McMahon Insurance Agency
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
McMahon Insurance Agency
Since 1922, there's been no better choice for insurance on the coast than McMahon Insurance Agency. Just as you've grown to trust us for policies protecting your family, home, health and business, we've grown to three locations (Ocean City, Marmora & Cape May) to serve you throughout NJ, PA and DE.

We're proud to say we've helped thousands of your neighbors - many over multiple generations - and we look forward to assisting you, too. Because of McMahon's open communication and outstanding service, I have much more confidence when it comes to my policies, coverages, and most importantly my premiums.
Services
Founded in 1922, McMahon Insurance brings to you nearly 100 years of success in meeting insurance needs and delivering satisfaction. Unlike others, we won't simply refer you to an 800 number. Call us instead at 609-399-0060 at any time 24/7/365 and we'll take full ownership of your claim. Many national insurers and local agencies shy away from flood insurance.
As an independent insurance agency, McMahon Insurance works with insurers that have proven their performance and value over the years. We carefully select highly regarded underwriters that offer comprehensive coverages at highly competitive rates. Each client is provided the individual attention of our knowledgeable and talented staff.
From the rooftop to the kitchen range, protect the financial investment you've made in your primary residence and vacation home with comprehensive homeowners plans from McMahon Insurance. You want the best homeowners insurance in NJ, PA, and De. The average homeowners insurance policy insures the home itself and the things you keep in it.
According to the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), thirty percent of flood claims are filed by people living in moderate- or low-risk areas; whether you are inland or near the coastline. A standard homeowners policy does not cover damages from flooding.

McMahon Insurance Agency is underwritten by the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) and can provide coverage for losses to your property caused by rising water which your homeowners insurance excludes.Are you in a flood zone? What are your flood options? Don't wait for a rainy day to learn about the affordable ways McMahon Insurance Agency can help to protect our home and its contents.
A condominium insurance policy protects you from the risks associated with being both a homeowner and a condo association member. McMahon Insurance Agency recognizes these specialized needs and maintains a department dedicated to meeting them. Generally, insurance offered by condo associations only covers the exterior of your condo, while the interior and your possessions are protected under your own condo insurance policy.
Reviews (10)
Alfred Moschella
Alfred Moschella
Dec 05, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness
I'm very happy with the service provided by Brian Mitchell. He is polite, professional and quick to respond to all questions and correspondence. Thank you for assigning him to my account.
Charles
Charles
Nov 25, 2021
Report
Bonnie Ash and the McMahon Agency have been our go to insurance company for years. Bonnie Ash is our insurance angel. She is extremely knowledgeable and always fights to get the best rates for us. I sleep well at night.
Chuck Salomon-Lowden
Don Carlino
Don Carlino
Nov 20, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness
Bonnie is great, she quickly (less than 24 hours) turned around a policy that was originally placed for too low a value, and which was needed for my construction mortgage...great firm that really understands the needs of NJ shore home owners, including those undertaking a new construction project.
Patrick Pruitt
Patrick Pruitt
Nov 04, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Great customer service. Angela Wolfe was responsive and explained the whole process of getting new home insurance and making sure everything was taken care of professionally.
Bernadette Donnelly
Bernadette Donnelly
Nov 02, 2021
Report
The account managers at McMahon are the BEST in the business. Anytime I need to request a copy of insurance for our customers here at Sturdy Savings Bank, the response is quick, professional and very nice to work with!!! I would like to thank some of the Account Managers : Bonnie Ash, Jake Cassidy, Beth Skversky, Joan Adams, Peggy Weir, Steacy Hartman, Darleen Bonner, Betsy Brown, Dominique, Lynne Tomasello , and all the Staff at McMahon Agency!!!
Janet Andrew
Janet Andrew
Aug 16, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
We have been working with Bonnie Ash now for several years and she does an excellent job handling our properties.
Gloria Heater
Gloria Heater
Aug 07, 2021
Report
McMahon Insurance Agency is excellent in a) problem solving; b) need determination and c) speed in responses for small business commercial coverages. They note all coverages in binder format for us, take our calls with quick answers and makes us feel like family. Great company, I would recommend.
Lisa Rice
Lisa Rice
Jun 22, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness
I have been a customer for many years and recently had a good experience with adding another policy. The team was very responsive and offered me good value options.
Paul McIntyre - Pds
Paul McIntyre - Pds
Apr 24, 2021
Report
Great agency. Always get me whatever we need quickly. Highly recommended.
Laura Myers
Laura Myers
Oct 20, 2020
Report
In my opinion the number one quality of the McMahon Insurance Agency is its responsiveness. On December 7, 2020, I spoke to Michael McMahon about the possibility of my homeowner's insurance through Narragansett Bay Insurance Company covering the replacement of a seven-year old heater I had to have replaced.
The next day I dropped off copies of documents relative to the replacement of the heater. Within several hours Michael sent me an email advising me he had submitted them along with a Loss Notice to Narragansett Bay Insurance Company for an adjuster to be assigned. He gave me the claim number