Nickel City Insurance Agency
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
By offering world class protection for your Auto, Home, Business, and Life Insurance, we make sure that you're covered today as well as in the future so that you can focus on what is important to you and your family. At Nickel City Insurance our #1 job is to assist you in identifying your needs and problems, while putting together a customized plan that's simple and easy to understand.

Founded in June of 2000, Nickel City Insurance Agency, Inc. has been a leader in providing quality protection for thousands of individuals, families and businesses throughout our state. Providing superior customer service and low rates along with our ability to understand our customer's coverage needs drives the success of our agency.
Services
We'll take the time to listen to your insurance needs and desires, and find the perfect coverage for you or your business. We'll tailor a policy just for you, your family or your business. Your total satifaction is our number one priority. Maintaining our reputation for client satisfaction depends on it.
When you call in for a quote, we gather the information we need to give you the most complete quote as possible. Before you call, take a look at this sheet and be prepared to provide us with the pertinant information. If your request is sent via email, it will be read during regular business hours Monday through Friday.
New York State has now approved online Defensive Driver courses to help save you money on your automobile insurance rates. Take the course in six straight hours, over a few days, or even a couple weeks. It's up to you and your schedule. Completing the Defensive Driver course will save you approximately 10% of the cost of your insurance for the next THREE years!
Reviews (9)
Ann Marie Graver
Ann Marie Graver
Dec 10, 2021
Report
Positive: Quality, Responsiveness, Value
I had a great experience with Mike. All it took was the initial phone call and 45 min later I was in his office getting a policy. All in the last hour of the work day. He was honest, professional and very down to earth. I highly recommend.
Barbara Zdybowicz
Barbara Zdybowicz
Oct 04, 2021
Report
I LOVE this Insurance Agency. Often when I call, I don’t need to speak with my agent, usually their administrative extraordinaire takes care of all my needs and answers any questions I may have. Mary Pych you are a pleasure to speak to and always so helpful and informative.
Thank you for always being a phone call away.
Barb Zdybowicz
Mike Solly
Mike Solly
Jul 21, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Mike Justinger is a pleasant, kind understanding person to deal with.
Anthony Martino
Anthony Martino
Jul 05, 2021
Report
Mike, his family and team have always been there to help and guide us every step of the way over the last decade.
We extremely happy with Mike and the team and will
Always recommend them to any of our family and friends.
As a business owners ourselves , and with all the pressures of running one, Mike has taken the stress out of one of the most worrisome parts of a business and that is Insurances.
Thank you Mike and Nickel City for everything. May God bless you, your families and your team.
Tony and Kim
KAMAR Holdings Inc
Six Friends Cabernet LLC
Claudette Kirchner
Claudette Kirchner
Jul 02, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness, Value
Mike is great. He always goes the extra mile and takes time to explain things to Me, even more than once.
Michael Justinger
Michael Justinger
Jun 27, 2021
Report
I am Lawrence J KRAUZA
I have been a client with Michael Justinger for well over twenty years.
Michael has always provided the BEST professional services in home and automobile insurance. He is always available and listening carefully and intelligently.
I would certainly never wish any other insurance provider than Nickel City insurance!!
I am totally 💯 satisfied and confident in that they will continue this professionalism Thank You Larry
Newyork Girl
Newyork Girl
Jun 27, 2021
Report
My husband and I have had Mike as our insurance rep for over 30 years> that length of time itself says everything about Mike's service and professionalism> he has been quick to return phone calls whenever we have had a question and he has always offered suggestions when we needed save some money on the house and car policies> Mike should be rated A+
Don Spasiano
Don Spasiano
Jun 26, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Great follow through, always returns calls quickly, courteous and genuinely concerned about excellent customer service. I'd recommend this agency wholeheartedly.
Joanna Johnson
Joanna Johnson
Jun 22, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
They are great to deal with and handle any questions. They make sure I am getting the most bang for my buck. Customer service is great, if I leave a message I always get a call back. Very helpful, friendly, and treat people right.