Thank you for stopping by Eagles Pizza's website. If you are planning a graduation party or corporate lunch meeting, Eagles Pizza can help. Visit the catering page for our large party menu. Located in the heart of New Albany, Ohio, our restaurant offers a great variety of pizza, subs, sandwiches, dinners, salads and desserts in a friendly, casual atmosphere.
Grab some great food to go or dine in at Eagles Villa Pizza. Since 1971 we have served thousands of pizzas and sub sandwiches to area families. Whether it was a local farmer grabbing a bag of subs during harvest, or a coach picking up a dozen pizzas for a post-game celebration, Eagles has been here for you.
Grab some great food to go or dine in at Eagles Villa Pizza. Since 1971 we have served thousands of pizzas and sub sandwiches to area families. Whether it was a local farmer grabbing a bag of subs during harvest, or a coach picking up a dozen pizzas for a post-game celebration, Eagles has been here for you.
Services
Mexican-style sauce covered with blended cheeses and seasoned hamburger cooked till crisp. Then topped with more cheese, fresh shredded lettuce, and diced tomatoes. Taco sauce packets and sour cream available also. Bake-At-Home Pizzas - our traditional Large pizza prepared on a specially designed pan ready for the oven.
Eagles Villa Pizza offers catering food for your next party or event. Our catering food is perfect for graduation parties, rehearsal dinners, weddings, Fourth of July parties, family reunions, high school reunions, picnics, or just about any social gathering. Give us a call and will provide the food.
Our pizza has been a part of New Albany and enjoyed for over 40 years. As the business grew it became apparent that a dining room would be needed to accommodate the already well known foods. In 1847 the present site located on the corner of Main Street and High Street was first purchased by John McCurdy from Noble Landon who platted the then fledgling town ten years earlier.
Reviews (19)
Robert B.
Jan 30, 2022
Report
Always great pizza at Eagles Pizza. The prices are great people are great they even have cakes from rush bakery so if you need a birthday cake they have them in all flavors. If you have yet to try this location in New Albany you are missing out for sure they have something for everyone on their menu and it's kind of like eating at an historical pizza place where people still act the way they did before the pandemic. Thank God for a place like eagles pizza still in this world
Julie H.
Dec 27, 2021
Report
Macie P.
Dec 22, 2021
Report
I always have a great experience at Eagles for takeout. I actually have never dined in, but I would like to at some point. I love thin crust pizzas, and eagles does a great job with theirs. The crust is flaky and crispy. I love asking for it well done and having the extra crispy pepperonis. Overall, Eagles has had timely service with good quality pizza each time that I have visited.
Nik S.
Nov 26, 2021
Report
This is one of those small places that someone recommended a few years ago and it was amazing. I have never been disappointed with anything I have ordered. This is the first place I ever tried a bacon pizza and it has yet to be matched. The crust is great and there's not too much and not too little. It's a good place for a dinner out with friends or family.
Dylan S.
Sep 21, 2021
Report
Working at a job site with a customer, they swore by this pizza and these subs, they were not wrong! The sandwiches were so flavorful and huge! Not pictured was the delicious meat lovers type pizza. It was on a slightly thick crust so everything stayed on the pizza. Bummed out i'm only here for a day because i'd love to try another pizza from there!
Alexia A.
Sep 05, 2021
Report
We just moved to the neighborhood and wanted to try all the pizzas to find out local favorite. Unfortunately it was not Eagles. The crust was kind of hard ,tasted old. The cheese on the pizza was thick and oily. It reminded me of the pizza we'd get from the school cafeteria for lunch. The gluten free crust wasn't the best we've had- just kind of gummy. As for the flavor it was fine. Not awful just not great. All in all, for $33 we were pretty disappointed and would likely not return.
Trish P.
Sep 02, 2021
Report
Tanna K.
Aug 10, 2021
Report
We have a list of local pizza shops that we want to try. Eagles Pizza has been on there for awhile and I'm not sure why we waited so long to get here. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza and it did not dissappoint. The pizza was cheesy and the pepperoni was crispy. The crust was crackery but not too thin! The perfect pizza in my opinion and it has moved into the leader position on our list! Also, the customer service was great and the wait was only 15-20 minutes. My only complaint would be the box was very flimsy and I was afraid of dropping it.
Gamer G.
May 28, 2021
Report
Jack S. M.
May 16, 2021
Report
Lisa K.
Mar 26, 2021
Report
This is our go to place for a taco pizza. Today, we did step out of the box and ordered a cheese pizza. It was good and had the perfect amount of sauce. I still think their taco pizza is their best pizza though. Also, the frosted sugar cookies are absolutely amazing. Omg the frosting and the cookie are always cooked perfectly and the right amount of frosting. Best taco pizza in the area.
Jason T.
Jan 01, 2021
Report
Went with a 15" classic pepperoni and cheese and Italian sub. The crust is somewhat between thin and thick but doesn't sag, with the expected amount of sauce, not dry or soggy. The pepperoni could use a little more spice to it, but it's still good and you can taste it. The subs are pretty good too. Enough meat without being overwhelming, topped with provolone, tomato, banana peppers, crisp lettuce and crisp onion on a toasted sesame bun. I like the fact that they provide the dressing on the side for a couple reasons. 1). You decide how much dressing you want. 2). It won't get
Suzanne P.
Dec 23, 2020
Report
Nancy K.
Jul 19, 2020
Report
I was initially skeptical of the good reviews because this is the type of place that locals will rave about but out of towners will think it's just ok. Overall, it's a solid 3.5 starts but the order completion speed and staff friendliness had me round up. The pizza was tasty on top but the bottom seemed a few minutes under baked. Not raw but not crispy either. The hot potatoes were a good app for only $4 and they had a good spice level. I wish they served them with ranch vs. ketchup but maybe that's too picky. Overall, it was a good pizza experience but not a great one.
Dia P.
Jun 18, 2020
Report
We ordered the smothered meatballs, garlic bread and cheese and some subs for the girls. The pizza was amazing. Not terribly greasy. The crust was my favorite part: We ordered pep and sausage. The sausage is the crumbly kind. The garlic bread and cheese was amazing. The meatballs were just ok. Nothing spectacular but good. The counter people we pleasant and the red x's on the floor were an added plus. They were wearing masks and had hand sanitizer available.
Definitely will be back.
Definitely will be back.
Charles D.
May 16, 2020
Report
Updated review: I've been here many times now. The Pizza is consistently excellent. The subs are HUGE, and flavorful! I'm not going to be able to add much about the pizza.
One underrated menu item is the chicken wings. The sauce is your typical Buffalo sauce, tangy and spicy without burning your face off. Where they stand out is the amount of meat that is on the wings. They are plump, and juicy, and yet still fall off the bone. The balance between wing and sauce was perfect. Not doused in sauce; but, not dry. There was plenty of extra sauce in the bottom of the tray to dip your fries
One underrated menu item is the chicken wings. The sauce is your typical Buffalo sauce, tangy and spicy without burning your face off. Where they stand out is the amount of meat that is on the wings. They are plump, and juicy, and yet still fall off the bone. The balance between wing and sauce was perfect. Not doused in sauce; but, not dry. There was plenty of extra sauce in the bottom of the tray to dip your fries
Joshua C.
Jan 17, 2020
Report
A friend brought me here speaking of pizza greatness.
In the land of Ohio and Cbus where pizza chains large and small abound, I was curious and skeptical.
But, I was impressed!
It was a filling and fluffy yet light pizza. Good balance and tasty enough that my wife gobbled it down as soon as I brought leftovers home.
Very interested to go back and try some of their other foods as they have more than just pizza.
Definitely a staple of the local neighborhood in New Albany and filled with historic pictures throughout the establishment. Always good to see charm and tradition.
PRO TIP: afterwards
In the land of Ohio and Cbus where pizza chains large and small abound, I was curious and skeptical.
But, I was impressed!
It was a filling and fluffy yet light pizza. Good balance and tasty enough that my wife gobbled it down as soon as I brought leftovers home.
Very interested to go back and try some of their other foods as they have more than just pizza.
Definitely a staple of the local neighborhood in New Albany and filled with historic pictures throughout the establishment. Always good to see charm and tradition.
PRO TIP: afterwards
Lyndsay B.
Dec 10, 2019
Report
A hidden gem! We're new to the area and had been going to Donato's for gluten-free pizza, until we found Eagles. Love their menu and all the different types of pizza they offer. Plus, it's always great supporting a local business!
The gluten-free taco pizza was exceptional. Don't forget to ask for taco sauce and sour cream on the side! We also got a Hawaiian pizza with regular crust, which I wasn't able to try, but it looked delicious.
Can't wait to go back and try more of their pizzas soon!
The gluten-free taco pizza was exceptional. Don't forget to ask for taco sauce and sour cream on the side! We also got a Hawaiian pizza with regular crust, which I wasn't able to try, but it looked delicious.
Can't wait to go back and try more of their pizzas soon!
Malini S.
Jun 24, 2019
Report
My husband grew up in Johnstown and used to come to Eagles all the time when he was a kid. We were in the area and he really wanted me to experience it.
Pros:
-super cute nostalgic vibe
-loved the smothered meatballs!
-good prices - the meatballs were less than $5 for decent sized portion - yum!
-food came out really fast!
-friendly service
Cons:
-I wasn't in love with the pizza. It wasn't bad, but it wasn't great. Everything just sort of lacked flavor. I know pizza is one of those things where people are particular - so for reference, I love carfagna's pizza, donatos
Pros:
-super cute nostalgic vibe
-loved the smothered meatballs!
-good prices - the meatballs were less than $5 for decent sized portion - yum!
-food came out really fast!
-friendly service
Cons:
-I wasn't in love with the pizza. It wasn't bad, but it wasn't great. Everything just sort of lacked flavor. I know pizza is one of those things where people are particular - so for reference, I love carfagna's pizza, donatos
