Reach Waldorf Astoria

This place checked off the boxes: great view, great food, great service. Both meals were big portions and we left full and happy. Great way to start the day with ocean views, a bloody mary in hand and some good breakfast.

Fabulous ocean view while you dine. This restaurant serves as the main food spot for the Hilton Reach hotel. We come here for breakfast while staying at the Reach or the Waldorf Astoria Casa Marina, as you can use your resort credit in the restaurant. Since this is part of the hotel, you pay hotel prices for the food. Sit outside on the patio enjoying the sounds of the waves crashing.

I order the coastal sunrise, which is 2 eggs, bacon or chicken sausage, hash browns and toast. Good overall meal. My wife enjoys the breakfast Turkey BLT.

Thai Calamari with peppers was excellent as were the scallops and fish and chips. Outstanding service. Less elegant decor than we expected but a very memorable dinner. Look forward to coming again.

Wow! Beautiful decor throughout the restaurant. And the view outside!!! Can't be beat. Our server was so sweet and accommodating to our big group. The food was great!!! And it may seem like a small thing, but it's a pet peeve when your dinner arrives and isn't piping hot. It was HOT, pleased w that. While we waited for our dinner we walked out on the dock and took some great photos as the sun set. From appetizers to dessert it was GREAT!!!

The scenery is beautiful and the food is delicious. My girlfriends and I are thinking about staying at the hotel next time we're in town because everything is so nice. I went for brunch and had the Mash, I enjoyed it a lot. I also ordered bottomless mimosas and got to keep the champagne bottle which was fantastic. Nice staff and good food.

The staff and Manager Josh at Four Marlins were the bright spot of our vacation at The Reach. Josh did a fantastic job with our beach dinner for our friends 70th birthday celebration. The server was also excellent and I'm sorry I forgot her name. We ate breakfast and lunch almost daily on our stay and the Chef never disappointed. I know a cheeseburger is just a cheeseburger but there's is the best we've ever eaten. Thank you again for being the bright spot of our hotel stay.

Nicely appointed dining area. The service was excellent. I had the hush puppies which were very good. The FM salad that was also good. The entree of the yellow fish with Brussel sprout leaves was $38 and was the worst fish plate I've ever seen or tasted. The plate was a mess...there was about 5 brussel sprout leaves scattered around the plate. Scales and bones filled every bite. The pile of inedible portions of the meal equaled what was edible. When you're eating fish in the Florida Keys at a Hilton owned property, I expect more.

We came here today for lunch and Ashley was our server. The restaurant has a nice view and great atmosphere. It's clean and everything you'd expect from an upscale hotel - with exception of the customer service.

We (5 adults and a 2-year old) were greeted by the hostess and who would eventually be our server, but no smiles. Just very straight-faced business. No big deal, we went along to our table outside. Great views and the restaurant was really pretty. We received our menus and gave our drink orders. Unfortunately our server dropped our whole tray of drinks and they had to be remade

Made it to the Florida Keys today and our hotel recommended this neat restaurant. WHAT A VIEW!!!!! The service was awesome, thanks Adam you are the best. My husband and I shared our dishes.... Seafood Mac and cheese, Baby gem lettuce salad, Grouper, Grilled Spiny Lobster and Key Lime pie. All of these dishes were from their small menu so they were the perfect size. Loved everyone of these dishes!!!! Bathrooms are super clean. I would definitely come back.

Amazing shrimp and grits! Would definitely get again. This is also what the server suggested as it is his favorite thing on the menu.

Visiting Key West for a double 40th birthday trip, we reserved a large evening sunset dinner. Josh worked with us on the menu, set up and it ended up being amazing! The modern nautical theme, location, view... just beautiful. Food was delicious, service was excellent and the restaurant/bar looked like it was newly renovated. If you are looking for a small intimate dinner-or booking a large group dinner- I highly suggest Four Marlins. Josh knocked it out of the park... customized printed menus, adjusting the seating from 16 to 22 person--he went above and beyond to make the birthday dinner truly

This spot, view and hospitality was exceptional. We had a very large group of 22 people and they had us seated in our own private area with a full view of the ocean. We had a specific menu to choose from and everything was delicious even the Key Lime Pie.

This was a truly amazing dining experience, a hidden gem in key west. I hesitated to even write a review because I don't want anyone to find this secret place lest I have to make reservations months in advance like the nearby Louies who had the same exact views ! Our waitress was helpful in making our meal choice, as you can choose small plates or large. We opted for small and picked 3 to share between us. We got the grouper, the spiny lobster, and the Mac and cheese. I was unsuccessful at capturing pictures of the grouper because i devoured it. In fact not a crumb left from our meal or dessert

We stayed at the hotel and this was also the pool menu, breakfast, and dinner.

it is right on the beach and if you prefer the AC and sit inside it's really nice place and cutely themed to beachy.
We kept coming back for the calamari. it was lightly breaded and had these amazing spicy pickles with it. We probably had it like 5 times on our trip. we also had a fried chicken Sammy which was a huge portion of chicken and amazing.
then had some shrimp it was cleaned and great dipping sauce.
The only downside we wish the menu changed daily or included more seafood options. other than that we

The meal was outstanding, Katie was so helpful and great to see her again. We sooo miss the wood fired oysters from 5 mos ago.
The hostess gals are the weakest link, pretty unbelievable but if you are patient and get past them... everything is exceptional!

The food was delicious and we were greeted with friendly service and seated quickly even after showing up early! The food is a little expensive but the food
Is very high end! But hands down the best key lime pie ever!

Loved this place. Fabulous views, great service--the best daiquiri I've ever had and crab cakes that are out of this world. If you want the calming views of the ocean, a clean white patio and incredible food, this place will
make you happy. Wanted to go back every single night.

Walked across this little gem and ventured inside for a piña colada. There was great live music, and a pier with a gazebo as well. There was a turtle habitat and even bronze are of a card game you can sot at for a photo opp. There is a lot of activity with the jet skis and swimming pool staying very busy throughout the day, but if you take just a moment to appreciate the Hampton bay decor, the patterned walls in the atrium or the cage chairs just outside this place is awesome to check out. It was also the best piña colada I had my entire trip made with real fruit and coco Lopez, not some sugary

For Dinner-

We stayed at Casa Marina and decided to try Four Marlins since it was at the sister property, The Reach.

We made a reservation online though we may not have needed to. The restaurant decor is fresh modern boathouse (is that a thing??) with tons of seating inside and out. Service was wonderful from beginning to end.

My husband and I had a rather disappointing dinner the night before (somewhere else) so we were sort of desperate for a decent meal.

We ordered a bunch of plates and shared them all.
Here is what we ordered:
Crab Rice - recommend
Roasted Oysters - really recommend
Pork

Can't get a much better view for dining in Key West! Stayed at the resort and had lunch here. The Mahi sandwich was grilled perfectly and topping were fresh and fantastic. My wife had the cheeseburger and loved it. A bit pricey, but very convenient. Overall excellent experience including the service.