Local Choice Insurance
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Business Insurance protects businesses and organizations. Our team can customize an insurance package to your specific needs and help protect the business that you have built. Life insurance is designed to protect your lifestyle and the future of your family. Local Choice Insurance can help you find the life insurance policy that is unique to you and your needs.

Senior Care Insurance provides health insurance coverage for individuals who need coverage primarily in their retirement age. Local Choice Insurance offers a wide array of carriers and programs to meet each seniors unique needs. I have found these folks to be very direct, honest, knowledgable and helpful.
Services
Local Choice Insurance, LLC's primary goal is to provide you with the right program at the best rates with exceptional service to meet your needs. Our insurance agency provides comprehensive insurance products for individuals, families and businesses. As an independent, multi-line insurance agency we represent many top-rated insurance companies.
Bill has always enjoyed helping others and wants to ensure his clients can enjoy life by providing them with peace of mind knowing their specific insurance needs are met. He began his insurance career as an intern with Northwestern Mutual Insurance while studying at the University of Louisville. From there he spent time at Allstate and State Farm.
Local Choice Insurance, LLC is an independent insurance agency in Louisville Kentucky that provides comprehensive insurance products for individuals and businesses, including, auto, home, life, and business coverage. As an independent, multi-line insurance agency we represent several top-rated insurance companies.
Are you needing to make a payment or file a claim? We are here to help guide you through the process. Listed below are the insurance carriers that we represent along with their payment and claim contact information. Please feel free to contact us with any questions. Contact us first! We are here to answer any questions, and assist you with any future changes or claims that you may have.
Reviews (10)
Elizabeth Lohr
Elizabeth Lohr
Jan 02, 2022
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness
Working with Local Choice Insurance has been a breeze, especially working with Karen K in particular! They are friendly, responsive, and knowledgeable. I feel confident knowing I am appropriately covered for all of my needs.
Emmy Malinovsky
Emmy Malinovsky
Dec 02, 2021
Report
My experience with Beth Waltrip has been amazing. She helped me find the best deal on car insurance and has been proactive in sharing ways in which I could save on coverage when I didn’t even realize it was possible. Beth is extremely professional and her kindness far surpasses anything I’ve ever experienced when working with an insurance representative. Highly recommended!
Ann Vega
Ann Vega
Nov 21, 2021
Report
Karen K. makes sure we have the right insurance for our needs. From house to apartment and back to house, she got us the coverage we needed for the best price. She checks home and car every year to make sure we have the best deal. And whenever we have a question, she is quick to provide an answer. So happy we made the switch! Thank you Karen!
Elizabeth Ziegler
Elizabeth Ziegler
Nov 20, 2021
Report
Not only does my agent make sure I get the best deals for my insurance, he also makes sure that I get the coverage I need. I appreciate Local Choice for always putting their clients first. Thanks for a job well done!
Tim Huels
Tim Huels
Nov 19, 2021
Report
Andrew and his team are outstanding. They helped me find the right coverage for my business while providing a personable experience. I shopped around and they were knowledgeable, offered the best value, and had impressive communication throughout the process. Sounds cheesy, but I really felt like I was family based on how willing they were to help. Well done, guys! I appreciate you.
Susanna Hoyt
Susanna Hoyt
Nov 16, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Andrew and his team at Local Choice got me a quote quickly and the follow through and communication were top notch. I would not hesitate to contact them with future insurance needs and cannot recommend them highly enough.
Jason Paynter
Jason Paynter
Nov 15, 2021
Report
Karen and staff at Local Choice bring a professional and tailored experience to your insurance needs! They are friendly, courteous and prove to have your best interest for your insurance needs. Thank you for all your help and for the pleasant experience we have received!
Chas Elliott
Chas Elliott
Nov 15, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Local Choice is fantastic to work with! If you are shopping or looking for Auto, Home Owners, or Business Insurance- I highly recommend you contact them! They searched to find the best options for my family and were relentless in doing so!
Aimee Zaring
Aimee Zaring
Nov 13, 2021
Report
My experience with Local Choice, and agent Karen Koestler especially, has been exceptional. Karen has continually found us better quality products at more affordable rates compared to competitor companies. She values her customers and takes pride in her work and delivering the best possible service.
Bdr
Bdr
Nov 13, 2021
Report
Recently switched over to local choice as Andy is a personal friend. He has went above and beyond getting us the best rates available. 5 star company with 5 star personnel!