Silver City Sarasota
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Silver City Sarasota
Monica and everyone at Silver City Sarasota is an absolute pleasure to work with and have the most beautiful jewelry design! Monica helped us design my beautiful and unique sapphire engagement ring exactly the way I imagined! I love this place, great prices and beautiful jewelry. I return every year and get a new piece while I'm there.

This year I bought a stunning pair of earrings to match the necklace my husband gave me on our 1st anniversary. I have been to this shop twice for watch battery replacement and new watch bands. One of my watches is a Philip Stein and it is next to impossible to find a place that can replace their battery.
Services
Here at Silver City Sarasota our passion is providing our customers not only fresh, unexpected designs in sterling silver and gold, but also a level of service that exceeds expectation. We aim at allowing our customers a relaxed and enjoyable shopping experience while personally helping them in choosing the perfect souvenir.
If you love Siesta Key, don't miss the Siesta Key Dune Jewelry Collection by Holly Daniels Christensen. Featured on Entertainment Tonight, all our sand jewelry pieces are handmade with authentic Siesta Key sand set in shiny sterling silver or silver plate. Our associates personally collect the sand that goes into each of these original pieces.
Philip Stein marries natural well-being technology and simple elegance in a line of stunning, innovative watches and sleep bracelets. These items are the ultimate luxury for anyone who wants a simple, natural, and effective way to improve sleep. Sleep bracelets contain metal disks that function like antennae, picking up frequencies and channeling them throughout your body.
Gold symbolizes wealth, wisdom, and victory. It represents elegance, value, quality, and sophistication. Wearing gold jewelry is a statement of your class and prestige as a buyer. At Silver City Sarasota, our one-of-a-kind gold jewelry is high-end and represents the unique terrain of the world's most beautiful beaches.
Silver City Sarasota is happy to introduce our collection of 10-karat yellow gold jewelry. Our 10-karat gold necklaces, chains, and pendants are a sophisticated way to remember your time at Siesta Key, or choose the perfect piece to give a loved one as a token of your affection. Pair one of our unforgettable golden pendants with a matching chain, or purchase the pendant on its own.
Reviews (20)
Alexandre Denizet
Alexandre Denizet
Dec 26, 2021
Report
The store and the products are amazing. We're seeing beautiful colored stones, the price is accesible and the quality is really good.
I strongly recommend this store.
Tom Gough
Tom Gough
Dec 23, 2021
Report
They custom made a setting for a sharks tooth that my oldest son had found. Because I wanted it made out of silver and not gold.....I was having a problem finding anyone to do this.....(silver melts at a higher temperature than gold) and everyone was worried about breaking the tooth. They were able to use a laser to get the task done. I couldn't be happier with how it turned out!!!! Pricing was great as well!!!! I will definitely be doing more business with them!!
Rob Boutelle
Rob Boutelle
Dec 22, 2021
Report
I purchased a beautiful pair of Siesta Key watercolor gemstone earrings as a Xmas gift for my wife. Suzanne was very helpful and courteous. She also educated me on the history of the Quartz stone and Siesta Key Crystal Beach. I would highly recommend you go see Suzanne and the beautiful jewelry they have to offer👍👍!!
David Robins
David Robins
Dec 21, 2021
Report
I have been going here for years for special jewelry. The quality of their product is always excellent and the gorgeous designs are so original. George and his staff offer terrific service.
Michol Hennessey
Michol Hennessey
Dec 14, 2021
Report
Beautiful jewelry and amazing customer service. I brought in a few pieces that my grandmother left me that needed some work and they did a fantastic job. Completely trust them with my heirlooms! Thank you Silver City!
Louann Cash
Louann Cash
Dec 12, 2021
Report
We went in to browse and found some uniquely beautiful pieces of jewelry at a very reasonable price. Particularly stunning is the watercolor gemstone and the Larimar collection. My sister and I were impressed with the professional service and each of us walked out of the store with a new ring! We highly recommend a visit to this store before leaving Siesta Key.
Aparajit Singh
Aparajit Singh
Nov 24, 2021
Report
I took my Omega Seamaster AT for service to Jorge. The AT (cal 8500) is not an easy watch to service, but he was kind and transparent and answered all my questions with patience. He was upfront and let me know in advance that if Omega will not sell the part to him, we may need to ship it to them for service. I was looking for an independent watchmaker who I can take all my watches to for service and I have found my person.
He kept me updated throughout the process, the watch was serviced, regulated to within COSC specs and pressure tested at a very reasonable price.
Molly R.
Molly R.
Nov 06, 2021
Report
I recently had my wedding ring cut off due to having forced it over my finger and getting stuck. I took it into Monica at Silver City. She is so amazing and found a new and better setting for my original diamond. She also found another matching diamond for a lost diamond earring. I am so happy with the results, customer service, and price. I give Silver City 5+ stars and a high recommendation!!
Dawn Turner
Dawn Turner
Oct 02, 2021
Report
Suzanne was fantastic! She greeted me as I entered, asked if she could show me something, and I said I had seen the Siesta Key Watercolors stone in an ad in a newspaper. There was an entire case loaded with original designs with the Watercolor stones! There were so many unique styles it was hard to choose. She was very patient with me as I narrowed down my selection. She even matched up the pendant I chose with a perfectly complimentary 20" sterling silver chain for just $30! Don't miss this wonderful hidden gem on Siesta Key!
Jennifer S.
Jennifer S.
Aug 05, 2021
Report
Annual stops here while vacationing with my sister have become a tradition. Some of my most treasured "souvenirs" have been purchased here. Some of my favorite pieces are larimar drop earrings sweet in sterling silver, their signature Siesta Key quartz pieces which reflects the green /blue colors of the sea so beautifully to their sand fine collection showcasing the beloved Siesta sands!

There is ample parking in the shopping center. The prices are reasonable for the quality of the artistry and quality. And finally, Sue is the absolute best to work with. She is so very kind & knowledgeable
P. R.
P. R.
Jul 16, 2021
Report
I needed a piece of Siesta Key! Silver City has a trademark "Siesta Key gemstone" made from the same quartz as Siesta sand. Beautiful craftsmanship at an affordable price. I also saw they have a collection of actual Siesta sand and turquoise that I may "need" also. Professional, knowledgeable and sweet sales people. NO PRESSURE sales. We will definitely return for more pieces.
Michael L.
Michael L.
May 04, 2021
Report
Great local shop. Super friendly. Lots of great designs. Colored stones bring a pop to the silver. And reasonable prices!
Diane M.
Diane M.
Nov 21, 2020
Report
Such a beautiful and fun store! Sparkling jewelry with colorful unique gemstones - particularly their trademarked Siesta Key quartz stone. The store owners are friendly and helpful. Almost as pretty as the sunsets, Silver City is must-stop on the Key for the jewelry lover. Bring your man - even the guys like this store! :)
Grace S.
Grace S.
Feb 21, 2019
Report
Silver City Sarasota was recommended to us by Tim and Jan of Key Sailing. When we told them that we had been married in Siesta Key over 10 years ago, Jan showed us a beautiful ring made with Siesta Key sand and a gorgeous bracelet with the Siesta Key Watercolor gemstone that Silver City Sarasota created. I was immediately hooked and now own both the ring and bracelet! If you are visiting the Sarasota/Siesta Key area, stop into Silver City Sarasota to see their wonderfully unique pieces that will help you remember the trip forever! I promised you will not be disappointed.
Lisa S.
Lisa S.
Feb 19, 2019
Report
I'm from the Boston area and frequent Sarasota. I make 2 stops, without fail and no matter the length of my stay. They are Cafe Bacchi and SILVER CITY! Silver City has beautiful and unique jewelry. I have yet to visit and not leave with a new piece(s) each and every time. My collection is growing as do the endless compliments that I receive when wearing them. Thanks ladies. See you soon. Cannot wait to create my turtle charm
Maggie D.
Maggie D.
Sep 02, 2018
Report
Great experience, Monica and Debra?? Were fabulous! I needed a great, original gift for a very important corporate function with all Chips. Silver city worked with me on ordering 16 money clips with Siesta Key sand and shipping it asap since it was very last minute on my part. The beautiful money clips were in a velvet pouch, in a light blue box with a ribbon. Everyone loved them! These people travel all over and get all types of goodies in there hotel room upon checking in and we wanted something different, original showcasing our area. My went and bought me a glass charm for my Pandora with
Anna P.
Anna P.
May 28, 2018
Report
I love the staff here as well as the beautiful jewelry! We plan to come every year to add to my "Siesta Key" gemstone collection. I received so many compliments on my ring that I purchased earrings to match. Next trip it will be the bracelet! Thank you Suzanne for always knowing just what I need!!
Lucy H.
Lucy H.
Feb 28, 2018
Report
My husband and I live half of the year in Sarasota. Silver City is our favorite jewelry store. We shop quite a bit for exquisite and unusual pieces of jewelry. SILVER CITY DELIVERS!!!! The owners Monica and her husband George are one of a kind. They are honest and so attentive to my taste. Debra who works there is outstanding at knowing what jewelry matches what. She also lets me know how to wear it. Suzanne who also works there is extremely kind and is always showing me new pieces. I have to say I wait until we get to Sarasota every November to buy my jewelry. Silver City is a gem. The prices
Patricia D.
Patricia D.
Feb 15, 2018
Report
Last year I discovered this wonderful jewelry store. I purchased pieces as gifts and for myself. Today I drove an hour and half just to go to this store and once again found outstanding pieces of outstanding quality. Not only are the designs unique but the quality and customer service are beyond comparison. Run don't walk to this wonderful place, you won't be sorry!
Pixie M.
Pixie M.
Nov 25, 2012
Report
Lovely shop with uberfriendly staff! Love the unique items they carry.