Name: Castaways
Address: 1500 N High St, Lancaster, OH, 43130, US
Telephone: (740) 654-9197
Rating: 3.22

Heartwarming meals at an attractive price with friendly service and in a comfortable setting await when you visit Castaways. For more than 70 years, our American restaurant in Lancaster, OH, has been the go-to place in Lancaster when you're looking for a wide variety of delicious meals in a cozy and quaint setting.

Our menu is full of time-tested favorites to please every member of the family. We source our freshly-butchered meats locally from Bay Food Market to ensure your meal is as fresh as it can possibly get. Would you like to enjoy your dinner during the nice weather? You can also dine on our outdoor patio for an even more pleasurable meal.

Website Update

Reviews (9)

Write a Review

Tabitha Knight-Bailey

Jan 31, 2022

Report

We had 2 waitresses. One was very nice the other who took our order was very short with us and rude. Yes they were busy but no reason to be rude. My husband and I both ordered steaks. Neither was cooked right and had no flavor, he ordered a side of mushrooms, they were literally a CAN of sliced mushrooms dumped in a cup. Ew. We spent $75 and we both left still hungry. Very disappointed to say the least.

Kourtney Turner

Jan 21, 2022

Report

Great food and service! We ordered the steak for 3 my goodness was it a mound of steak and delicious too! Our first time there and we all said we would definitely come back.

Jake Penning

Dec 30, 2021

Report

Pizza crust was soaked in some kind of liquid and especially middle of crust was soggy and not edible. My wife's hashbrowns looked and tasted old or something? Salads had good dressings. Probably won't try it again.

Kimberly Hamilton

Dec 02, 2021

Report

Never disappointed. Food tastes great. Atmosphere wonderful. Service always friendly. Support Local and you'll never be let down. One of my favorite restaurants to visit when home to see family.

Chris Swain

Nov 12, 2021

Report

Amazing food, attentive staff!!! Very quick service!!!!! Will return every time in town!!!!

M. Rey

Oct 29, 2021

Report

Worst restaurant and Prime Rib dinner ever.
The meat at Save-A-Lot is better that the meat that they served as Prime Rib.
They soaked the meat I'm meat tendering solution.
Nasty taste.
And to top this it was $64 for 2 dinners.
Will never recommend this place to anyone.

M. Rey

Oct 16, 2021

Report

Went there for the Prime Rib dinner.
Worst piece of meat ever.
NOT PRIME RIB, VERY TOUGH AND THE TASTE OF THE MEAT TENDERIZE POWDER, IT WAS SALTY AND WAS DISCUSTING
. Prime Rib should never be saturated in meat TENDERIZER, BUT THIS WAS.
$64 DOLLARS FOR MEAT FROM SAVE-A-LOT. FOR 2 DINNERS.

Lee Tipple

Oct 03, 2021

Report

The atmosphere is very appealing which is why we chose this place for our Saturday get together. A little overpriced for the quality and quantity of food. Salad and potatoes are cheap and plentiful in central ohio especially in the summer. When I order potato skins I expect half a potato per skin, not a quarter. A full salad plate would have been nice. The dinner for 2 Is served with sirloin steak which is fine but for the price I would expect better marbling

Colleen Olds

Sep 01, 2021

Report

I have been going there since I was about 12 years old and I am now 60! They have the best pizza, but all of their food is amazing. A few of my friends and I ate on their patio and everyone made sure our experience was wonderful. I had the steak, salad and baked potato. It was all yummy and I had plenty to take home.