Coop's Pizza
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Coop's Pizza
Coop's Pizza Parloure in Hayward, WI | Family Favorite Restaurant Serving Pizzas, Italian Food, and Sandwiches. Coop's Pizza Parloure in Hayward, WI | Family Favorite Restaurant Serving Pizzas, Italian Food, and Sandwiches Family owned and operated since 1979, Coop's Pizza Parloure is your 1st Choice for an excellent dining experience for the entire family!

In addition to our great-tasting foods, Coop's Pizza Parloure features a log cabin-style atmosphere, with friendly, personable service while the kids enjoy a large family menu, game room and a 2000 gallon fresh water aquarium! Excellent service & even better Pizza! We will make the 45 minute trip from our annual camping spot just to come back to Coops - it's WORTH IT!
Services
Fried or grilled chicken served with salad greens, onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers, eggs & mozzarella cheese. House roasted beef on choice of white, marble rye or whole wheat with pepperocini (Giardiniera peppers on request) and chips. With your choice of cheese: mozzarella, pepper jack, cheddar, Swiss 13.99.
Reviews (20)
Brenda M.
Brenda M.
Jan 11, 2022
Report
The pizza, to my liking was not edible. The dough tasted like a biscuit and was bland. Maybe the pizza didn't come out right because we have eaten there before and it was good. When we asked The hostess, if there was anything she could do, she got defensive. Also, I felt it was overpriced, feel bad paying $15 for a 10 inch pizza that was not cooked right. I felt the manager - hostess could have reacted better in making me another or offering me a discount. And it was not just me I was there with someone else who also was of the same opinion.
Andrew Mills
Andrew Mills
Jan 09, 2022
Report
The only two things not to like was the suprise food prep charge they did not post this anywhere else in the restraunt for the pizza. They also need a better pizza cutter. Delicious thin crust pizza with large sausage pieces and plenty of black olives. The price is more expensive then a Dominos or a Little Ceasars but unlike them freshly made not mass produced.
M. Netterlund
M. Netterlund
Dec 18, 2021
Report
A Staple eating experience while in Hayward. Full salad bar includes pizza slices, chicken tenders, & garlic bread. Special was open till 2pm.
Keith Snyder
Keith Snyder
Oct 17, 2021
Report
This was some good pizza! The place was very busy but they got my carryout order in good time. It was a real hit where my wife was working that day. I definitely go again when we're in town.
Vivi Cooper
Vivi Cooper
Oct 14, 2021
Report
Delicious pizza and salad bar. Tasty French Onion Soup. Ingredients are always fresh. Comfortable, upbeat environment. Friendly staff. We visit Coop's Pizza every year when visiting Hayward. We love it! Consistently, one of the best restaurants in Hayward.
T. Tass
T. Tass
Sep 04, 2021
Report
I don't like the pizza, just too plain for my taste. Crust seems premade off-premise. My wife really likes the pizza though, so we go back.
Price/value is good.
Chicken tenders with pizza buffet are better than pizza but nothing special.
Salad bar could be better.
Soups are very salty.
North Woods atmosphere is enjoyable.
Josiah G.
Josiah G.
Aug 06, 2021
Report
On our way home from vacation we had one last dinner with the family. I ordered the corn dogs and the #4 pizza special individual size.
The pizza came out steaming hot and great flavor. The only downside was the fact it had too many toppings on it. Which is something I would never say lol! But, truly the extra cheese on top made it a little difficult to eat.

Suggestions- The Hawaiian pizza sounds delicious i should have got that one.

Moose Out
Eric K.
Eric K.
Jul 28, 2021
Report
Curb appeal was great with the log structure, outside seating and located just off the main road. Inside atmosphere was perfect for a family with little kids ( music and fish tank entertainment). The service was great even during these hard to find employees times(thanks covid) and our waitress was very nice and very helpful. Pizza taste was great and was nice they had a salad bar if you wanted to snack while you wait. I will definitely visit this establishment again in the near future!!
S.
S.
Jun 26, 2021
Report
Great family friendly atmosphere, warm and welcoming. The salad bar was great, plenty to choose from and the pizza was good crispy thin crust Hawaiian is what I got. Very saucy and lacking slightly in toppings and cheese however it was good. This restaurant has been a part of my family's traditions for over two decades. They still have a little portion of the restaurant with pinball and fun quarter games as well as a fish wall and plenty of interesting decor.
Pamela M.
Pamela M.
Apr 23, 2021
Report
Nice place, good food. It was great to walk into a restaurant and nobody jumped on you to wear a mask! They had a salad bar that you could actually get your own salad. No mask was amazing!!! Thank you!!
Dennis Quaderer Jr
Dennis Quaderer Jr
Apr 20, 2021
Report
This is a good pizza place, they have good customer service, the food is also great. They don't only serve pizzas either, they fry chicken, they got got burgers, a salad bar, a daily soup a big fish tank in the restaurant that you can look at and they also got a small game room for the kids to check out. This place has one of the best made pizzas there is in town.
John S.
John S.
Apr 14, 2021
Report
Go on a week day!!!
This buffet delivers a great culinary experience as well as deliver a old timey vibe as well. I'd recommend getting the egg rolls and the chicken strips. The barbecue sauce is also amazing. Overall, a really nice choice when riding around trying to find something to eat.
Jenn F.
Jenn F.
Feb 28, 2021
Report
The pizza was AMAZING! I had homemade Italian sausage and onions, and the sausage was one of the best I have ever had!
My wife is Vegan so she had a veggie with no cheese. She said it was the best vegan pizza she has ever had... who would have thought it would be in Hayward WI that she would say that!!
Richie Rich
Richie Rich
Jan 25, 2021
Report
I was surprisingly shocked on how good this pizza was. It's very comparable to Chicago style thin crust. I only have one small complaint, use fresh mushrooms instead of canned ones. The real mushrooms have a much better texture and taste. The canned ones are almost fake looking and tasting, and are kind of rubbery. I've been eating Chicago pizza my entire life and all the quality pizza parlors use real fresh mushrooms.
Update: So I heard some of the locals saying to try the seafood combination pizza. Well I did and I had them add onions. WOOOOOW JUST INCREDIBLE. Talk about something you've never
Anita Z.
Anita Z.
Jan 04, 2021
Report
No masks on employees or customers. It was annoying. We turned around and left. It's not 2019 anymore, Toto!
Lisa M.
Lisa M.
Oct 20, 2020
Report
The best pizza in Hayward!
I come here for pizza every time I come to visit my parents. Only downfall is...I wish I didn't live 350 miles away
Dawn C.
Dawn C.
Sep 09, 2020
Report
I have been visiting Coop's each year for the past 20+ years since I was a child, always a highlight of our travels with my parents among other tourist attractions. My family and I drove over 3 hours to take our kids to a relic of my childhood.

What a disappointment to discover that they believe the pandemic doesn't apply to them. None of the servers, hostesses, anyone - was wearing so much as a face shield. In fact, over 90% of the patrons were wearing one, most seeing the staff situation and then requesting an outside table. How are they not getting the message here?? STAY AWAY if
Chris W.
Chris W.
Oct 05, 2019
Report
Casual Up North ambience with a cool fish tank, great 80's music. Nice clean large restaurant with tables and booths to choose from. Lots of choices on menu from pizza to fried chicken dinners to sandwiches. Good selection of appetizers and beer, wine and mixed drinks. The pizza had a really good amount of cheese, sauce was just right, not too spicy, and nice crisp medium crust. We ordered the #4 and asked for the mushrooms on only half of the pizza but they could not do that for us. ??So the pizzas are not freshly made?? Other than that, we enjoyed our night at Coop's and will probably
Mister Jon
Mister Jon
Jan 21, 2019
Report
Excellent pizza and cheese bread. A small salad bar is also fresh and tasty. Large drink selection with reasonable drink prices. Pizza prices are moderately high for the area. Very interesting ambiance. Lots of stuffed animals and a large aquarium. Kids love it. There is also a small game rooms.
James Greathouse
James Greathouse
Aug 02, 2018
Report
Have not had a Coop's pizza in over 20 years. Didn't even know they moved to a new location. The pizza is still as good as I remember. Also, they have a fantastic salad bar as well as other Italian dishes.