Barnes Jewelers
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Barnes Jewelers was established in the South Shore area of Milwaukee, Wisconsin in 1986. After quickly outgrowing this location, Barnes Jewelers relocated to Brookfield, Wisconsin in 1993. This move was a wise decision, as we greatly increased our inventory and expanded our loyal customer base. We again outgrew this store, and when the opportunity to relocate to a growing community presented itself, we decided to move once again, this time to the Pabst Farms Marketplace in Oconomowoc.
Services
At Barnes Jewelers we are known for our wide variety of professional services. We take pride in the high quality of our services, fair pricing, and lightning fast turnaround time. John Sr. is one of the few Certified Gemologist-Appraisers in Wisconsin. With his 40 years of experience, you can be assured that your appraisal will be done accurately and professionally.
The word carat derives from the word carob, a Mediterranean seed, which has an extremely consistent weight for measuring. The greater the carat weight, the rarer, and more valuable the diamond becomes. Five metric carats weighs exactly 1 gram. Some people want the largest diamond possible.

If size is a priority, we at Barnes Jewelers can help you classify the proper cut, color and clarity to fit your budget economically, and fit your jewelry beautifully.Many of our engagement rings can fit diamonds up to 5.00 carats, but each ring has different size constraints based on its size and the type of setting.
Every year, Barnes Jewelers travels nearly 10,000 miles to hand select diamonds in Antwerp for our customers back in Oconomowoc. With our connections overseas, we are able to cut out the middleman, and save money in the process. With this elite service, we extend these savings to our customers, and are able to get the best selection of diamonds in the world.
Kendra Scott Jewelry View our Kendra Scott Jewelry at Barnes Jewelers. Pandora PANDORA is a universe of jewelry. Each piece of Danish design is handcrafted in sterling silver or 14K gold. Many pieces incorporate pearls, semi-precious and precious stones. PANDORA's modular design allows the wearer to change the beads for an elegant look, or change the bracelet for a casual wear at a moment's notice.
Ashi offers a dazzling range of exquisitely crafted fine jewelry featuring our signature I Do Collection engagement rings and bridal sets along with a wide array of beautiful diamonds and precious gemstones rings, earrings, necklaces, pendants, bracelets, and fashionable fine jewelry of all descriptions and value.
Reviews (9)
Matthew Dixon
Matthew Dixon
Dec 27, 2021
Report
Helpful staff, great selection, they even rush resized my wife's ring the Thursday before our wedding!
Ashley Bentrup
Ashley Bentrup
Nov 05, 2021
Report
We can’t say THANK YOU enough! Everyone is the absolute sweetest and so accommodating! Everything was just so perfect, and I couldn’t be happier. You are all amazing, especially Rachel. So happy we decided to go with Barnes 💍❤️
Kevin Keller
Kevin Keller
Oct 25, 2021
Report
Looking for an honest to goodness, caring, and professional jeweler, Barnes and Co. is your shop. We worked with them from March - October 2021 and received only this highest quality service, personal touch, and pieces. There's was no pressure and Rachel was very responsive to our needs and desires. She was a lot of fun to work with as well! I would gladly recommend this shop and Rachel to family and friends.
We did shop around and speak with several jewelers, and Barnes was by far the top tier leaving others in the dust. Most jewelers either didn't seem to care about helping us find the best
Zach Chudy
Zach Chudy
Oct 18, 2021
Report
Great service incredibly helpful Jennifer is fantastic helped me get a ring in time to make it a special day
Brandon Barber
Brandon Barber
Sep 28, 2021
Report
Rude staff. Lost a customer that was willing to spend $2000. I guess what cloths I wear matter to how I'm treated.
Angela Fischer
Angela Fischer
Aug 26, 2021
Report
John Jr. was knowledgeable, patient and very helpful in assisting me with election and purchase. #supportsmallbusiness
Jo Weinkauf
Jo Weinkauf
Jul 04, 2021
Report
It was great working with Jennifer at Barnes Jewelers. Looking to get a new wedding ring to celebrate 40 years. After looking at several settings, found a unique setting and created a masterpiece. Can't love my new ring more. I highly recommend going to Barnes for a great experience.
Susan Waldman
Susan Waldman
Jan 15, 2021
Report
Popped in with 20 minutes to shop for my daughter's birthday present. Told her age and my budget, and the sales rep presented me so many ideas. I ended up with two items and $.50 under budget. Barnes is my go-to special occasion retailer. So many choices at so many price ranges!
Callie Neumann
Callie Neumann
Dec 10, 2020
Report
The people working there were friendly, not overbearing and very helpful. So thankful we stopped inside. Rachel helped us and she was great!