Website
Call
Justin May Insurance & Financial Services
Although I may not be Jake from State Farm, my team and I have been helping individuals with their Auto, Life, Home, and Renter's Insurance for over 25 years combined. We also assist customers with business insurance along with obtaining a surety bond or a fidelity bond. I am the son, nephew, and brother of current or former State Farm agents.

I graduated from Granville High School in central Ohio and attended The Ohio State University, graduating with a degree in Social and Behavioral Sciences. My wife Brynn and I love spending time with friends, family, and our dogs. What sets our office apart is the personalized insurance and financial services plans that are molded to fit each individual based on their needs.
Reviews (14)
Sarah Jenkins
Sarah Jenkins
Aug 03, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Tyler was super nice and quick with getting me switched to State Farm! Made the process so easy!
Barry Sweeney Jrn A. Lot
Barry Sweeney Jrn A. Lot
May 30, 2021
Report
I've been w Justin May. I think for about five years. And they are always very professional. With whatever I need I can call them anytime. And they will stop and address my concerns questions and needs immediately. The one time I had a accident they called me right away to make sure I was OK. Great people
Katie Coomes
Katie Coomes
May 02, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness
Switching car insurance is always a hassle but Tyler made it easy. I felt like I understood any changes I made to my policy and felt good about what I set up. He even called with me to cancel my existing plan from another provider! Thank you for making this process easy and for saving me money!
Angel Eyes
Angel Eyes
Mar 15, 2021
Report
I was so nervous about switching my insurance but Tyler was absolutely amazing and made the transition very smooth. I love the way he handled my situation. Making it work for me. I appreciate that more than you can understand. Thank you Tyler for being wonderful.
Joe Upholzer
Joe Upholzer
Jan 19, 2021
Report
After being with the same insurance representative for over twenty years, we decided to make a change. Our plan was to shop around, & make an informed decision. I reached out to our local State Farm Representative & spoke to Jason Zander. Not only were the price quotes for auto, & home significantly less, but the coverage was better as well. After talking with Mr. Zander, there was a comfort level that led us to stop the search & make the change immediately. Quick, efficient, & professional... we hope to be with State Farm, Jason Zander & the Justin May Insurance group for many years to come.
Maryam Musa
Maryam Musa
Jan 07, 2021
Report
I initially invested a total of $105,000 over a period of 5 weeks. My bonus/profit was $830,000, every attempt to make withdrawal failed and I was instructed to make another deposit of $25,000 before I can make withdrawals which I did. Up till now, I'm still unable to make withdrawals and all attempts to contact brokers have failed. This is very… pathetic and I felt so bad losing my investment. I did a due diligence test before investing with them but guess what I ended up getting burned. This is to create awareness, not everybody can be as lucky as I was. I'm saying this because I was able
Herman Speck
Herman Speck
Dec 06, 2020
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness
Tyler was very professional and knowledgeable in helping us with our insurance needs. Customer service is a priority at this State Farm office.
George H.
George H.
Nov 14, 2020
Report
Hi,
I’m a brand new State Farm Customer and after many years with another Insurance Company I came over to State Farm on the recommendation of Friends and Family. A shout out to Jason Zander, Thanks Jason! You made my transition go smooth and seamless, and you saved me some money,
So thanks again with a wish for a very Happy New Year!
George H.
Maureen McHugh
Maureen McHugh
Aug 13, 2019
Report
Jason at this agency reworked everything for me and i converted from a lifetime Allstate girl to State Farm I cannot be happier -- this agency CARES! I am happy to say I am a part of this team for a year now!
Carlita Arn
Carlita Arn
Jun 16, 2019
Report
Justin is an incredible insurance agent. He remembers your name and really makes you feel comfortable. He explains everything in a very helpful way, but not condescending. It was not a hard sales pitch. He communicates via phone and email for follow ups. The location is tough to make a left out of during busy driving times.
Nicole Hawkins
Nicole Hawkins
Nov 19, 2017
Report
If you’re looking for a reliable and honest insurance agent, Justin is your guy. All my insurance needs are bundled into one easy monthly payment. The rates are much better than other competitors. Justin and his team are always available to answer any questions you may have, they truly care for you and your family’s insurance needs.
Brandt Hawkins
Brandt Hawkins
Nov 14, 2017
Report
As a customer service professional myself, it is rare to find an individual who exemplifies the true meaning of a consummate professional and that is exactly what Justin May does. Justin's passion for service… is deeply rooted in a belief of always doing right by his clients and their specific needs. He is highly competent and has put forth the effort to be an extraordinary asset to his clients, as they make crucial decisions in protecting themselves and their families today while securing their tomorrow.
Justin is extremely patient and very straight forward. His impeccable integrity is
Tammy Hawkins
Tammy Hawkins
Nov 14, 2017
Report
Justin May is more than you could ever want in a insurance agent. He is very knowledgeable and thorough providing a rapid response to all your questions and needs. Justin is not pushy, rather very patient and answered every question we had for him. I highly recommend him for any and all your insurance needs.
Keanna S.
Keanna S.
Jul 17, 2017
Report
Justin May and his staff provide wonderful customer service and honesty. My s/o spent the summer as an intern there, and he always came back from the work day with positive things to say. His coworkers and work environment helped him get hands-on experience for his career beginning in Summer 2018. While visiting the office, you will realize there are some very kind people there that want to help you and not just get the most money out of you that they can. Would recommend him over the others in the area.