Located in the heart of Randolph, NJ, Paisano's Pizzeria is proud to bring fresh, authentic Italian flavors to the residents of Morris County. From recipes that originate in Brooklyn, we are committed to staying true to what we've been taught and want to cook authentic New York style pizza and Italian entrees that you and your family will enjoy.
We invite you to come on in and taste the difference that fresh ingredients and family recipes make. The word paisano in Italian means a close friend or neighbor. At Paisano's Pizzeria, we seek to bring together friends and neighbors around a good meal. Let us do the cooking for you. Our desire is to bring the traditional "old school" authentic pizza and entrees across the river to New Jersey, for all to enjoy.
We invite you to come on in and taste the difference that fresh ingredients and family recipes make. The word paisano in Italian means a close friend or neighbor. At Paisano's Pizzeria, we seek to bring together friends and neighbors around a good meal. Let us do the cooking for you. Our desire is to bring the traditional "old school" authentic pizza and entrees across the river to New Jersey, for all to enjoy.
Reviews (9)
Siddharth Srivastav
Dec 29, 2021
Report
Izzy Dechiaro
Nov 26, 2021
Report
Trevor Waldron
Nov 22, 2021
Report
Natasha Rivera
Oct 22, 2021
Report
Anthony Quinones
Feb 22, 2021
Report
This place used to be scilicis pizza. Scilicis pizza was some of the best greasy pizza in the area. Once these people opened the shop back up under Paisano's I went back to give it a shot, really hoping the new pizza place was good since I lived close. Mannnnn I couldn't even finish the slice. Like it's not that it wasn't great. It's that it wasn't even good. My parents decided to try it before asking me if I have, and came to me the next day saying they had a full pizza with a few bits out of 2 slices missing. I just feel for the price you can do way better. Delicia's in Dover has one dollar slices
Cindy Finkelstein
Dec 15, 2020
Report
Chuck Mound
Aug 16, 2020
Report
This Pizza had a lot of potential..Very Good Sauce, Very Good Cheese with the crust at Ok. Ordered a Well done Margarita Pie, but could have used more time in the oven to get a little more crisp. This is first visit to this Pizzeria and I was happy with the first order. Speaking of which, you should think about that box promotion to 10 Pizzas Purchases versus 15 that you offer now. I would have to spend $300 before I get a Free Pizza basically. Anyway, I will be back, the place is new, clean and is on the right track with the Pizza. Did not recommend a signature Pizza on the Phone, just started
Rs
Jun 15, 2020
Report
First time going since it opened. As with any new business, business was busy. However, with busy business comes incompetence. In-short, the pie I ordered was wrong and to make matters worse, it wasn’t even cut when I got home to open it, shame on me for not checking when I was there...not to mention two plain pies was almost $30, seemed a bit expensive ...probably since I got charged for the pie I was suppose to get.. “The special”...Despite all this non-sense, the pizza was good. I would recommended going back but maybe when it settles down
Timothy Moran
Jun 05, 2020
Report
