Why Choose Us
Custom Tailored Coverage
Our motto “Insurance To Fit Your Lifestyle” Never pay for coverage you don’t need. Our insurance policies are customized to you or your business.
Fast And Simple
Get an quick and easy price. Nickerson and issue your policy fast! Just sign and go with e- signature never have to waste time traveling to office again.
Convenient For You
Pay a bill, report a Claim, Quote a policy 24 hours 7 days a week. Whether your preference is online, email, telephone, text, or in person the Nickerson Insurance Agency is happy to serve you. We have dedicated staff in our office waiting to help you.
Save Time And Money
Nickerson Insurance Agency works for you. We feature direct from the company pricing with all the convenience
Custom Tailored Coverage
Our motto “Insurance To Fit Your Lifestyle” Never pay for coverage you don’t need. Our insurance policies are customized to you or your business.
Fast And Simple
Get an quick and easy price. Nickerson and issue your policy fast! Just sign and go with e- signature never have to waste time traveling to office again.
Convenient For You
Pay a bill, report a Claim, Quote a policy 24 hours 7 days a week. Whether your preference is online, email, telephone, text, or in person the Nickerson Insurance Agency is happy to serve you. We have dedicated staff in our office waiting to help you.
Save Time And Money
Nickerson Insurance Agency works for you. We feature direct from the company pricing with all the convenience
Details
- Licensed
- Insured
Payment methods
- Cash, Debit cards, Credit cards, Mobile payments, Bank transfers
Services
Partnering with our local, independent insurance agency is a smart decision if you want a combination of the best service, price, and protection for each driver and vehicle in your household.We have developed very strong, long-term relationships with high quality and easy-to-work-with personal insurance carriers. Through these partnerships, we are able to find you the best auto insurance products for all your personal vehicles
Designing a comprehensive homeowners insurance program is always a collaborative process between the Nickerson team and our clients. This approach includes a detailed fact-finding about you, your family, and your home, and helps us find the policy that best matches your specific needs and fits your individual budget. 
There are lots of available discounts that we include to get you the best rate like the quote in advance discount, motorcycle license discount, safety course discount, responsible driver discount, and pay on time discount… just to name a few. You deserve great coverage that is included standard in your policy, such as full replacement cost, OEM parts, medical coverage, and accessories/custom parts coverage. 
Life always throws us curveballs. From car accidents injuring others to your neighbors suing you because your animal accidentally bit them, your basic insurance coverage may not cover all the damages and medical expenses. Before you have to deal with the loss of time and money, have you considered getting an additional insurance plan that will kick in and help with these extra charges? That is where Personal Umbrella Insurance comes in. People
Mark Nickerson
As a business owner in our community, Mark has been
involved in a variety of organizations and events to give back:
Former First Selectman, East Lyme, Connecticut (7 years)
Former member/Chair of Zoning Commission, East Lyme, CT
Chamber of Commerce member, 4 years as Director
Former Chair, Military Community Council of the Chamber of Commerce
Past President of the Navy League, Eastern Connecticut Council
Former National Director of the Navy League
Former Chairman, Military Affairs Committee
Big Brothers Big Sisters
East Lyme Police Commission
And many other community, government, and non-profit organizations
involved in a variety of organizations and events to give back:
Former First Selectman, East Lyme, Connecticut (7 years)
Former member/Chair of Zoning Commission, East Lyme, CT
Chamber of Commerce member, 4 years as Director
Former Chair, Military Community Council of the Chamber of Commerce
Past President of the Navy League, Eastern Connecticut Council
Former National Director of the Navy League
Former Chairman, Military Affairs Committee
Big Brothers Big Sisters
East Lyme Police Commission
And many other community, government, and non-profit organizations
Reviews (2)
S. Tyree
Oct 10, 2022
Report
I called Nickerson Insurance Agency for a quote on auto insurance and spoke with Abby. She was extremely helpful and knowledgeable. She took the time to explain all of the coverages on my current policy and explained what coverages I did not currently have. Not only did I save money on my auto insurance, I got an even better deal on a bundle with renters insurance. I got better coverage for a great price. Looking to switch your insurance company? Call Nickerson Insurance Agency and speak with Abby. You’ll be glad you did.
Sandra Voogd
Jun 25, 2022
Report
I recently worked with Justin Hedrick out of Mark’s office. I can’t say enough about Justin’s excellent service. He was thorough, detailed and patient. He answered all of my questions and initiated suggestions to my policy. I ended up going with the policy he recommended ! I trust Justin gave me sound advice and it was a pleasure to do business with him .