Anthony's Restaurant & Pizzeria
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
All of your favorite Anthony's food items are now available chilled and frozen! From pizzas and family sized meals to subs, salads, and weekly specials - Anthony's has prepared foods in our grab-and-go market ready for pick-up. Grab something fresh for now and frozen for later!. Enjoy our fresh and frozen food market, or something from our take-out menu, both available all day.

Calling your order in ahead of time is best, but you are always welcome to come in and browse our selections.
Services
I can still remember the day in June of 2013 when my husband and daughter returned from a ride through town and said, "guess which building is for sale?" I knew the answer and I knew without a doubt that our adventure was about to begin. My name is Wendy (Volk) Bartok and I'm a 1986 graduate of Elk Lake High School.
Our breaded boneless wings are all white meat chicken, tossed in your favorite Anthony's wing sauce. New York Style Pizza Each New York Style Pizza is made with our own hand-tossed dough, topped with homemade pizza sauce and our special blend of quality cheeses and spices. However, other ingredients in our restaurant and pizzeria contain gluten, and are prepared on shared equipment.
Salads All Salads include iceberg lettuce and romaine mix with tomato, cucumber, black olive, onion, croutons, and your choice of dressing. Extra dressing $.60 each. 6 Homemade pizza dough knots baked, then tossed with butter, fresh garlic, and parmesan cheese. 4 Egg roll wrappers stuffed with mozzarella cheese and pepperoni, served with our homemade tomato sauce for dipping.
Tender elbow macaroni cooked in a homemade cheese sauce, topped with shredded cheddar cheese and buttered bread crumbs. Prepared with a blend of ricotta, parmesan, and mozzarella, baked with our homemade tomato sauce and melted mozzarella cheese. Anthony's own hand-pounded chicken breast and mushrooms sauteed in butter, marsala wine, and spices.
Reviews (7)
Ro Forrest
Ro Forrest
Oct 30, 2021
Report
Just driving by and decided to stop for lunch. Ordered burgers and some of those delish garlic fries. Great burgers! And those garlic fries ..you get your money's worth. Noticed freezers full of prepared food for popping in the oven at home. The folks behind the counter are friendly, helpful and pleasant.. Don't miss this experience.
Daniel Anthony
Daniel Anthony
Sep 26, 2021
Report
Good little pizza shop for small little town in South Montrose good prices all around good food
Linda Short
Linda Short
Jul 23, 2021
Report
Great service food and service. Didn't realize they didn't have dine in but they offer picnic tables which was nice.
Alphascrub
Alphascrub
Apr 25, 2021
Report
Pizza is ok. Prices are moderate for local restaurants. Their wings and none pizza food is honest better than the pizza. They do off a cold section where you can purchase decent quality meals to heat up or finish cooking yourself. Their daily menu options aren't bad either. I would honestly rate it higher if you could order more of its menu after 2pm.
Steven Yetter
Steven Yetter
Jul 30, 2020
Report
Great food and prices. Their menu offers a variety of dishes and they have some of the best pizza in the area. The people there are extremely friendly and make you feel welcome from the moment you walk in until the time they say goodbye and tell you to "watch your step". I love this place.
David S. Channin Md
David S. Channin Md
Jan 04, 2020
Report
Small, clean, quiet, neighborhood Italian restaurant with pretty darn good food. Large portions for the most part; available in half servings, too. Very fast and friendly service. BYOB! Modest prices. Very popular with the locals.
Vera Scroggins Progressive Media
Vera Scroggins Progressive Media
Aug 10, 2019
Report
Great menu, prices..great service...fed
15 of us right on the spot...thanks, Anthony's...