2 NYers Pizza
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
2 NYers Pizza
2 NYer's Pizza, located in Sugarloaf Marketplace in Duluth, GA, is run by Kevin and Franky, both from New York. Kevin is from Long Island and Franky from Brooklyn. They both began working in the restaurant industry in their early teens. With a shared belief in quality, delicious food, and exemplary customer service, 2NYER'S Pizza opened in October of 2020.

For them, they are not servicing customers; they are serving their families. With over 60 years of combined restaurant experience, they came together to bring the New York pizza experience to Georgia. Our restaurant is available for private events: weddings, business lunches, dinners, team buildings, and more.
Reviews (26)
Tina C.
Tina C.
Jan 26, 2022
Report
We had plans to visit another pizza place but fortunately it was closed. Pizza won't disappoint my husband loved it and wish they were closer to us. We will definitely be going back soon and great service by the owner and the boys working that night.
Cher G.
Cher G.
Jan 24, 2022
Report
Really good pizza and service! Close to NY style! Would recommend if you're looking for authenticity.
Mohogany B.
Mohogany B.
Jan 13, 2022
Report
One of my favorite places to get true New York style pizza. The staff is very friendly and warm. Always good vibes.
Mario DiAntonio
Mario DiAntonio
Dec 18, 2021
Report
Great experience provided by a family-operated pizza restaurant. Get the whole pie, it’s totally worth it. Their cheese bread is really good too. The service was very friendly. Highly recommended!
Tom B.
Tom B.
Dec 17, 2021
Report
Always fresh & delicious tasting!! I've traveled the world and I always try out pizza everywhere I go. This place ranks among my top 3 favs !

The owners and staff are always friendly and deliver on time every time !!!
Esther K.
Esther K.
Dec 13, 2021
Report
This new pizzeria is good. Their pies are a hidden gem! We were really pleased with the pizza here. Good flavor and a nice chewy dough which I love. The toppings were genuinely topped on the pies too. I like the variety of pizza options they have.

The salad wasn't as full of toppings as I would hope. Hopefully, it was just a off order with my salad.

This pizzeria is located in the same plaza as Zoe Kitchen, Chipotle, Sprouts, and Hollywood Feed. The owner was friendly and making the pies himself. They also have some lunch specials.

Check them out!
Salman Khan
Salman Khan
Nov 01, 2021
Report
Love this place. The owner, or at least who I assume to be the owner, is super friendly and personable. He greets everyone who walks through his doors with a big hello and a smile as if you've known each other for years. Really makes you feel welcome. There's only one other pizza place in the area that comes close to the quality of pizza here and try to find any excuse to order from here whenever I can.
I've only ever ordered their largest pizza with cheese, no other toppings, every time I've visited. I feel like a lot places hide behind the fact that they may have a bunch of topping options but
Z. G.
Z. G.
Oct 20, 2021
Report
The pizza is eh so so - looks and smells are deceiving - It doesn’t really taste like a New York Style Pizza. I wouldn’t take the effort to spend $25 bucks on another one.
Debbie M.
Debbie M.
Oct 14, 2021
Report
Great pizza. Great atmosphere. Manager/owner is hands on and friendly. Husband and I went on a Saturday evening. Not too busy. We both got pizza. It came out quickly and hot. We will go back!
Akhil Parmar
Akhil Parmar
Sep 29, 2021
Report
We were in the area shopping and decided that lunch would be the move and we are happy to say it was a great decision! We walked in and were happily greeted before picking the 16" pizza. It came quickly and was incredibly delicious. Ambiance of the restaurant was great and I couldn't complain, I just can't wait to come back and get another one. Highly recommend anyone to give this place a shot.
Malone M.
Malone M.
Sep 18, 2021
Report
This place was cool. We ordered a 16” pie, food was good, idk about NY. Restaurant was messy, crumbs everywhere, dirty tables, sticky garlic holder. No greeting when we walked in, place was empty and quiet.
Kashien Latham
Kashien Latham
Sep 16, 2021
Report
The pizza was great. The owner was very authentic being an Italian from Brooklyn, he takes his pizza seriously. Fast service. I couldn't give them 5 stars because I've had traditional cheesy, greesey New York pizza and I can't find anyone to replace that
Kevin H.
Kevin H.
Sep 01, 2021
Report
These guys do pizza right. Tried for the first time last evening as I bought 3 pies, meat lovers, pepperoni, and cheese for guys working late. Hit a home run and 2NYers pizza is going on my list of great pizza, right up there to the top. I heard the owner say he has been making pizza for 32 years, you can tell. You won't be disappointed.
Jamie Hsiao JESUSmyLORD
Jamie Hsiao JESUSmyLORD
Aug 29, 2021
Report
My husband and I visited NY quite a few times and we have experienced some famous NY pizza right in New York City during our visits in the past.
In comparison, this restaurant's taste is quite authentic and the brick oven is beautiful. 😄
Everything we ordered was delicious. The service was quick and very friendly! Definitely will return soon.
Donna N.
Donna N.
Jul 26, 2021
Report
Excellent pizza, fresh green salad & speedy delivery!
The pizza had the delicious smell of a brick oven and a great chew to the crust. Nice & thin too'
Jg G.
Jg G.
Jul 16, 2021
Report
The experience started with the young lady taking my order over the phone. No customer service at all. I should have just stopped placing the order. The pizza did not reflect the images seen on previous yelp reviews. Toppings were sparse and cheese bread was not that cheesy. It only covered the bread sticks in the middle, the 2 bread sticks on each end did not have any cheese. Their marketing does not show pizza's with bits and pieces of toppings. Where are the sliced vegetables?

I would have tried them again because anyone can have a bad night. Experiences & customer service is everything
Stephen G.
Stephen G.
Jul 13, 2021
Report
Cheesy bread was delicious. I think they are very busy because the delivery was about 20 minutes past the window.

We got the hawaiian pizza and added Jalapenos and garlic. It was pretty tasty.

Order form does not seem to allow for splitting ingredients on the pizza.
Kaycee C.
Kaycee C.
Jul 06, 2021
Report
We got the Bianca pizza and added Italian sausage Was absolutely delicious and even our picky three year old loved it! Everything is reasonably priced and the staff were more than accommodating!
Nick S.
Nick S.
Jun 27, 2021
Report
Solid New York pizza, brick oven gets stuff out super quick. I suggest getting less toppings because it cooks sooo quick and with a bunch of toppings the cheese doesn't melt all the way. Meat lover was on point though. They sell pie by the slice to which is always nice.

Nice little spot in Duluth. They definitely let you know when they close though. Owner let us know at 8pm that they stop closing at 8:45.

All in all, the owner was very nice and hospitable.
Aja Carter
Aja Carter
May 17, 2021
Report
2 NYERS Pizza is DELICIOUS! We decided to stop for lunch and we were pleasantly surprised. The restaurant is clean, the staff and owners are courteous and the prices were fair. We came in and placed an order and our food was out super quick. I already know we will become regulars here. We ordered the small margherita pizza and small meat lover pizza. The sweet tea was the cherry on top for our meal.
David S.
David S.
Apr 10, 2021
Report
The best NY pizza in the area. Crust has just the right amount of chew. Meat Lovers pizza is piled high with toppings. Margherita pizza is great.
Caesar salad is a hidden gem.

Online ordering thru Toast is quick and painless. Pizza is always ready before the 30 minute pickup window.

Owner always has a friendly greeting when I stop in to pickup my pizza.

This is our go-to pizza place.....
Mike S.
Mike S.
Feb 23, 2021
Report
Greeted nicely. Cool looking place with outdoor seating. The pizza came out quickly. There was nothing wrong with it, I just don't think it was for me. My wife described it as good kids party pizza. Pizza 6.1. Everything else 7.4. We prefer a crispier crust.
Chaerilicious C.
Chaerilicious C.
Dec 03, 2020
Report
Second time trying this place out with my kids. We love it!

Pizza is simple and delicious, love the dough and the crust! My kids say they love the pepperoni.

Also, the guys who work there, assuming he's the owner since he's always there, is friendly and welcoming. They always say thank you and bye on our way out. Love that.
Jeffrey C.
Jeffrey C.
Nov 23, 2020
Report
REAL NY crust in Duluth! This is the real deal. Ordered 4 large and they were all excellent. The magic is in the crust, and they got it spot on. The toppings were all fresh and perfectly proportioned. I wish I had just ordered a plain cheese. When you've got real NY style pizza, that's all you need!
It's a brave time to start a restaurant, let's support this locally owned and operated business Duluth!
Morgan M.
Morgan M.
Oct 27, 2020
Report
2 NYers pizza is a brand new pizza spot that opened up in the shopping center in front of the sprouts super market and beside chipotle.

I was super excited to find a new "NY pizza" spot to add to my pizza list! I went with the safe choice and decided to order large pepperoni pie and cheesy bread.

The pizza was prepared in a fire oven so the dough/crust was pretty good. Not too crunchy, but just right. It was a bit saucy in my opinion! The cheesy bread was sloppily made as you can see in the photo. I will not be ordering cheesy bread again sadly!

I will come back and have another pizza
Mansi R.
Mansi R.
Oct 18, 2020
Report
We were really excited to try this place but were disappointed. I ordered the white pizza and cheesy bread online for pick up and it said it would be ready in 30 minutes. Hubby was there on time, but when we got the pizza it was cold. Had to warm up the pizza and cheesy bread.

The white pizza also had zero garlic flavor.

Don't think we'll be trying it again.