Sumner Insurance Services
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
When we say we're "Your Comprehensive Source for Insurance Needs" we mean it! We offer individual and business insurance for all kinds of needs including Medicare, Health, Life, Farms, Cars, Homes, Renter's, Churches, Events, Travel and much more! We have virtual, phone and in-person appointments available.

In 2022, we'll see lots of changes to Medicare Advantage Plans (Part C) and Prescription Drug Plans (Part D). Our team can check your eligibility, walk you through plan comparisons, and give you tips for choosing a plan. As a family-owned business, we have served the central Missouri community with quality insurance products and valuable customer service for 3 generations.
Services
This insurance company came recommended to me by a family member. I worked with Scott Venable as my agent. Every issue is resolved immediately, he is quick to respond to any questions that I have. You can tell when dealing with him he is doing his job because he truly cares about his customers. We have been with Sumner Insurance for over 50 years and have ALWAYS been treated very fairly.
We proudly offer several of the highest quality insurance companies in the business. We present many options so that we can provide you with competitive quotes for the quality insurance. This allows us to help you get the insurance you want, while also saving you money! Below is a sampling of insurance companies we carry.
Don't miss your chance to enroll in a Medicare plan for 2022. New Medicare Advantage Plans (Part C) and Prescription Drug Plans (Part D) have been released. To get an accurate idea of which Medicare plans will fit your needs, our team needs a list of your prescription medications. Medicare health and drug plans can make changes each year-things like premiums, copays, coinsurance, which drugs, doctors and pharmacies are in the network.
Don't miss your chance to enroll in a Medicare plan for 2022. New Medicare Advantage Plans (Part C) and Prescription Drug Plans (Part D) have been released. To get an accurate idea of which Medicare plans will fit your needs, our team needs a list of your prescription medications. SilverSneakers is a health and fitness program designed for adults 65+ that's included with many Medicare Plans.
A Medicare Supplement Insurance (Medigap) policy, sold by private companies, can help pay some of the health care costs that Original Medicare doesn't cover, like copayments, coinsurance, and deductibles. A Medicare Supplement policy helps pay health costs that aren't covered by your Original Medicare.
Reviews (10)
Eddie Brown
Eddie Brown
Nov 03, 2021
Report
My wife and I have been clients of the Sumners for 31 years. We were first with Caleb's grandfather, Jim, and then we were with Caleb's father, Keith. I have known Caleb since he was about 12 years old. I watched him grow up and mature. He was respectful and responsible as a child, and as an adult, he is the sort of person that I want handling my important insurance decisions involving my healthcare as well as my annuities. Caleb and his staff and associates are knowledgeable, competent, friendly, helpful, caring, and of the highest integrity. I cannot imagine considering any other group to handle
Rebecca Tiffany
Rebecca Tiffany
Apr 23, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness, Value
Scott made navigating the chaos that is health insurance look easy. It was even a pleasant experience. I am very greatful for his help. I feel like he bent over backwards to fit me into his schedule.
Tammy Persinger
Tammy Persinger
Apr 14, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
This insurance company came recommended to me by a family member. I worked with Scott Venable as my agent. Every issue is resolved immediately, he is quick to respond to any questions that I have. You can tell when dealing with him he is doing his job because he truly cares about his customers.
Dale Leisenheimer
Dale Leisenheimer
Apr 02, 2021
Report
Positive: Responsiveness, Value
Always there when you need them. Very friendly, helpful staff.
Carla Helmig
Carla Helmig
Mar 30, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Value
Sumner insurance worked with me promptly after retirement to get the best insurance for me to fit my needs
Ashly McGovern
Ashly McGovern
Mar 29, 2021
Report
Id highly reccoment going to see Paul at Sumner insurance Very honest and trustable.
Jodie Heck
Jodie Heck
Mar 27, 2021
Report
We have been with Sumner Insurance for over 50 years and have ALWAYS been treated very Fairley .
Caleb is our 3rd generation Sumner agent . Their word is their bond ..
Alan Brotherton
Alan Brotherton
Mar 18, 2021
Report
Great customer service and prices from a local independent insurance company.
Linda Maddix
Linda Maddix
Mar 16, 2021
Report
My friend Laura who works for Sumner Insurance learned that I needed some help with cost for a medical procedure and jumped in to help me. I wasn't even a client of Sumner Insurance! I later talked to her about the new Medicare plans and she invited me to come in to speak to one of their agents. Seeing I knew Paul Bergman through his help with another friend, I went in to see Paul. He set me up with a wonderful new Medicare plan that saved me money each month. I then mentioned about my father and Paul invited me to get my father to come in. My father was on a plan that was costing him much money
Vernon Gage
Vernon Gage
Sep 24, 2020
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Very nice people at Sumner Insurance. We are very pleased with their service.