Preferred Insurance
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Preferred Insurance
Colorado's best group health insurance broker specializing in small business employee health benefits and Medicare Supplements & Advantage Plans. Need assistance with figuring out Medicare and all the various parts, supplements and plans? We are Medicare insurance experts and can guide you though the maze.

Individual and family health insurance is easy to research and buy online. Click to view resources and advice on finding the best individual health care plans and rates. We have years of experience, 30 years to be exact and our work doesn't stop after the purchase. We have multiple locations in Colorado and a staff dedicated to customer service.
Services
Preferred Insurance is a group health insurance broker that specializes in employee health insurance for small businesses and Medicare supplements in Colorado Springs. In business since 1989, our primary mission is to help Colorado employers and seniors obtain health insurance that is affordable and offers excellent medical coverage.
We are Colorado Springs best group health insurance broker for small business health benefits and Medicare Supplements & Advantage Plans. A good health insurance broker is kind of like a coach you can rely on for information, guidance, and a strategic game plan for your health insurance needs. Contact us today to get answers and free health insurance quotes tailored to your goals.
Call for free group health insurance quotes and to get your questions answered by a locally owned Colorado Springs independent health insurance broker. We can meet either on the phone, at your business or at our Colorado Springs or Denver offices. After the meeting give us one day to create the best health insurance quotes for your specific requirements.
Our team of small business health insurance brokers specialize in helping employers in Colorado Springs and Denver areas. Your health insurance solution is precisely designed for your business, your employees and your budget. Since the 1980's we have helped hundreds of small businesses in Colorado find group health insurance plans that are affordable and that offer excellent protection for their employees.
We are an independent Medicare insurance broker serving Colorado Springs and Denver metro areas. Medicare supplemental insurance can be confusing. We simplify the process and provide expert guidance so you understand what you are getting and paying. Since the 1980's we have helped numerous Colorado residents find Medicare supplement insurance plans or Medicare Advantage Plans that fit their needs and budgets.
Reviews (10)
Voyager Cares
Voyager Cares
Nov 06, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Voyager has been using Preferred Insurance for benefits administration advice and guidance, and the Staff have been nothing short of amazing and helpful. We turn to them for a lot of questions and they have always been an incredible resource.
Mike Benzian
Mike Benzian
Nov 02, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Awesome experience from beginning to end. Called when moving to Colorado and they made the difference with regard to setting up our policies. A pleasure to work with!!!!
Katie Engelman
Katie Engelman
Oct 23, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness
Julie and the team at Preferred Insurance are amazing! They are so helpful and always respond quickly to any questions I have. Definitely the most attentive and friendly brokers I've worked with!
Colleen Bardy
Colleen Bardy
Oct 21, 2021
Report
I chose Preferred Insurance based on the recommendation of a friend and I was not disappointed. Carl and everyone in the office were not only personable but very professional and knowledgeable with a thorough understanding of original Medicare with Medigap and the Medicare Advantage Plans. Carl was patient and answered every question whether in-person, on the phone or via email. After enrolling, Carl followed up with phone calls and emails to be sure I was receiving the appropriate Medicare information/booklets/cards. I highly recommend Preferred Insurance and have made several referrals to my
Cristy Carlson
Cristy Carlson
Jul 07, 2021
Report
Moving from Mpls to CO and needed help setting up supplemental insurance for Medicare.. Worked with Carl and I have been extremely impressed with his knowledge and how I was walked through the process of establishing new insurance from beginning to end. I couldn't have done it without him. Other family members have now worked with Preferred Insurance and are also very pleased. I highly recommend this company.
Kari Kenney
Kari Kenney
May 22, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness
The staff at Preferred Insurance is the the greatest. We had a different insurance broker and they were horrible. I moved my company to Preferred 2 years ago and they have been the most helpful, kindest and funniest Insurance company I have ever dealt with. I highly recommend them for you insurance needs!!!!
Lesley Call
Lesley Call
Dec 04, 2020
Report
Positive: Quality, Responsiveness
Aaron has been invaluable in every step of helping our small business choose and implement a group healthcare plan. He continues to stay engaged with our company and provide quick thorough answers to any questions that arise. Very glad we went with Aaron and Preferred Insurance.
Tiffani Sandoval
Tiffani Sandoval
Nov 16, 2020
Report
Positive: Responsiveness
I have worked with Preferred Insurance for more then 4 years now. They have made my job as an admin assistant/HR manager so easy. They are so professional. They get the job done, and would not work with another Broker. Work with them you will not be disappointed. Julie and Melissa are so great and have amazing customer service skills.
Clarey Fam
Clarey Fam
Nov 11, 2020
Report
Carl and Julie have been so amazing to work with! They have gone above and beyond for me and are always so friendly and happy to help! I would recommend 100%
Mike Deulen
Mike Deulen
Oct 06, 2019
Report
Carl and his very talented staff are the best. They go over the top with their service, knowledge of the market place, and looking out for you their customer. I have been with them for over 20 years. They have managed my corporate business and private insurance needs. They just know the market better then anyone else.