Audrey's Fine Baked Goods has earned a well-known and respected reputation in the industry, providing high-quality baked goods for Long Island and New York tri-state area since 1996. You can find us in the heart of West Sayville, Long Island, our home for the last years!. All of our cakes and fillings are made on-premise, and we offer a variety of designs and flavors to accomodate even the most demanding needs.
In addition to servicing many restaurants, retail customers, private venues and local businesses, our products are featured at all of our Long Island and New York Apogee Events catering establishments. Made from the freshest, finest ingredients, our cakes are sure to stand out on your special day. Stocked daily, our bakery specializes in assorted breads, pastries, and of course, cakes for all occasions.
In addition to servicing many restaurants, retail customers, private venues and local businesses, our products are featured at all of our Long Island and New York Apogee Events catering establishments. Made from the freshest, finest ingredients, our cakes are sure to stand out on your special day. Stocked daily, our bakery specializes in assorted breads, pastries, and of course, cakes for all occasions.
Services
From the finest, most elaborate wedding event to a romantic backyard celebration, we have a cake to match - the perfect end to your magical celebration. Take your personal style and inspiration, add the passion and talent of our decorators, and there is a reason Audrey's is known for amazing results.
There is always a risk of cross-contamination so there are no guarantees that any items will not contain traces of nuts, wheat or soy. We do not offer dairy free cakes. This is a traditional gift from the bride to the groom! Tell us his favorite flavors, icings, fillings, etc and give him something sweet on the big day.
Reviews (9)
Amanda Tirado
Dec 26, 2021
Report
Audreys is the best! Our wedding cake was both stunning and delicious. Katie was so helpful and easy to work with. We also got apple cider donuts and various pies for our october wedding which were to die for. So many of our guests raved about the desserts. We’ve definitely found our new favorite bakery!
Luke Robertson
Oct 15, 2021
Report
Andrea Doelger
Sep 03, 2021
Report
I have been a loyal customer for 15 years but will never purchase from Audrey’s again. I ordered (paid in full) a cake for my daughter’s birthday. Unfortunately, I had to reschedule my daughter’s birthday due to medical reasons. I called and rescheduled the cake 4 days early and requested a smaller cake. I was told “sure no problem” they could change the date and size of my cake. When I picked up the cake they gave me a smaller cake but refused to reimburse me the difference for the larger cake. A manager was not at the bakery. I was told the manager would call me when they were back
Philip B.
Aug 30, 2021
Report
I am seeing an ongoing theme within the last few months and now I am not surprised of my own situation and latest encounter. I have been a customer of Audrey's for the past 20 years and have spent thousands on pastries and cakes through the years. I went in to order a 1/4 sheet birthday cake last Wednesday for Saturday. I was told they can not accommodate. No let me ask, just no you can only have an 8 inch pre-made. I left disgusted and disappointed. I then called Stanley's bakery and was told not a problem, I asked do I have to come down, Nope. Cake was ready on Saturday, and I was happily greeted
Olivia Myszkowski
Aug 14, 2021
Report
My husband and I used Audrey's Fine Baked Goods for our wedding cake on Friday and we couldn't be any happier! From the beginning, we worked with Katie and she has very helpful and very accommodating. We did our cake tasting in the height of COVID, and she was able to set us up with a to-go tasting which we did at home. She was also flexible when we had to move our wedding date twice! On the day of the wedding, the cake looked simple yet elegant---exactly what we wanted, and tasted phenomenal! We also had many guests tell it was "the best wedding cake they've ever tasted" and we couldn't agree
Marie Boyle
Jun 23, 2021
Report
Audrey’s is known as a wonderful bakery. I too had a terrible experience asking for a specialty item on the phone. It was for a christening. I asked for a special kind of cake. She said they didn’t make it. And, that was that. End of conversation. Didn’t even check with anyone. The young girl should never be handling phone duty or orders. They lost a big sale that day. I wouldn’t go out of my way to go here with this amount of attitude.
Maria Lambertson
Jun 07, 2021
Report
I ordered two cakes for a friend's birthday, one being the funfetti with funfetti frosting, looked amazinggg, so did the black forest. But look at that funfetti cake, you think it's going to be amazing right?!!?! Nope. It was plain vanilla with sprinkles, and the vanilla wasn't even that strong so it just tasted like sugar. I'm a buttercream lover and yes it was right consistency but all I tasted was sugar, no flavor. It was a real let down. Toooo much buttercream between layers also. I was disappointed cause everything looked so good at the bakery that I wanted to pick up extra treats. But anyone
Alexis Volka
May 17, 2021
Report
Been coming here around 20 years and normally the cakes are very good. However don't bother ordering a Tiramisu cake here. What we ending up serving what appeared to be previously mousse cake. This cake most importantly could not have been not freshly made. What was supposed to be marscapone filling was vanilla mousse that was thawing still, barely if any marscapone cheese, no coffee liquor flavor whatsoever, not layered, the lady fingers were hard as rocks and dry (supposed to be soaked in espresso). Everyone who had a slice barely touched it. What a disappointment and for the price not worth
Catherine Schneider
Jan 14, 2021
Report
