonderful as well!

Amazing dinner and large portions. Pizza is on point. Very good drinks at the bar and friendly staff make you feel at home.
One day they might make a vodka pie. Will keep you posted.

Great Italian restaurant 😋! If you looking for a cozy place, try this one. Love tbe atmosphere inside, and the stuff are friendly! Food is great and worth to try it!

As always, a great meal at at great value. My favorite is the Clams Luciano and Chicken Scarpiello with Sausage and Hot Cherry Peppers...