Name: Castle Hill Supper Club
Address: N9581 US Highway 12, Merrillan, WI, 54754, US
Telephone: (715) 333-5901
Rating: 4.11

Castle Hill has a great selection of wine, craft beer and cocktails to compliment your meal! Castle Hill has been Jackson County's Choice for dinner for more than 79 years. Since 1976 the Hensel Family has carried on Castle Hill's rich tradition of serving only the finest food and providing the best possible service.

We hope your visit will be a pleasant one and you will allow us to serve you again in the future. In addition to serving the Finest steaks and seafood in Jackson County, Castle Hill Supper Club boasts a 400 seat banquet hall that is very popular for weddings and other special events. Ask us about reserving our large banquet facility for your wedding or special event!

Website Update

Services

Legendary” Steaks Report

All of our "Famous" Steaks are either USDA Prime or Choice cuts of Beef and expertly grilled to your specifications by our Chefs!. Our Signature Sirloin - a mouthwatering USDA Choice Center-cut Top Sirloin, fire-grilled for extra juiciness and flavor. Dinners include: Choice of Potato Jumbo Idaho Baked w/Real WI Sour Cream, American Fries, Crispy Battered French Fries, Potato Skins, Hash Browns or Vegetable Medley.

Reviews (9)

Write a Review

Brandon Mckevitt

Dec 19, 2021

Report

Dont waste your money. service sucks food is not what you would expect from a supper club have had better steaks and prime rib served at a bar ...and don't bother calling for take out called many times a minute after they open and say they are too busy...the owner yelled in my pregnet girlfriends face because we didn't not find that a 25 dollor steak should look like a minute steak and be over cooked.....unbelievably un happy with this place

Shari Christianson

Dec 01, 2021

Report

This is not a supper club. It's more of a glorified Old Country Buffet with a bar. Staff was nice. But disappointing...

Lucas Jensen

Nov 12, 2021

Report

Great Friday night fish fry. Coleslaw was tangy and creamy. Fish was crunchy and flaky. Tarter sauce had good flavor.

Muriel Chappell

Aug 19, 2021

Report

Very good food. Had reservations and the wait to be seated was good .The waitress was in training and was excellent.

Brian Bock

Jun 11, 2021

Report

The food was spectacular. This is the best prime rib I have ever had. Great food for the entire family. Service was amazing. Our servers were organized, helpful, and very quick with the food for our large >25 group.

B. Hart

May 12, 2021

Report

Two of us had prime rib and it wasn't up to par this time. Not as tender as it normally is. The other two in our party had steaks and were very pleased. The remainder of the meal and drinks were wonderful. The service was great.

Mickey Crittenden

Apr 30, 2021

Report

Castle Hill Supper Club is a great quality dining experience and reasonably priced. The Friday fish fry is wonderful, but the Saturday night Prime Rib is the signature dish, consistently prepared to perfection. Every steak on the menu is a winning option. The cozy bar is nice for a cocktail before dinner. The staff are friendly and helpful to an exceptional degree.

Shirley Kirby

Mar 03, 2021

Report

Their seafood buffet was really good and so was the service. Very nice atmosphere and clean. And the price was right.

Kathie Smestad

Oct 12, 2019

Report

Start with the barbecue ribs! fall off the bone tender! Just the perfect sauce not to sweet with a little bit of tang. The prime rib was cooked perfectly. Packed with flavor. Then the shrimp served with steamed vegetables; light breading on the shrimp cooked to perfection . The service was spot on , water cups full and dishes removed fast. It’s a very busy place so plan ahead or come early