One of the best places to stay for families and groups, our Old Town Key West hotel has maintained a long-standing reputation for providing impeccable hospitality in a gorgeous setting with incredible amenities. Situated in Historic Old Town Key West, sits this unique property that is comprised of three separate buildings, The Arch House, The Cigar House, and the Island City House.
The oldest operating Guest House in Key West, Island City House Hotel offers guests an exceptional experience. See what's new with our hotel policies and cleaning practices to provide a safe and relaxing place to rest and relax. Our historic property is a family-friendly destination offering a warm atmosphere to socialize and enjoy each other's company.
The oldest operating Guest House in Key West, Island City House Hotel offers guests an exceptional experience. See what's new with our hotel policies and cleaning practices to provide a safe and relaxing place to rest and relax. Our historic property is a family-friendly destination offering a warm atmosphere to socialize and enjoy each other's company.
Services
The Island City House Hotel is the oldest operating guesthouse on Key West. It is comprised of three buildings: the Carriage House, the Island City House, and the Cigar House. Each building lends its own unique history and style to the property. Island City House is also a part of the Key West Historic Marker Tour.
Stay just a 10-minute walk from Duval Street in our spacious hotel suites in Key West, Florida. Complete with full kitchens, our tropical suites are perfect for wedding parties and families looking for a home away from home on our heavenly island. Island City House Hotel offers three buildings, each with a distinct style and character to suit every guest's taste.
Stay in the heart of downtown with our affordable hotel deals in Key West, FL. Island City House Hotel offers the perfect balance of an ideal location near Duval St. with a quiet atmosphere to relax and rejuvenate. A family-friendly property, each of our suites comes with either a full kitchen or kitchenette and free Wi-Fi, providing you with the comforting amenities of home.
Take advantage of many amenities and services during your stay at our Key West hotel with pool and tropical garden space. Island City House Hotel is an all-suites property that is steps away from Duval Street and all the best parts of our island! Enjoy a comfortable stay with your family in the heart of Old Town where fun-filled days and relaxed evenings await you.
Step away for a moment of indulgence during your stay at Island City House. We are proud to offer the services of Essera Spa. Owner, Rachel Cobb, is a licensed massage therapist practicing a variety of massage modalities including Swedish, Deep Tissue, Hot Stone, and Shiatsu, among others. Each Essera Spa treatment uses doTERRA CPTG Essential Oils, the highest standard for pure essential oils for aromatic, topical, and internal wellness.
Reviews (23)
Jennifer Welch
Nov 16, 2021
Report
Tiffany Howard
Oct 08, 2021
Report
I just had clients stay with you and they were happy with everything. I want to particularly thank Carlos for helping with gifts that I had sent to their room. He made sure it was refrigerated and waiting on them when they arrived. Special touches make a difference and combined with the great stay and customer service, I would book clients here again for sure!
Karen Cantrell
Oct 03, 2021
Report
Nick Boscia
Oct 01, 2021
Report
Gylany Crossman
Sep 30, 2021
Report
Never even got to stay. I’m a ICU nurse and my unit was extremely understaffed so I stayed to work. My partner and I tried calling multiple days in a row to change the dates. They kept telling us to call back or change online. When I spoke with them again today they said they could have changed the dates if we had called yesterday. Don’t waste your time.
Trudy Konitzer Albert
Sep 05, 2021
Report
Michelle Crawford
Aug 07, 2021
Report
Anna Lonskaya
Aug 05, 2021
Report
Beautiful hotel in the middle of everything and exceptional customer service! My fiancé and I were celebrating our engagement and the hotel staff upgraded our room to a patio suit, which we didn’t expect at all. The room was extremely clean and nicely furnished. The amenities are beautiful as well! Carlos and Annetta were the sweetest and made our stay even more pleasant. Will definitely be back!
D. T.
Jul 21, 2021
Report
We came here for the 4th of July weekend (2 adults and one toddler) and stayed in the garden studio suite (it is a studio with kitchen including pots and pans). We took the Key West Express and this hotel is located very close to the ferry dock in a very charming Key West neighborhood. We can't say enough about how lovely this hotel is: it is very clean, the tropical garden is so charming, and the buildings are in great condition. The manager is so nice and everyone who works here is really lovely. Highly recommend and can't wait to come back.
Kathy Cole
May 14, 2021
Report
Perfect location to walk everywhere. We were in the Cigar House room 8 and I loved the hammock and Adirondack chairs on the patio. Only downside was the ceiling fan in the bedroom didn’t have speed control so difficult to keep air moving while trying to sleep. The on site bike rentals were a great deal and the bikes were awesome and well maintained for a day of riding around the island.
Ana F.
Mar 21, 2021
Report
This was our second stay here. In the midst of a pandemic the staff go above and beyond to make it comfortable. They give coupons to local cafes since they can't offer breakfast or room service. The rooms are beautiful and well appointed. All with kitchens and full sized fridges with all you need to cook if you choose. Gorgeous gardens with waterfalls for tranquility. Bike rentals available if you wish. Cafe bustello pods for the keurig in your room. Mattresses so comfy I slept like a baby. Pool and sauna. You can leave your bags before and after. Close to everything without the feel of it
Annette Bennett
Feb 14, 2021
Report
Stay here if you like old Florida Keys!! The room was amazing as was the property. Pack light, we were on the third floor and there isn't an elevator. Worth it. Comfy bed, super clean, great staff, beautifully decorated, nice extras like water! Very nice kitchen with everything you would need, although we didn't use it. Parking is difficult in Key West, we parked in the parking garage which was central to the marina, food and the room for $32 for 24 hours.
Tori D.
Dec 30, 2020
Report
Had a wonderful stay at the Island City House Hotel for our couples getaway just before Christmas 2020. The hotel was perfect for our stay. We had a king 1 bedroom suite on the second floor of 1 of their three buildings. The room was extremely clean and well kept. The hotel is a couple blocks off of the chaos of Duval street, which is only a quick bike ride or walk away. It was peaceful and quiet and BEAUTIFUL. We sat in the gardens quite a bit (pictured below) and lounged by the pool often as well (also pictured below). Hotel staff were friendly and accommodating. They have a coin op washer/dryer
Katie M.
Aug 30, 2020
Report
Amazing stay! We live in Miami Beach and make it to Key West often..... if I could stay here every time I would, if I could live here, hell, I would! The cutest garden area and pool, there are multiple buildings making you feel a little secluded! The room itself was adorable, so much space and the balcony was AMAZING (it had a hammock on it and overlooked the garden). We rented bikes from the office and the customer service was fabulous! We will definitely be back! Thank you!!!!
Kyle R.
May 12, 2020
Report
I hate to write a review complaining about a property. However, what's right is right! I booked 2 rooms checking in on June 4 2020. I booked them back in December before the Coronavirus hit the US. I called today to cancel the 2 reservations and explained to the manager Eric, that people in our group could not travel then because they could not get off of work (now since the Coronavirus outbreak has happened.) They work in the medical field and have been told that they cannot take any vacation until their employer notifies them that they can.
On top of that, all major hotel chains, cruise
On top of that, all major hotel chains, cruise
Linda M.
Feb 16, 2020
Report
Terrible place to stay. We arrived early and left our bags and the lady said she would call us for an early check in. We were first on the list. We never got a call. When we did get checked in, we were very disappointed in our rooms. The place is very old. Not many plugs for 2 sleep machines in the bedroom. The staff was not willing to try to ask Maintainence for an extension cord. The air conditioning could not cool the room because of the very tall ceilings. The biggest complaint I have is the shower. Not enough water pressure to rinse my hair in the shower and then it wouldn't drain out
Kaela A.
Feb 02, 2020
Report
The property is beautiful; it's calming and quiet and embodies everything that Key West has to offer. But I was underwhelmed by the experience. The location is great - close to the water and easy access to the Duval Loop. This ended up being a great development since there is no parking available.
The room was clean and quiet, but some of the features should be checked. The hot water in our room was spotty - water would go from hot to temperate very quickly and the television in the bedroom wouldn't turn on. I will say that the best feature was the resident cat, Bert, who was out and
The room was clean and quiet, but some of the features should be checked. The hot water in our room was spotty - water would go from hot to temperate very quickly and the television in the bedroom wouldn't turn on. I will say that the best feature was the resident cat, Bert, who was out and
Robert M.
Feb 25, 2019
Report
Andrea C.
Dec 01, 2017
Report
My husband and I stayed at the Island City House during our wedding week - November 2017 - post hurricane Irma. Everything looks just as beautiful as it did when I stayed here several years ago. The gardens were lush and the pool and lounge area inviting. I have seen a couple bad reviews on here and one thing you have to understand is that this hotel is full of historical charm that many of us fall in love with when we come to Key West - this means it's not cookie cutter hotel. The three buildings are amazing. Very clean and the staff is so nice and helpful. So far I've stayed in the
Kristi D.
Dec 03, 2016
Report
I am absolutely enchanted with this quaint inn! Perfectly located within walking distance to everything. Beautiful grounds, extremely helpful & polite staff! I love how they have it decorated. The bed is fantastic, big fluffy pillows, lovely soaps in the en suite. I am thoroughly enjoying my stay here. Love that they have bikes available too!
Anthony A.
Jan 27, 2016
Report
Loved the hotel. Stayed here last time I visited Key West. I could live there in a heart beat. Reservations were made through Hotel Tonight, check-in was a breeze, no hidden fees at the check-in desk (no crazy hold on your credit card for incidentals.) No one was there to hassle you about "activities or excursions." The room it self was like an apartment only nicer with housekeeping service. The room had a very smooth laid back Old Key West vibe. It almost felt like I was checking in to my home without the normal everyday stress of fast paced life. Check out was just as simple I handed
Kyle P.
Jan 03, 2016
Report
Brook Y.
Oct 20, 2014
Report
Island City House Hotel has the quaint, homey feel of a B&B (without the extra B).
We stayed in Room 14, a comfortable space on the ground floor with a kitchenette, two TVs, and an old creaky bed. It's strategically located in Old Town near the marina, within walking distance of several breakfast options like Old Town Bakery, Cuban Coffee Queen and Pepe's.
The biggest convenience was the bike rentals offered by the hotel! It was very affordable, and you're able to keep the bikes day after day and just pay the total when you check out. The bicycles were in good condition with
We stayed in Room 14, a comfortable space on the ground floor with a kitchenette, two TVs, and an old creaky bed. It's strategically located in Old Town near the marina, within walking distance of several breakfast options like Old Town Bakery, Cuban Coffee Queen and Pepe's.
The biggest convenience was the bike rentals offered by the hotel! It was very affordable, and you're able to keep the bikes day after day and just pay the total when you check out. The bicycles were in good condition with
