We are a team of Independent Insurance advisors located in Columbus, Indiana. We can help you with all of your insurance needs by comparing your coverages and rates with multiple insurance providers, saving you time, aggravation, and money. Auto Insurance We'll customize a policy that offers great coverage at an equally great rate.
Life Insurance We'll help you protect your family for pennies on the dollar with life insurance. My family and I have been doing business with Zeller Insurance in Columbus, Indiana for over 45 years. Throughout that time we have found the staff to be professional but also responsive and caring. They unfailingly look to provide safety and security while looking for ways to reduce the cost for the insured.
Life Insurance We'll help you protect your family for pennies on the dollar with life insurance. My family and I have been doing business with Zeller Insurance in Columbus, Indiana for over 45 years. Throughout that time we have found the staff to be professional but also responsive and caring. They unfailingly look to provide safety and security while looking for ways to reduce the cost for the insured.
Services
Zeller Insurance was established by Bill Zeller in 1972 as a full-service independent insurance agency. Upon his death in 2011, the management team of Tim Zeller, Rick Zeller and Lori Rowan assumed ownership. In keeping with Bill's core philosophy, we continue to adhere to the highest ethical and professional standards in dealing with our clients, prospects, and companies.
One of the best things you can do as a client of our agency is to leave us an online review. If you've had a positive experience with our agency and/or a member of our staff, we would be grateful if you took a few seconds to leave us a review. It couldn't be easier, and it helps us tremendously in terms of other people finding our agency online.
Here at Zeller Insurance, we take your trust very seriously, so it means a lot to us when you refer your friends and family to our agency. If you refer someone to Zeller Insurance and we are able to quote them, we will send you a $5 gift card to Sogno della Terra as a token of our appreciation! There are no limits to the number of gift cards or raffle entries you can receive, so remember to refer often!
If you need help with this process, please call the office at 812-372-8456, and we will be glad to assist you in learning the system. If you have a blue invoice or a red statement from Zeller Insurance, you will be able to pay your bill through this online portal. You will need your Zeller Insurance specific account number in order to use this site.
To get the quote process started, please complete the fields below. We will reach out to you to gather more information to complete your quote and provide you with a proposal. These can be easily downloaded from your online profile with your current provider (if you have a login), or from your current agent.
Reviews (11)
Daniel Douglass
Sep 27, 2021
Report
Will Wagner
Mar 04, 2021
Report
Tom Rust
Nov 28, 2018
Report
Cliff Putterill
Nov 17, 2018
Report
Cindy Slaughter
Oct 30, 2018
Report
Laszlo Tikk
Oct 10, 2018
Report
Ron Harrell
Aug 31, 2018
Report
This is an outstanding agency! We found experienced, caring agents who are client-focused. The agency offers a variety of products tailored to consumer needs, all at a competitive price. The Zeller team is available, approachable, friendly and responsive. We’re pleased to be part of the Zeller Family!
Larry Olson
Aug 29, 2018
Report
I have been a customer of Zeller Insurance for over 30 years. They have always worked hard to find the best insurance at the most competitive rates. There staff is always professional, courteous and prompt in getting me the help I need whether it's looking into checking on better rates or filing a claim. It is always a pleasure to do business with all of the members of Zeller Insurance.
Tom Gorman
Aug 23, 2018
Report
Diana Lynn Biddle
Jun 21, 2018
Report
Kathryn Armstrong
Jun 14, 2018
Report
We had such a positive experience with Tim Zeller when we decided to change insurance companies. We received more coverage with less premium expense. We each recently purchased new vehicles and Tim had the coverage switched for us immediately with one telephone call. Insurance for our home and vehicles is something we never need to worry about thanks to Zeller.
