Shine Insurance Agency
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Shine Insurance Agency
Shine took a look at one of my apartments and helped me realize some gaps in our coverage. With their help, we were able to improve our coverage, while managing our costs. On top of that, they explained the coverage in a way that empowered us to make informed decisions to manage risk across our portfolio.

Jeremy and his team have become a trusted advisor for us. From the very moment I filed the claim, the service from both Shine & the company was outstanding. Real estate is all about connections and team. I'd honestly never seen my insurance agent as an integral part of that until my broker introduced me to Shine.
Services
You'll never worry about mountains of paperwork, sit on hold for hours, or feel totally lost. You'll understand insurance because we talk to you like a person and treat you like family. Shine is an independent insurance agency committed making our clients & our community better.

Not only are we able to provide the best insurance experience you never imagined, but our Rise by Lifting Others program also directs a portion of every policy premium to organizations that lift their community.So it's pretty simple to say yes to Shine. Jeremy owns Shine Insurance Agency with McKenzie.
Your Shine team is here when you need a hand. Whether it's a billing question or a major disaster, the people you know are a simple call/text/email away. When smart insurance is simple you can move on with your life knowing your family is safe and Shine has your back. Smart protection for your family starts with a simple process and ends with confidence you've made an informed decision.
Independent insurance agents are one of the 3 avenues to getting home, auto, and business insurance. An independent agent is the only way to connect with an insurance advisor that doesn't work for the insurance companies they offer. Our allegiance is to our clients so we can educate and advocate for you.
Reviews (10)
Hilary Kanyi
Hilary Kanyi
Dec 28, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
The people who worked with me during my claim were great. The process was simple and quick, and helped to relive me during a bad situation.
Susan Carson
Susan Carson
Dec 21, 2021
Report
Shine truly did Shine in a very stressful situation. They were transparent, honest and empathetic."
Andrew Bogie
Andrew Bogie
Dec 07, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness
Had a great and informative experience speaking with Jeremy about commercial insurance coverage and options. ...He took the time to evaluate my current coverage and offer key insights. ...Very helpful and I certainly appreciate and recommend Shine.
Denise Breeden-Ost
Denise Breeden-Ost
Jul 15, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Friendly and helpful! Got us a better deal than we’d been getting.
Brooke Hannon
Brooke Hannon
Jun 28, 2021
Report
Jeremy is always so willing to help! I have loved working with them for my home & auto insurance. Quick responses and everything is very clearly explained. Highly recommend!
Jennie Vaughan
Jennie Vaughan
Jun 27, 2021
Report
We love SHINE. We just had a claim after a tree limb fell and hit our car. Filing the claim took minutes, no tranfering me to that dept or this dept. I was notified quickly via text on all the next steps, which made it super convenient with our busy schedules.
We appreciated the friendly check-in from Jeremy and Team Shine, just making sure we were in good shape, at the beginning and immediately following the service.
The Caliber Collision Center team was also incredible. Excellent communication and follow-through and with a smile! Our work was done earlier than expected too!
Thank you all so
Joni Piano
Joni Piano
Jun 16, 2021
Report
Jeremy and his team have been wonderful in providing me competitive quotes, efficient service (eg, when my car got broken into), and overall prompt communication for my property, car, and home renter insurances. They care about customers' need and priorities and try their best to clients first. I especially appreciate his team's prompt and warm email replies especially in several emergency situations. SHINE has a fantastic reputation in town and I highly recommend them.
Jesse Eastwood
Jesse Eastwood
Feb 05, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness
I’ve used Shine for my insurance needs over the last few years. Every time I’ve reached out to the team at Shine I get a prompt, accurate response. The team has a lot of expertise and takes a lot of the “heavy lifting” out of the process through their proactive research. I’ve already recommended them to friends and family!
Nikolaos Spurgetis
Nikolaos Spurgetis
Oct 20, 2020
Report
Deciding to recommend Shine to be your local insurance agency was easier than figuring out what I want for lunch today!
Jeremy, Talia, and the rest of the Shine team have been so helpful in dealing with a large homeowners insurance claim as well as handling our auto insurance. They are knowledgeable and have always provided prompt and friendly service.
Jeremy's advice throughout the claim process has been invaluable, and he has gone the extra mile several times to help resolve some issues directly with the contractor/mortgage company/actual provider of the insurance product. Furthermore, he will
Julie Stutler
Julie Stutler
Aug 28, 2020
Report
You know how sometimes you take your parents and upbringing for granted? Like, “Yeah, they saw to all my needs and took care of my emotional/physical/mental well being. Why wouldn’t they? They’re my parents.”
And then you go out into the cold, hard world and are exposed to the full extent of mankind. And you realize that your parents weren’t just good, they were great. And you want to call them up and be like, “OMG, I had no idea. Thank you. Thank you so much.”
Well I’ve moved away from Indiana after having Shine Insurance for so many years, and they’re like those supportive